zeogold: In my opinion, all games that are billed as "adventure" should be the point-and-click/puzzle-solving type [..]
The problem is that the classification on this is a pretty broad one compared to game genres such as FPS [..]
I never liked the "official" genre names.
They're super generic.
For example:
- "Adventure" could mean almost ANY game with a story. O_o
It's hard to summarize a genre properly, but wouldn't "mystery solving" or "clue solving" make more sense, at least? (or something else).
- "Point&click" is meaningless by now, as the mouse is common elsewhere (RTS,RPG,puzzles,etc).
- also "FPS" isn't great.. Rail Shooters or Flight Simulators are "First Person Shooters" too, but they're not the same thing.
- "Action Adventure" is even more generic.
- etc..
The modern mix of genres, then, complicates everything.