It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionThe Puzzlemaster's Court(567 posts)(567 posts)
(567 posts)
Pages:
1
5
10
15
20
25
26
27
28
29
30
35
38
This is my favourite topic
Posted January 11, 2016
avatar
popperik: Well, the new piece of evidence doesn't contradict my theory so I'd like to lock my verdict: Not guilty. My explanation can be found earlier in the thread:

[i]So, the second robber wanted to ditch the wounded / dead robber's body in the well.

Then we have Whitemane, who was trying to wash his clothes after a small kitchen accident, but the washing machine wouldn't work. He tried the kitchen sink, but no water there, so he decides to stroll over to the well on the other side of the field, where he notices the body and decides to carry it home, because he recognises the body as the travelling salesman. Then he gets spotted by the workers, etc... [/i]

I'm also gonna be quite busy this week and while I'll try to keep an eye on the thread, just assume I'm voting for the majority. In case of ties, I'm voting for the one with the shorter name.
C'mon, ABSOLUTELY noone that lives in this century goes to an abandoned well to wash their clothes because the water is out in their house! Not even old bear hunters like Whitemane! You're all voting for his innocence, but I KNOW he's guilty, I'm just undecided on WHAT he's guilty of. I have a hunch the autopsy report will clear things up.
Post edited January 11, 2016 by sunshinecorp
Posted January 11, 2016
avatar
popperik: Well, the new piece of evidence doesn't contradict my theory so I'd like to lock my verdict: Not guilty. My explanation can be found earlier in the thread:

[i]So, the second robber wanted to ditch the wounded / dead robber's body in the well.

Then we have Whitemane, who was trying to wash his clothes after a small kitchen accident, but the washing machine wouldn't work. He tried the kitchen sink, but no water there, so he decides to stroll over to the well on the other side of the field, where he notices the body and decides to carry it home, because he recognises the body as the travelling salesman. Then he gets spotted by the workers, etc... [/i]

I'm also gonna be quite busy this week and while I'll try to keep an eye on the thread, just assume I'm voting for the majority. In case of ties, I'm voting for the one with the shorter name.
avatar
sunshinecorp: C'mon, ABSOLUTELY noone that lives in this century goes to an abandoned well to wash their clothes because the water is out in their house! Not even old bear hunters like Whitemane! You're all voting for his innocence, but I KNOW he's guilty, I'm just undecided on WHAT he's guilty of. I have a hunch the autopsy report will clear things up.
Watch it on the bold, there. I keep track of those for votes, but I know it wasn't your intention and will let you off the hook.
And by the way, he's on trial for robbery here. If you think he's guilty of something else, that's not the place of this particular jury. Vote on this case only.
Posted January 11, 2016
*plays banjo*

We need to *hic*.. release the guy and put *hic*... the puzzlemaster in lockup.
Posted January 11, 2016
wutz a pozzle marster?
Posted January 11, 2016
avatar
mikopotato: *plays banjo*

We need to *hic*.. release the guy and put *hic*... the puzzlemaster in lockup.
Now yer talkin', got any more of that stuff?
Posted January 11, 2016
avatar
mikopotato: *plays banjo*

We need to *hic*.. release the guy and put *hic*... the puzzlemaster in lockup.
Well... I agree with the second part.
I also vote to lock up the Puzzlemaster.
Posted January 11, 2016
avatar
zeogold:
Didn't teach us anything new, really. Only confirming what was already speculated since Day 1...

Really doubt the last two evidences will make a difference now, but who knows.

Gonna go with Evidence from the Car.

avatar
soxy_lady: wutz a pozzle marster?
Who let this drunk Gypsy in?

Don't tell me she's the defendants wife !?

avatar
sunshinecorp: Well... I agree with the second part.
I also vote to lock up the Puzzlemaster.
Agreed, Lock up the Puzzlemaster and throw away the keys.
Post edited January 11, 2016 by Habanerose
Posted January 11, 2016
Lock up the Puzzlemaster!
Posted January 11, 2016
avatar
mikopotato: *plays banjo*

We need to *hic*.. release the guy and put *hic*... the puzzlemaster in lockup.
avatar
EndreWhiteMane: Now yer talkin', got any more of that stuff?
um yup, *hic* *passes hte half empty bottle*

NOW WHERE IS THE MUZZLEPASTER!?
Posted January 11, 2016
avatar
EndreWhiteMane: Now yer talkin', got any more of that stuff?
avatar
mikopotato: um yup, *hic* *passes hte half empty bottle*

NOW WHERE IS THE MUZZLEPASTER!?
Dunno, mumbled sumthin' about 'dang jury' and moseyed out.
Posted January 11, 2016
*scratches head*
Posted January 11, 2016
avatar
ashwald: *scratches head*
Agreed. Our jury doesn't seem particularly impartial, and I'm starting to doubt they ever were in the first place.

Evidence from the Car
Posted January 11, 2016
avatar
zeogold:
avatar
Habanerose: Didn't teach us anything new, really. Only confirming what was already speculated since Day 1...
I did warn about this, you know.

avatar
soxy_lady:
No being drunk in the audience!
I'm only letting the jury get away with that.

avatar
madth3: Lock up the Puzzlemaster!
The only reason I'm letting myself get locked up is for my own protection.
...although that's looking pretty reasonable right about now, considering this jury.
Posted January 11, 2016
Evidence from the Car then from the Autopsy.

I have my mind made up for 80%, but I want to hear out all the evidence if it is possible.
Posted January 12, 2016
avatar
zeogold: The only reason I'm letting myself get locked up is for my own protection.
...although that's looking pretty reasonable right about now, considering this jury.
I'd say throw the book at him, but I'm not sure we're bright enough to read an actual book.

Perhaps someone has a leaflet we could throw at him? No?

A take-out menu? Yes, indeed. Throw the take-out menu at him!

As they say.
Pages:
1
5
10
15
20
25
26
27
28
29
30
35
38
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionThe Puzzlemaster's Court(567 posts)(567 posts)
(567 posts)