mrkgnao: What about my Mystery Game Variant Giveaway where the prize was a game of my choice from the winner's public wishlist?
Third point in rule II.
Assuming the winner meets all the requirements, the question would be whether their public wishlist is a "small collection" or not. I'll judge it on a case by case basis. In most cases it should be fine, except in cases when someone puts every game an its mother on their wishlist.
Of course I'll have to trust the entrant to be honest and enter for a game from their wishlist from the time your GA was made. i.e. not add a game to it now just to enter for it in my GA.