Understood. I think I'll just drop it then, for the sake of fairness. Anyway, Redshirt (Steam) is available in either case, if anyone's interested! :)

Sorry, I am forum novice, pleased to meet you :[

I like what you're saying, though- it's something to consider!

Hey i am not a regular forum poster either, but i just dont like a thread with too much rules which you need to read through before typing anything. I just like the thread to dont have much rules except.
Just take 1 gift 1
Gifter decides if he's okey with it.

I have an extra key that I just dispatched. ;)

I noticed and upvoted your post. That's true generosity! My hat's off to you. :)
Hopefully your offer will be appreciated.

So, main problem, as i understood, is that while Desura\Steam keys is mostly comes from various cheap or not that cheap bundles, GOG keys, usually, is keys purchased for real $$$ (even if they was on sale at purchase moment) and there is much bigger natural value in them. There was some bundles\deals offering GOG keys (IndieGameStand mostly and, unexpectedly, IndieGala sometimes), but its very uncommon overall.

P.S. Lets all dig in more into gifting then arguing. So i first shall shut up.

This thread will either turn into a ninja or trading thread but the idea is interesting nonetheless.

Yeah, but if someone is making a gift out of being generous, they will feel weird all of a sudden saying, no your gift is shit, I don't want to proceed. I think once the thread is, like, a few weeks old everything will settle into place.

We wouldn't have the rules if there weren't people who want to prey on the generosity of others.

I don't think so, there are plenty of bundles you can get for cheap, is what I mean.

(Dammit, make me mute), but there is still interesting question - can QUANTITY compensate QUALITY? If someone feel like his offer inferior, is it ok to add more stuff?

Ok, i see. Guess, its really not easy to prevent gift for gift from degradation to trading, as BlackDawn said.

I already asked this and apparently that is considered trading...

Since the actual giveaways are risking to get lost among the rules discussion, I've taken the liberty to update LoboBlanco's post - I hope (s)he doesn't mind! :)

Yeah maybe, time will tell.
However, the value of a game is highly subjective. So for one person a game maybe shit, but not for another.

I think what cmdr means, is that someone could purchase some bundles for a dollar each and have get ~5 for that dollar and can practically snatch away all the games without spending money. It's not really about a game being "shit" or good or anything.

Aaanyway, to get this thread back to the topic, let's add Waking Mars to the mix, (again for Steam).

I would like it, I just entered Crusader Kings Complete into the fray...

Edit: Thanks a lot!