Breja: Bah. I love all the Star Trek movies. That's right, all of them. Some are genuinely great cinema (Wrath of Khan, First Contact, Motion Picture Director's Cut) and some are just fun (Voyage Home) and the rest are good-to-great action/adventure movies, and I even like the much maligned ones like Final Frontier or Generations. For all their faults they explore interesting themes and sci-fi ideas and get the characters well. And have great music. Even Nemesis and Into Darkness (in my opinion those are the two weakest ones) are still not really bad movies, they are still entertaining and for the most part well made. Is there a lot of problems and nitpicks? Sure. But I still had a good time watching them.
I guess for a hardocre Trek fan I'm actually pretty flexible about what Trek can be, and I'm especially forgiving of the movies, as they are not Trek's "natural habitat" anyway. So if they work out as great Trek it's an added bonus, but as long as it's an entertaining new adventure with the Trek characters, that's really all I'm asking for.
EDIT: Oh, and as for The Final Frontier-
this is probably my favourite scene of all the Trek movies. Everything and everyone here is simply superb.
Is the director's cut of the Motion picture much improved compared to the original? The version I've seen is terribly boring. It's also strange how they basically copied the plot of the TOS episode with that space probe Nomad. Pretty lame.