RailRoad Tycoon XXVI.

I'm betting this one might be nigh impossible. Not that I know anything about it, but I'm guessing there's Kiss licenses involved that would make a release of a bit more difficult.

I wish for these oldies first:
- Civilization 1,2,3
- Myth 1,2
- Gta 1

Then, in theory:
- Civilization 4,5
- Borderlands 1,2
- Bioshock 1,2,i
- Gta 5
- Max Payne 1,3

True...Kiss members are so wealth hungry (mostly Gene Simmons) that you don't know how they'll react to a re-release of their game.
Of course they'd love the extra $, but they might disagree on how much.

And thanks Grargar for the Psygnosis/Sony tip. We can only hope! They might be from the early 3D graphics era, but they have atmosphere!

I believe you wanted to say Max Payne 3?

you are probably right
along with a insultingly high price tag for the games on offer

Ah woops, yes.

Wishful thinking, but I'd love to see XCom - Enemy Unknown + Enemy Within and the first 2 Bioshock games, XCom 2 and Bioshock: Infinite would be great as well but those two games releasing on gog right now is even more unlikely.