yyahoo: tinyE is a poor example. He is an antagonist. He has gone on sprees where he posts intentionally offensive things and begs people to downrep him. He simply enjoys the attention.
Except all those reasons you gave are why tinyE is the
best example. He is subject to both having his posts downrated because of their content
and because someone is downrating his posts regardless of their content.
yyahoo: Regardless, I honestly interpret *both* of your examples as popularity contests. Sometimes it's an *un*popularity contest, but that's the same thing. In no way can I see any of this as harassment.
I can unravel your argument of "it's just a popularity contest" here in one simple statement.
It only takes one person to not like you.
Really.. just imagine if
I decided I didn't like you and felt it was okay to do it. I have the ability to downrate (and keep low-rated) every post you have made or will make on your account in a maximally efficient way... with little initial effort and no ongoing effort at all. Within 2 months, I'd have your rep in the negatives.
It isn't a popularity contest when the one person with the biggest guns wins.
yyahoo: It's a little meaningless number by your username.
Except it isn't a meaningless number because there are some people here who give it meaning. It gets used to stop people from entering groups and contests. That's a meaning. Enough people use it that GOG added it to the PM page due to
the community requesting it. That's a meaning. Some people, in a trade, will demand the other person send their side of the trade first because
they have low rep. That's a meaning. In most cases, people have just flat out
earned that little number under their name (for the record, I'm don't feel like I'm one of them :P) and for some, that is meaning enough.
yyahoo: That number going up or going down cannot possibly be interpreted as harassment.
I've already stated that it isn't the number going down that is interpreted as harrassment. It is the abuse of the post rating system
against a specific user that is the harassment.
xyem: <Xyem tips his hand>
wpegg: My friend, I feel you tipped your hand here too early. You were only supposed to blow the bloody doors off! To be more specific, your stats would be better if it were a simple stat gathering project, rather than something with an agenda.
Maybe I've misunderstood, I am quite drunk...
I don't understand why having an agenda would affect the statistics I get back from this.
I'm not looking to prove anything one way or another. Just providing a service and mentioned that if the data does point out something unusual, that I might investigate further and why.