It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
tremere110: I don't think thanking the people that defend your country is overly patriotic or worship.
avatar
supplementscene: In what sense are the American military that invade sovereign countries, 'defending your country'?
Again, I'm not defending the States, but I don't think someone from the U.K. should be criticizing anyone for imperialism. :P
avatar
DubConqueror: But the funny thing is, America hasn't been attacked since 1941 Japan made an attack on US owned islands. Ever since when America was at war, the US was the attacker.

In the Netherlands, the last time there was massive saying thank you's to soldiers was in 1944 and 1945 to American, British, Canadian and the Dutch 'Princess Irene Brigade' soldiers.
avatar
tinyE: Well there was 9-11 but who's counting. :P
And the attack on the U. S. S. Cole. But hey. Murica are always the aggressors.
avatar
blotunga: Wanting to defend your country is also an american thing. I wouldn't give a rat's ass about my country. Actually I would welcome it if let's say Germany invaded us and cleaned up the corrupt system. But they aren't interested in conquest nowadays.
avatar
anothername: We tried recently, but the Slovenian army chased us off.
You probably thought it was the infamous balkan death squads. Understandable.

Next time, please remember to thank us for not murdering you.
Post edited January 12, 2017 by Titanium
avatar
supplementscene: In what sense are the American military that invade sovereign countries, 'defending your country'?
avatar
tinyE: Again, I'm not defending the States, but I don't think someone from the U.K. should be criticizing anyone for imperialism. :P
To be fair, quite a few European countries had imperialist tendencies, but much of that disappeared a long time ago. :-)
For Germany it's mostly indifference towards members of the armed forces. Certainly never witnessed anyone randomly approaching a soldier and thanking him. You'd be hard pressed to find them in any case. I can't remember the last time I've actually seen somebody in uniform.
Post edited January 13, 2017 by k4ZE106
avatar
supplementscene: When was the last time America was invaded and when was the last time your army defended you against said threat successfully?
There was 1812...

...but after that little bonfire you chaps had I'm not sure we can exactly count that one as a "success."
There is also March 19th 2010, a day which will live in infamy, when we were ruthlessly and without provocation [url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_World_2.0#/media/File:Myworld2.jpg]attacked by Canada[/url].
Post edited January 13, 2017 by tinyE
I haven't been in the army myself, but I think something like this is pretty uncommon in Germany. It would have been more likely back during the Cold war when there was conscription and the Bundeswehr (back then fairly large, at about 500 000 men iirc) served as a deterrent against the Eastern bloc....though there was also a very large pacifist movement back in the 1980s (some of that pretty militant with slogans like "Soldaten sind Mörder" = "soldiers are murderers").
Nowadays the army is badly underfunded, quite small, its materiel rotting away and there's no prestige to it; conscription has ended and because of this links to the wider public have decreased; and what remains of the military is engaged in unpopular no-win interventions like Afghanistan that politicans have never properly explained to the public (and for which the more deranged lefties regard soldiers as war criminals).
So no, I can't imagine German soldiers being thanked by members of the public...it must be a very frustrating job, I don't envy them. Pretty bad situation imo.
avatar
tinyE: Again, I'm not defending the States, but I don't think someone from the U.K. should be criticizing anyone for imperialism. :P
avatar
blakstar: To be fair, quite a few European countries had imperialist tendencies, but much of that disappeared a long time ago. :-)
Not that long ago: from 1945-1949 the Netherlands waged war on the new independent state of Indonesia.
Post edited January 13, 2017 by DubConqueror
It's kinda weird. What I see is people going all rah-rah-rah for recently returned soldiers or recently discharged vets, or old people who are about to die. If you're in the middle ground - that is, a vet but out for a while - nobody seems to give a crap.
avatar
blakstar: To be fair, quite a few European countries had imperialist tendencies, but much of that disappeared a long time ago. :-)
avatar
DubConqueror: Not that long ago: from 1945-1949 the Netherlands waged war on the new independent state of Indonesia.
Well, I did say "much", and I guess "a long time" can be relative -- almost 70 years isn't that recent by my standards, but I guess some people might regard it as such. :-)
avatar
tinyE: This went downhill fast. XD

I'm going to start a thread called "Mustard or Ketchup" and put a timer on how long it takes to devolve into a flame war. :P
Only sweet mustard, please!
avatar
tinyE: This went downhill fast. XD

I'm going to start a thread called "Mustard or Ketchup" and put a timer on how long it takes to devolve into a flame war. :P
avatar
Maxvorstadt: Only sweet mustard, please!
That is a very situational question. Sweet mustard for original bavarian Weißwurst; everything else is a major crime. For Leberkäse on the other hand medium or spicy mustard as with regular cooked and sometimes grilled sausage. Fries & Burgers get the Ketchup treatment as does sometimes grilled sausage.
avatar
GothikOrk: Are you frequently approached and thanked for your service, or is that more of an American thing?
What service? We have a compulsory military service here (or one can choose to serve also outside the army in civil service). I became a second lieutenant ("vänrikki") during the year I was there in an arm that I don't think exists anymore (coastal artillery; they've been replaced with some kind of missile and rocket systems now I think).

It is not like I have been abroad fighting commies or nazis or kinks or yanks, in fact I've never got to shoot anybody. However, those old farts who were fighting during the WWII (against Russia) are generally highly regarded in here, there's an annual nation-wide money collection for them etc., but they must be like 90 years old by now and getting fewer and fewer in numbers. We haven't been in any war after that, no Vietnam or Afghanistan.
Post edited January 13, 2017 by timppu
avatar
Maxvorstadt: Only sweet mustard, please!
avatar
anothername: That is a very situational question. Sweet mustard for original bavarian Weißwurst; everything else is a major crime. For Leberkäse on the other hand medium or spicy mustard as with regular cooked and sometimes grilled sausage. Fries & Burgers get the Ketchup treatment as does sometimes grilled sausage.
Ketchup and Mayo for Pommes.