AlexTerranova: I find
reCAPTCHA and similar "services" much more annoying, than spam itself.
I very clearly didn't suggest it for everyone, every time a post is made. After 9 years here, you likely have enough posts and bought games that it wouldn't affect you.
Just as you need to deal with reCAPTCHA when resetting your password or trying to redeem a code without being logged in, it should be there as a roadblock to stop spam under certain conditions. Total posts made and bought games were my preferred metrics, but if some other stats would work better, I'm fine with that.
AlexTerranova: Yes, it discourages anyone from posting anything, effectively turning forums into a field of desolation. ;)
You think new users would prefer dealing with pages and pages worth of spam, instead of reCAPTCHA for a while?