In that case, I guess it wasn't a total waste.

My total haul, some stuff I wanted but I think I am done.

We are the Dwarves
Throne of Darkness
Stories Untold
Pilot Brothers
Meridian: New World
Darksiders II: Deathinitive Edition
Bombshell
Metro 2033 Redux
Pinstripe
Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons
Metro: Last Light Redux
Saints Row: Gat out of Hell
Imperium Galactica
Darksiders Warmastered Edition
Skyshine's BEDLAM Deluxe Edition
Her Story
Republique
Saints Row IV: Game of the Century Edition

I bought nine pinata - four duplicates, but that's my own fault for having 1,754 Steam games (and a few on other platforms).

That said, the ones I did not yet have look half-decent:

Duplicates
King's Bounty: The Legend
Kyn
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. - Shadow of Chernobyl (actually, this one is triplicate!)
SoulBringer *DUPLICATE


Star Wolves 3: Civil War
Drox Operative
Dead Synchronicity: Tomorrow Comes Today
Political Animals
Gratuitous Space Battles 2

Not sure about the gratuitous one, but the others tend towards decent reviews. Political Animals was one I had not heard of, but would probably have gone onto my wishlist if I had.

Check your PMs, and thanks GOG for converting the pinata!

I bought 4 and received the following:

Capitalism 2 (wont play it myself but it looks like a building game and my 9yr son loves them. He still plays sim city for snes)

Conquests of Camelot (at this point i was getting worried that i wasted my money)

Baldurs gate enhanced edition (i played the original edition for many hours but never beat it. One of disks became scratched so bad i couldn't finish. Looking forward to a replay)

Blackguards Special Edition (I love turn based strategy so this suits me.)

Overall happy with my games only 1 big dud but that's how gambling works.

Yesterday: Holy Potatoes! A Weapon Shop?!
Today: Bombshell

So for the 4 pinatas I bought I got

RIME
Capitalism 2
Hard West
Dreamfall Chapters: The Final Cut

Not a bad haul really.

Another go, got....

Randal's Monday
Deponia 3: Goodbye Deponia
Pilot Brothers
Depths of Peril
Democracy 3: Africa
Throne of Darkness
Caesar II
Caesar™ IV
Kim
The Whispered World: Special Edition
------------------- added more----------------
Caesar
Shivah
Tetrobot and Co.
Enter the Gungeon
BLACKHOLE
Caravan
The Inner World
1954 Alcatraz
SOMA
Slave Zero
--------------- again -----------------------
Space Rangers: Quest
Homeworld: Emergence
Cossacks 3
Krush Kill ‘N Destroy 2: Krossfire
Blood 2: The Blood Group
The Adventures of Willy Beamish
Hacknet
Codename: ICEMAN
Edna & Harvey: The Breakout
Imperium Galactica II: Alliances

Got Skyshine's BEDLAM Redux! with my initial piñata around the time the event started. Added Icewind Dale: Enhanced Edition with the second (a pretty welcome upgrade for my Icewind Dale Complete), and finally War for the Overworld with the third one. Not bad at all, though like many I was hoping for Tyranny to pop out. :P

Might try another one or two before the event ends.

I got

Crawl (fun but I don't really do couch co-op anymore)
Kim (looks like a game I'll play for and hour and forget)
Untold stories (only game that I got that I had a desire for)
Redshirt (frankly looks bad, very poor looking characters)

Overall it wasn't bad it was random so I can't get mad at anyone but myself for gambling but it was only 3$ a shot it's not a bad deal

Purchased four pinatas:

•Agatha Christie: The ABC Murders
•Back to the Future: The Game
•Dead Synchronocity: Tomorrow Comes Today
•Mount & Blade: Warband

I already had Back to the Future from a previous purchase on TellTale's page, but it's nice to have it here. Overall very satisfied with today's gamble.

List updated

Today's Piñata: IL2-Sturmovik

There are six games on the spreadsheet that i really wanted .

Caesar IV
CivCity: Rome
Craft The World
Day of the Tentacle Remastered
Freddy Pharkas: Frontier Pharmacist
Full Throttle Remastered