Mine took about 15 minutes after I bought them to show up in the hub.

I got:
Seven Kingdoms 2 HD
Stalker - Shadow of Chernobyl
Bombshell
Titan Quest: Anniversary Edition
Metro 2033 Redux
Serious Sam's bogus Detour
War for the Overworld
The Signal From Tölva
RiME
World in Conflict: Complete Edition
Kyn
Stalker - Call of Pripyat
Trine Enchanted Edition
Cossacks 3
Saints Row: Gat Out Of Hell
Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons
Darksiders Warmastered Edition
Scanner Sombre
Superhot
Trine 2: Complete Story
Imperium Galactica
Metro: Last Light Redux
Saints Row Iv: Game of the Century Edition
Tyranny - Commander Edition
Stories Untold
Imperium Galactica II: Alliances
Enter the Gungeon

Warlords Battlecry 3

Its simulating the missing. You miss all the time when your blindfolded.

It takes a little while to show.
I got three and it didn't show af first but then I got:
- bombshell
- tempest
- man'owar: corsair

Alright, mine just appeared. Maybe it just takes some time.

I got:

Her Story

Yep, mine just now showed up - must be a GOG Bear Cousin :)

Heroes of Might and Magic 5: Bundle

I got Imperium Galactica 2. Not sure if I'm going to buy more or not, but if I do I'll edit this post to add the games I get. I think this is a pretty fun and neat idea, but I do wish we had access to the list of potential games. I'd hate to buy a bunch of them without knowing that any of the games I'd be interested in aren't even possible to get.

Edit: Actually, I completely missed all the games on sale when I was looking at the pinata stuff.. is it safe to assume that the only games that can drop in the pinatas are games that are a part of this weekly sale?



Edit (adding games): Skyshine's BEDLAM Redux!

Yup i got mine too.

Good news! I think you just volunteered. ;P

I got
Skyshine's BEDLAM Redux!
Owlboy
Kyn

Not likely, I'm at work :)

If someone wants to compile the list of games and send it I can put it in the first post later, otherwise someone might want to do an "Official" thread :)

It seems to be an alright deal:
Imperium Galactica
Imperium Galactica 2
SOMA
Cossacks 3
Bombshell

Might try a couple more towards the end.

Very strange. According to the FAQ you should not be able to get Darkest Dungeon: Edit: Okay. It seems I've misread that. You cannot get DLCs in a pinata. Although I don't think that games with DLC qualify as full games…

Got Pillars of Eternity: Hero Edition, which I already own. I mean, I pre-ordered the actual Hero Edition and that is the one I own and have owned since before the game was released.

I guess I need to contact customer support? Or will there be some magical automatic fix?

Pax