Isn't this the definition of Metroidvania?

"A style of platform game with role-playing game elements and inventory items, involving more exploration than a traditional linear platform game."

Knytt Underground maybe? As a "Metroidvania"?

2 in development:

[url=http://www.konjak.org/index.php?folder=4&file=30 ]The Iconoclasts [/url]
[url=http://www.axiomverge.com/ ]Axiom Verge[/url]

I agree with both your recommendations. However Dice5 did say no console games.

Two free Rogue-likes I have played and enjoyed:

nethack dot org
transcendence dot kronosaur dot com

I am afraid I am not into those other games unless Lemmings can be counted as one...

There is also a combination of the two genres: a Castlevania Roguelike!
(free and Java-based. I.e. platform independent)

Oh - I forgot - Gentrive 2, 1 person procedurally generated metroidvania.

OK. Agreed.

No, not really. OP has no such definitions, this is all yours. For me genre is more about gameplay, than not just perspective. I have no problem with metroidvania games being played in 1'st or 3'd person perspective.

I would also like to mention Delver for rogue likes, but it is 3d, so I am maybe not allowed.

PS - Also, not sure OP cares that much any more, this is a necor'd thread.

PSS - Caveat is of course when someone puts perspective as description of genre for example 2d metrodvania or FPS, OP did not

Roguelikes: Brogue, Stone Soup, Spelunky, DoD & DoomRL

but also

ADOM - 'open world' roguelike with quests & more rpg stuff - link

Infra Arcana - classic 1 dungon roguelike with 'Blood meets Lovecraft' setting - link (can't wait for v14)

I've been watching that one for a while and it looks amazing!

I am officially adding to the recommendations of Project Black Sun and Bunny Must Die.

BTW it's likes</span> not <span class="bold">[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rouge]rougelikes.

And there are tons of roguelikes on the PC. Most of the in the grand tradition of dungeon crawlers, not these newly fangled Bindings and FTLs :)


I'd recommend:

Stone Soup
Tales of Maj'eyal
Dungeons of Dredmor

Well perhaps he was looking for something like the colour red that isn't the colour red. In French. :P

By that definition, Metroid is not a Metroidvania, since it lacks roleplaying game elements.

Something like...

"A style of platform game with adventure game elements, involving more exploration than a traditional linear platform game"

...would probably make more sense.

And yes, laying down the definition is important if we're gonna suggest some games to the OP. What he is looking for are action-adventure games with platforming elements, not action-RPGs.

Yes, I realize that Symphony of the Night has some action-RPG elements, but that is not part of the Metroid formula. These type of games, including SotN, are first and foremost action-adventures.