I’ve seen you play (as town) but don’t recall any of the others. Taking out the players who are new to gog leaves:


Here's my personal wall-of-takext:




1. Dessimu...............................Nathaniel (Nathan) Smith
2. Lifthrasil...............................Sean O'Donnell (Sean-O!)
3. docbear1975.........................................Laura Jennings
4. Ixamyakxim..................................................Emma Hess
5. agentcarr16.............................................Adam Johnson
6. QuadrAlien.....................................William (Bill) O'Brian
7. bookwyrm627.............................................Craig Adams
8. Brasas..............................................Daniel (Dan) Evans
9. cristigale.......................................................Claire Dwyer
11. yogsloth.........................................................Eric Barton
14. trentonlf.......................................................Emily Barton
15. bler144..................................................Marie Thomson

Of those, bler, yogs, and bookwyrm would normally be expected to be the most active and stir the pot. Might play logical, might lead, might play antagonist, but should all be active and push for things to happen when nothing is happening. I’m guilty of being a driver when I should strategically sit back and ride, regardless of alignment. Lack patience in-game.

Trent is fairly active but generally plays a stoic, cards close to the chest style. His calling card is being grumpy about PM reveals. Not 100% consistent. Occasional appeal to emotion, particularly as town.

Lift can vary in terms of activity depending on the game and his schedule, but generally leans towards a logical style. That is NAI, as he's fairly even-keel and similar regardless.

cristi plays close to the chest, and is typically online only U.S. evenings, but does consistently post a few things every day. Her posting frequency makes her somewhat hard to engage with pressure and makes reading her votes a bit harder. Very smart, but especially early game doesn't tend to reveal much at all regardless of alignment. Consistent on the surface in terms of tone and approach. The person who reads her alignment most consistently is not in this game, though he would say she definitely has a tell when mafia.


Quad (QA), and Agent, as much as they can be effective when active, are almost certainly going to be lurkers needing to be resolved by POE or investigation. Quad can be pressured and might resolve himself that way. Agent likes to play a logical style, but the past few games hasn’t been present enough to actually do much of that.
Ix probably also falls into that group, though he's capable of playing more. Might lurk; might play. Hard to predict.

If we were allowed to wager on who would take a sub, if it’s not one of the new players I’d put money on one of those three.

Docbear is pretty new. Not much opinion yet. Aside from the non-GOG players I don’t think she’s played with me, trent, QA, or yogs either. Do suspect she will resolve herself one way or the other as the game goes, at least more likely than others.

Dess/Brasas are harder to summarize, in part because I don’t think I read either particularly well. Brasas I’ve observed but don’t think I’ve played with. [She?] is also relatively new to playing with us, but I believe pretty experienced with this type of game, particularly the Resistance. Is that right?

Dess can be lucid and focused or I might literally have zero idea what he’s talking about for an entire day. Do think he tends to resolve over time. Both are certainly skilled enough to be effective as town or non-town.

These are just my own opinions/observations, and anyone is free to counter/challenge/correct as they see fit.

/endWOT