onarliog: Sorry to derail the topic, but I'm curious. Did we ever get any sort of confirmation that wishlist entries are being used that way? Or in
any way for that matter?
Also I'm in the process of doing some basic analyses to correlate the wishes w/ games we actually do get, coming soon.
GOG has always clearly stated, and right here in the forums as well, that the wishlist acts as somewhat of a guide as to what games might be popular here if they were able to bring them to GOG. In no way is it a guarantee that they have any way to get their hands on them at all, because they do not control the ownership rights of the games nor have any kind of control over what a publisher or rights owner decides to do or not do with their games.
Some people expect that the wishlist is like a genie in a bottle, and you wish for a game and GOG magically brings it here because they can just ask any publisher for any game and it will materialize out of thin air and all legal issues and other property ownership concerns will magically vanish, and if a certain time passes and GOG does not obtain and release the game here that the wishlist is completely meaningless and there's no point to it at all. That it's a shill designed to keep the sheep happy and wishfully thinking.
No, it's not a genie in a bottle, and GOG has no control over rights owners. All they can do is approach them and keep approaching them year after year trying to get access to the games if possible. Many games are tangled in a myriad of legal rights issues that will most likely never be resolved. For example games that license 3rd party movie/TV show/sports or other intellectual property to which the developer/publisher of the game no longer has rights to publish games with that IP. Battle For Middle Earth 2 for example is no longer sold for years now and EA no longer has the rights to put that game back on the market, and it's extremely unlikely they will ever re-acquire such rights to do so, nor that GOG has any influence over the Saul Zaentz company to make it happen even if EA had any interest at all, which they most likely don't.
There are tonnes of reasons why some games are simply just not available to GOG to even have a chance to bring here, and such games probably will never show up here at all because of that. Voting for them can not hurt really because it costs nothing and it does in fact tell GOG and anyone else looking there including the game companies - that people do actually have an interest in that given game. Whether it is enough to make decisions happen is another story, but there is never any harm in voting for something.
One can look at the list of games on the wishlist which are marked "completed" - meaning they have actually come to the GOG store. Sort the list by most wished for to least, and stroll through the list to see the plethora of games that people wished for with high levels of votes that did actually come to GOG eventually. The wishlist did not itself alone decide this fate, but it gave GOG one additional piece of statistical data to go to a publisher and say "... and also, we have a public wishlist and N people have voted for this game" which is never something that can hurt in a negotiation.
So for people who think the wishlist is a magic genie in the bottle that instantly transports games to the GOG store in N days/weeks/months, no - you will be gravely disappointed, that is not how it works.
For those who want to take a few seconds or minutes to peruse the list or vote for a game or add a game in order to increase the interest in the game that is represented there in hopes that it might help as part of the bargaining power GOG has with a publisher for a given game that might actually be possible to come to GOG and isn't encumbered by endless legal issues, then yes it is worth it and yes GOG does use it in their negotiations. What factor it might have in the end in the overall decision making process for a given game likely varies greatly from one game to another however.
One thing is true though - not voting for a game at all, or just not using the wishlist at all means that a person's personal desire for a game is not represented anywhere visible at all, to GOG, to a developer or publisher or anyone else to whom it might matter.
As long as people think that the wishlist is useless unless you can vote for something and have a high percentage chance of seeing it show up here in a few weeks/months or whatever though, that would be a delusional way of thinking as it simply doesn't work that way.
One problem I see though, is I don't think the majority of GOG's customers even know the wishlist exists let alone use it. GOG should come up with "The Bear's Den", where random game titles show up in the web or Galaxy UI on some screen with a "Would you be potentially interested in buying this game if it came to GOG in the future?" or something like that to expand the sentiment. Of course that would be gameable much like Steam Greenlight is so maybe that's a crap idea too. :)