All lists are for entertainment and should not be used for investment purposes.

Prior post updated to tally all discrete guesses (308-310) in Rounds 1 & 2:
http://www.gog.com/forum/general/mystery_game_3rd_edition_giveaway/post350

I'm keeping separate track of the subset of those that are potentially eligible winners but won't post that here to give those posters first dibs on their old guess if they want it - 5 attempts at those, 3 of which were poaches, and 2 were by the same poster both in rd 2 & 3.

Rd 3 alpha:

XIII
Aquanox
Blackguards Special Edition (poached but wrong)
Black Mirror (winner!)
Book of Unwritten Tales II
Dark Matter
Dead Synchronicity (poached but wrong)
Disciples Sacred Lands G old
Dust: An Elysian Tale
Galactic Civilizations
Jade Empire: Special Edition
Jazzpunk
King's Quest 4, 5 & 6
Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver. (reguess by same)
Legend of Heroes Trails in the Sky
Lumino City (reguess by same)
Outlaws + A Handful of Missions
Rayman 3: Hoodlum Havoc (poached but wrong)
Red Faction
Re-Volt
Star Wars: X-Wing vs. Tie Fighter
Syndicate Plus
xenonauts

Congratulations! I'd have guessed Black Mirror if I didn't already have those.

So, Asterbreed?

R3 guess #1: Book of Unwritten Tales II

It was guessed just 4 posts prior to yours.

Off-topic, but I realized there are 5 items on my gog wishlist that still haven't been guessed even this deep into the pool.

havent read all the guesses, so my next one is probably a repeat again .... Fallout

That's the first it has appeared in any of the 3 rounds.

Dead State
Not a valid guess since:

Forgot to congratulate park_84. Congratulations, park_84. I'm glad I managed to at least guess one removed game before the only two removed games were so quickly removed from the giveaway.
Round #3, Guess #2: Hotline Miami 2: Wrong Number Digital Special Edition

Undecided on my strategy here.

Don't know 100% that it's allowed, but I'm going to use my guess this window Dreamfall: Longest Journey for _slaugh_ who had put in for it at the end of Rd 2.

I feel moderately confident this is the game from the 12 hour window hint.

I tried it already :)

And now I'm going to try Starpoint Gemini 2

haha, so had I - oof

Why not then.

Outlaws

Not sure if you're joking, but it was guessed in the early rounds and not in the possible pool to be a solution for Rd3, barring error.

It's also already been guessed in Rd 3. ;)