It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
DarrkPhoenix: While I'm sure more information will become available as an investigation is conducted, there's currently a fair amount of circumstantial evidence pointing to the Russian/separatist forces having shot down the plane. The plane was flying at just over 30,000 feet, which is out of range of the that the separatists have most frequently been using, and requiring something like a [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buk_missile_system]BUK system. Earlier separatist forces reported they had taken control of such a system, but a few hours after MH17 went down they pulled down their social media posts claiming such and started denying they had the capability to shoot down a plane at that altitude. Additionally, an An-26 (Ukrainian military cargo plane) was shot down three days ago while flying at a bit over 20,000 feet (generally outside the range of MANPADs), further supporting that separatists have the capability to shoot down planes at that altitude (or that Russia is willing to do it for them).

There was also tweet released by [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Igor_Girkin]Igor Girkin (a separatist leader) shortly after MH17 went down, claiming responsibility for just shooting down an An-26 in the same region that MH17 had just gone down (one current hypothesis is that separatist forces shot down MH17 thinking that it was another Ukrainian An-26). Translated:

Near Torez (city) an An-26 airplane was just shot down, it crashed somewhere beyond "Progress" mine site. We warned beforehand - do not fly over "our zone". Here's another video proof of the next "birdfall". A birdie crashed down beyond terricon (mine excavation site), missed living areas. Population not harmed. We also allegedly have info on another SU-25 shot down.
avatar
DarrkPhoenix: As a related note, Igor Girkin (aka Igor Strelkov) is former Russian GRU and FSB (reportedly active up until 2013).

Ultimately not conclusive, and it's always possible a false flag operation is in effect, but currently the actions of the separatists/Russians are not showing them in a good light. It also wouldn't be the first time that Russian military forces shot down civilian aircraft (see and [url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_Air_Lines_Flight_902]KAL-902, although to be fair such events have also occurred with [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_Air_Flight_655]countries as well).
Geez what a mess this whole affair is going to be.
It's pro-Russian rebels who (accidentally) shot down the plane. Ukraine has released an intercepted phone conversation between the rebels. The news are reporting the intercepted conversation, and it's all over the Internet. The rebels initially thought they had shot down an Ukrainian fighter jet AN-26.
Post edited July 17, 2014 by ktchong
avatar
ktchong: It's pro-Russian rebels who (accidentally) shot down the plane. Ukraine has released an intercepted phone conversation between the rebels. The news are reporting the intercepted conversation, and it's all over the Internet. The rebels initially thought they had shot down an Ukrainian fighter jet AN-26.
Has there been confirmation of the authenticity of these recordings? I see that they've been posted on YouTube and Ukrainian officials are claiming the conversation is between Russian operatives, but I haven't seen any other intelligence agencies making statements regarding the recording, nor any reputable news sources making firm claims one way or the other on it.
So, I wonder if Putin regrets shipping rabble rousers into Ukraine to stir up unrest? Seems like they're the ones responsible for this. I bet the single strand holding EU ties to Russia has just been cut.
low rated
Please trigger the World War 3. I need a few countries to be annihilated.
avatar
DarrkPhoenix: Has there been confirmation of the authenticity of these recordings? I see that they've been posted on YouTube and Ukrainian officials are claiming the conversation is between Russian operatives, but I haven't seen any other intelligence agencies making statements regarding the recording, nor any reputable news sources making firm claims one way or the other on it.
Would be pretty surprising if they were fake. Some of the people in them seemingly aren't anonymous militants but public figures who presumably would have recognizable voices.
avatar
zeroxxx: Please trigger the World War 3. I need a few countries to be annihilated.
Since I live in middle Europe hope that we are far from WW3.
avatar
Luned: Even worse, it's Malaysian Airlines again.
That's just coincidence.
avatar
truhlik: Since I live in middle Europe hope that we are far from WW3.
Well, who knows. Ucraine doesn't want to settle down, Russia is trying to gain the advantage, the Arabs wanting a new Caliphate... the struggle might just be enough to annihilate all of us if we're lucky :P
Post edited July 18, 2014 by blotunga
avatar
blotunga: That's just coincidence.
Well, who knows. Ucraine doesn't want to settle down, Russia is trying to gain the advantage, the Arabs wanting a new Caliphate... the struggle might just be enough to annihilate all of us if we're lucky :P
I tried to quote your post with 5 important survival tips for food and water and it appears the universe doesn't want me to post it as it vanished :(
Actually, there was a short victorious message right after the plane was shot, from one of the so-called leaders of these pro-russian bandits, that they shot another plane. He thought it was another military plane, but after it became obvious that it was a civillian airplane, the message was removed and they started to deny the very fact of having long range anti-air missiles. Ah, the modern world, where terrorists like to post tweets and youtube videos. Freaking degradation.
Post edited July 18, 2014 by AzureKite
avatar
Tarnicus: I tried to quote your post with 5 important survival tips for food and water and it appears the universe doesn't want me to post it as it vanished :(
The universe wants all of us starved to death :D
avatar
Tarnicus: I tried to quote your post with 5 important survival tips for food and water and it appears the universe doesn't want me to post it as it vanished :(
avatar
blotunga: The universe wants all of us starved to death :D
That's what I figured, so I didn't repost it. So with that in mind, I'll post my revised edition:

1/ Carry a plastic bag at all times. If you can't figure out how to get water from it, put it on your head and keep breathing until you see the light.
avatar
Tarnicus: That's what I figured, so I didn't repost it. So with that in mind, I'll post my revised edition:

1/ Carry a plastic bag at all times. If you can't figure out how to get water from it, put it on your head and keep breathing until you see the light.
A good one :D
avatar
reaver894: IF it was shot down by EITHER side, it will change the political playing field significantly,
Why would it? When a US Captain shot down Flight 655 with 290 dead he got a medal for it. They never even apologized.
avatar
zeroxxx: Please trigger the World War 3. I need a few countries to be annihilated.
What's the population in Indonesia? Better hope it's not your's one of them.
Also, this type of post is rather dumb. While humanity and the world are nowhere near the other spectrum of fucked up, a few hundred millions death toll is not the answer. Plus, countries are no longer annihilated. They just lose or win. Rewards and consequences come in economic instability or prosperity.
And in the end, everyone loses when it comes to environmental disaster. We all live on the same planet.
Post edited July 18, 2014 by HijacK