Posted June 06, 2014
DeMignon: I do understand, that many would like the rep system to be gone right now, but I think it's mostly because down-repping is heavily abused for quite some time now. In my opinion the problem isn't the down-vote function but its abuse.
From a sociological standpoint it's very effective for a community to have sanctioning capabilities or alternatively a higher instance that takes a close look and sanctions all dysfunctional behavior to a community wide consent.
The difference between real life social cohesion and an anonymous rep system in the Internet is the accountability, transparency and shared reference frame of what is actually a "postiive" or "negative" action. From a sociological standpoint it's very effective for a community to have sanctioning capabilities or alternatively a higher instance that takes a close look and sanctions all dysfunctional behavior to a community wide consent.
To judge what is "dysfucntional" would require published and committed standrads of some kind. A lot of the repping is about personal like or dislike of a given opinion. It should be about style of enaging others - but this would require moderation, in practice, I think.
Besides repping topic which I think a lot are ok to just ignore, my question would be: how to accomodate time zone differences for a lively discussion?
I think it would be nice to be able to display all new topics opened in the past x hours. I rarely hop back to beyond, say, first five to ten tabs. Not the only one, maybe?
Edit: or maybe as "highlight" feature of sorts, rotate a given country of given time zone as optional filter, for those who would like. I cannot recall when I have replied to an OP form New Zealand, for example! Full posting history would help establish that, of course! ;-p
Post edited June 06, 2014 by TStael