CMOT70: Best Western RPG in almost 20 years, since the first Gothic I'd say. The only other recent RPG's even in the ballpark for me are the Divinity OS games (which are totally different). I've already forgotten about The Witcher 3, yet I'll remember this one in 20 years in the same way I remember Jagged Alliance or Fallout.
Ah, Jagged Alliance. Damn nostalgia. Love it to bits.
KCD has many flaws, no doubt. Combat 1v1 is actually really good, but fails against multiple opponents. Devs bragged about realism, but we have magic potions.
There are no children in the game. Don't get me wrong, i don't want children who behave like in Skyrim, but none at all takes away from the immersion and realism.
There are still, after two years garments in the game that are broken. You see slit throates or complete detached necks from the body in every other cutscene. This is unaccatable.
The story in my opinion. doesn't hold a candle against the story in Witcher 3. KCD has many good side content, but the main story is not the games strong point.
I hope we see a more polished KCD 2, so that we can continue Henry's story and let him get his revenge. But please, no more bitches like Johanka. :P
If the devs could make combat against multiple opponents more fun, that would be great. And please, by the love of all what is holy, no more Bandits in full plate armor, or peasents who masterstrike you. It is not immersive or realistic. It is not even historically accurate.