tfishell: isn't Zoom-Platform sort of doing that? (albeit at a snail's pace) The problem is getting devs and pubs to actually give a crap about a tiny store.
Cavalary: That's my point. ZP has been around since 2014, which is incidentally when GOG notably set firmly on its way to shed its clear, specific stated values (even if a solid argument can be made for the moment when they decided to allow newer games (and higher prices), in 2012). But can it be said that it in any way replaced the old GOG in the scheme of things?
ZP has DRM-free games and, afaik, not many sales and not deep discounts. Does it have regional pricing?
Are you talking about ZP not having many games? I don't think we can have our cake and eat it too:
correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't GOG drop "one world" pricing to get more games here basically and grow? If they stuck with their values, do we have any idea how much more they would have grown or been able to stay in business? Do you believe they'd continue on the trajectory of growth and an ability to actually influence the industry for the better and get "AAA" games here without compromising their values? Personally I don't see it, but I guess we're just getting into "what if" territory.
(IIRC you are someone who has said he'd prefer GOG have gone out of business than compromise any of their values, something I disagree with aside from DRM-free but certainly don't want to argue over.)
Cavalary: it would be nice if an original GOG shaped hole would be created and some other store would fill it, but I fear that GOG took that banner and ran away with it, because if that hole was to be left, they already left it long ago and nobody managed to fill it, and their failure despite several years of bending over backwards to cater to the masses and the trends of the industry would just tell publishers and indie devs that there's no room for anything even remotely resembling principles and actually scare them away even more from any others trying to become what GOG used to be.
I guess I don't actually get what you're saying here: in your view, shouldn't a "GOG shaped hole" already exist since GOG dropped their values? Why does one need to be "created"? Or are you saying you believe nobody will try what GOG did ever again at this point because GOG dropped their principles to be able to grow or even stay in business, so a business won't even bother trying what GOG did?
Also it sounds like you're saying it's hopeless,
in which case Cavalary: I've been saying that since they dropped the flat price principle. And CDP has their own store, or at least used to, so the solution would have been to have games that don't follow GOG's original principles there and leave GOG to make a stand, preferably with a transfer of games from the "generic" store to GOG after a number of years, when they're old enough for the publishers to perhaps be more maleable regarding terms.
So set up a second store that allows DRM, regional pricing, etc., but keep GOG "pure", all under CDP's control? Would that have satisfied you, because, even if GOG "died", they'd have died "for something", like a martyr?