It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
Orkhepaj: so if gog gives ownership ,how can i sell the games?
in practice, it just looks like most steam games need you to occasionally connect to steam server
while gog games don't

renting is like that xbox gamepass , you can play the games, but you cant after the subs ends
avatar
InSaintMonoxide: I was always confused with the requirement to occasionally connect to steam servers thing. I used to live without an internet connection in my apartment from 2016 to 2018 and was therefore dependent on my steam games working without any internet connection ever. I never had a problem launching anything in offline mode during this time period, so i still don't get how or when you're supposed to be forced to connect to the internet.
New Denuvo games have this requirement, because one trick is to rent a game you want to play on Steam, download it via steam, put steam in offline mode... then refund the game via steam's webpage.
low rated
avatar
Orkhepaj: so if gog gives ownership ,how can i sell the games?
in practice, it just looks like most steam games need you to occasionally connect to steam server
while gog games don't

renting is like that xbox gamepass , you can play the games, but you cant after the subs ends
avatar
haidynn: No, renting is when someone else owns the product and you're only given a license to use their service to access the product. Stop confusing things. It's all about ownership, not about a service ending.

I wouldn't say that GoG grants ownership either, but that what you pay for is the luxury of being able to download a specific game from their servers. Bitcoin and NFTs have more actual ownership than other digital products, since digital products can all be copied which makes their value effectively zero. You get the same game whether you pirate it or download it from GoG.
dont think so , with gog you can use galaxy features like achievements and remote saves and ofc updates
so if gog bans your account, and you haven't backuped your games you should be able to legally download it from somewhere right?
if not i really dont get what you get for this supposed ownership , it sounds like fake legal talk
low rated
avatar
Orkhepaj: how is it rental when there is nor monthly nor yearly payment? it isnt
avatar
Arcadius-8606: Public libraries have rental systems without payment also. At least in the US, it does.
you borrow a book from a library, you don't rent it
avatar
haidynn: No, renting is when someone else owns the product and you're only given a license to use their service to access the product. Stop confusing things. It's all about ownership, not about a service ending.

I wouldn't say that GoG grants ownership either, but that what you pay for is the luxury of being able to download a specific game from their servers. Bitcoin and NFTs have more actual ownership than other digital products, since digital products can all be copied which makes their value effectively zero. You get the same game whether you pirate it or download it from GoG.
avatar
Orkhepaj: dont think so , with gog you can use galaxy features like achievements and remote saves and ofc updates
so if gog bans your account, and you haven't backuped your games you should be able to legally download it from somewhere right?
if not i really dont get what you get for this supposed ownership , it sounds like fake legal talk
I told you, GoG doesn't grant you ownership either. Responding with more "But if GoG grants you ownership" style retorts isn't changing that Digital Products tend not to be ownable.
low rated
avatar
Orkhepaj: dont think so , with gog you can use galaxy features like achievements and remote saves and ofc updates
so if gog bans your account, and you haven't backuped your games you should be able to legally download it from somewhere right?
if not i really dont get what you get for this supposed ownership , it sounds like fake legal talk
avatar
haidynn: I told you, GoG doesn't grant you ownership either. Responding with more "But if GoG grants you ownership" style retorts isn't changing that Digital Products tend not to be ownable.
but some here argue that steam gives rent and gog gives ownership
low rated
avatar
Orkhepaj: so if gog gives ownership ,how can i sell the games?
avatar
teceem: Since when is ownership absolute? I can't think of any object (real or virtual) that, when owned, you can (legally) use in ANY way you want. (murder being an obvious example)

In short, you own GOG games for personal use.
actually, not quite. as youo know, you don't buy the game on gOg either, but a license. So the ownership on gOg ans Steam is the same. Theoretically, the license holders can revoke your license to play the game. The differnce is that Steam can enforce the removal of the game, while gOg can not. But then you are playing an unlicensed game, i.e. same as pirating.

Off course it is your own moral whats-its determine if you feel it is still your right to play the game you paid for, but this is the legal position.

(to date, I do no know any game makers who have withdrawn any licenses, apart from illigal licenses.)
avatar
haidynn: New Denuvo games have this requirement, because one trick is to rent a game you want to play on Steam, download it via steam, put steam in offline mode... then refund the game via steam's webpage.
Indeed. And on top of that, Steam's "offline mode" also only "worked" for CEG protected games only as long as you didn't change motherboard.

avatar
amok: you borrow a book from a library, you don't rent it
And you don't buy games on Steam, you "subscribe" to them (as is literally spelled out in Section 2 of the Steam Subscriber Agreement as to how Valve openly describes its own store - "Steam and your Subscription(s) require the download and installation of...", "As a Subscriber you may obtain access to...", etc).
avatar
haidynn: I told you, GoG doesn't grant you ownership either. Responding with more "But if GoG grants you ownership" style retorts isn't changing that Digital Products tend not to be ownable.
Define ownership.
low rated
avatar
BrianSim: And you don't buy games on Steam, you "subscribe" to them (as is literally spelled out in Section 2 of the Steam Subscriber Agreement as to how Valve openly describes its own store - "Steam and your Subscription(s) require the download and installation of...", "As a Subscriber you may obtain access to...", etc).
sigh... this is what you get when you try to do a joke with fanatics.... do I really need to explain it? The post I responded to had a big Freudian slip, which I found very funny.

edit - I should have know better by now....

edit 2 - Well, I was in a good mood,e now I despair again. so, yeah. carry on, you lot - do your thing.
Post edited May 30, 2021 by amok
avatar
haidynn: I told you, GoG doesn't grant you ownership either. Responding with more "But if GoG grants you ownership" style retorts isn't changing that Digital Products tend not to be ownable.
avatar
Orkhepaj: but some here argue that steam gives rent and gog gives ownership
So because reading the message you're quoting is too difficult, you're just spewing out random nonsense? Steam is a rental service but GoG doesn't grant ownership and, without DRM, GoG doesn't really have any control over your ability to play the game. So GoG is more like a download service, you pay for the luxury of being able to get the downloads you want direct from GoG without looking elsewhere.
avatar
amok: actually, not quite. as youo know, you don't buy the game on gOg either, but a license. So the ownership on gOg ans Steam is the same. Theoretically, the license holders can revoke your license to play the game. The differnce is that Steam can enforce the removal of the game, while gOg can not. But then you are playing an unlicensed game, i.e. same as pirating.

Off course it is your own moral whats-its determine if you feel it is still your right to play the game you paid for, but this is the legal position.

(to date, I do no know any game makers who have withdrawn any licenses, apart from illigal licenses.)
I'll ask you too: define ownership!
Everything in life can be legally taken away from you. Are you saying ownership doesn't exist unless it's absolute?
avatar
Orkhepaj: dont think so , with gog you can use galaxy features like achievements and remote saves and ofc updates
so if gog bans your account, and you haven't backuped your games you should be able to legally download it from somewhere right?
if not i really dont get what you get for this supposed ownership , it sounds like fake legal talk
avatar
haidynn: I told you, GoG doesn't grant you ownership either. Responding with more "But if GoG grants you ownership" style retorts isn't changing that Digital Products tend not to be ownable.
This time you are making philosophy over the real facts of GOG and Steam EULA differences, or the actual court sentencesgiving some direction. You shoud focus on that.
Everybody knows the difference in ownership between a boxed game copy and a digital copy. But If an EULAs focus on product ownership you own he product. Obviously with the limitations of the respective media.
As it is been said ownership is not absolute and the digital media can be an example.
low rated
avatar
amok: actually, not quite. as youo know, you don't buy the game on gOg either, but a license. So the ownership on gOg ans Steam is the same. Theoretically, the license holders can revoke your license to play the game. The differnce is that Steam can enforce the removal of the game, while gOg can not. But then you are playing an unlicensed game, i.e. same as pirating.

Off course it is your own moral whats-its determine if you feel it is still your right to play the game you paid for, but this is the legal position.

(to date, I do no know any game makers who have withdrawn any licenses, apart from illigal licenses.)
avatar
teceem: I'll ask you too: define ownership!
Everything in life can be legally taken away from you. Are you saying ownership doesn't exist unless it's absolute?
god. and now this.... why don't you just go the last milimeter and claim I am Hitler.... or that nothing matters as entropy dictates the heat death of the universe. so ownership do not matter as everything in the end will just bleed out in to the empty void of the universe and nothing will be left.

In any case, you don't own shit, apparently. therefore then, ownership of games on gOg' is a meaningless concept. This is as following your own argument here; you own your games just as much on gOg as on Steam as ownership is not going to be defined as we are now making so grand statments as " Everything in life can be legally taken away from you.". There - argument solved, you cracked it. No longer any point arguing any further.
Post edited May 30, 2021 by amok
avatar
haidynn: I told you, GoG doesn't grant you ownership either. Responding with more "But if GoG grants you ownership" style retorts isn't changing that Digital Products tend not to be ownable.
avatar
teceem: Define ownership.
Ownership gives you complete authority over something, which is why it's never actually possible to own another human being (said person has their own authority, so you can never gain complete authority.) You're not free to do whatever you want with the installer you download, nor are you free to do what ever you want with the files inside the installer.

The pitiful part is that the people who supposedly "own" the installer or "own" the gamefiles are completely helpless to stopping you from doing anything with it because they lack any authority over what happens to their code once it leaves their systems.

Then we get to legal ownership where someone says "I can prove I was the correct owner of this" but actually read the subscriber agreements... neither GoG nor Steam have any clauses saying that they are required to restore your access to your account or items on your account should you lose them for whatever reason. They may do so as a courtesy but they're not required to,


CDs are like Bearer bonds, the person who currently owns (meaning even if the CD was stolen from someone) the CD owns the license to play the game. You don't really get that with digital downloads, instead you get a license to use Steam to download and play the game with the steam client or a license to use GoG to just download the game. That you can't sell those licenses (unlike the CD) can also result in a dispute over who actually owns what.
Post edited May 30, 2021 by haidynn
avatar
amok: sigh... this is what you get when you try to do a joke with fanatics...
"Fanatics"? "Claim I am Hitler"? People here are just talking normally mate. Sounds like you need to take a break and get some fresh air...
Post edited May 30, 2021 by BrianSim