It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
dtgreene: Those PC handhelds look interesting, but have the drawback that they won't fit in my purse.
avatar
timppu: I'd buy a bigger purse if I were you. Maybe even so big it could fit my laptop in.

Another thing that kinda pushes me away from handhelds is that I am unsure about their maintainability. How easy it is to fix it yourself if one tiny button or analog stick or whatever gets broken, or the battery starts swelling, can you find those spare parts easily and how much do they cost etc.

I guess the handheld could still be played with e.g. a wireless BT gamepad, but that would feel super-weird, like picking your nose with a hammer or something,

Oh yeah I do have a Nintendo Switch but we have only one game for it so far (Minecraft) and I don't use the device at all (my kids play it once in a bluemoon, e.g, yesterday; otherwise they are either on their tablets (mostly watching Youtube on it) or playing Roblox on their laptops). I guess if I were into handheld gaming, I'd buy some Zelda games for Switch and play there, or hey maybe even The Witcher 3 (Switch-version)? So far I haven't seen the need for that.

One of its controllers started acting up, fortunately the Switch controllers can be removed easily so I didn't even try to fix the controller but just bought a cheaper third-party controller parts for the Switch, ones without the battery (don't need the battery for the controllers, if my kids play the Switch on TV, they use 8bitdo wireless gamepads).

I kinda wished I would have jailbroken the Switch when it was (possibly) still possible with an older firmware, so that I could run some homebrew games and emulators on it. But then maybe it couldn't have run official Nintendo Switch games anymore, which would have been a shame too in case I would have wanted to buy those Zelda games or something...
Maintaining a handheld is my largest gripe. Nobody seems to interested in doing things that ensure the long term use of these machines. Like the thread I made about the Legion Go recently. No matter the handheld, from any brand. People who discuss them seem to ignore the key parts that keep them functioning. The AC adapter and the batteries.

If a machine cant turn on, it doesnt matter what the use case and specs are.

If interested the Go has detach able controllers too. But nobody seemms to know if it will run without the battery(AC power only).
avatar
Shmacky-McNuts: Maintaining a handheld is my largest gripe. Nobody seems to interested in doing things that ensure the long term use of these machines. Like the thread I made about the Legion Go recently. No matter the handheld, from any brand. People who discuss them seem to ignore the key parts that keep them functioning. The AC adapter and the batteries.

If a machine cant turn on, it doesnt matter what the use case and specs are.

If interested the Go has detach able controllers too. But nobody seemms to know if it will run without the battery(AC power only).
Was it the thread where someone mentioned they didn't find the charge limit options in BIOS settings but had to use a Windows application to change that (to e.g. limit the charging to 80%)?

I meant to comment there that it seems to be the case with many Lenovo Legion laptops too. I think my Legion laptop used to have the option in the BIOS/UEFI settings to limit the charging by selecting one of three profiles (one charges up to 100%, one to 80%, and one to 60% I think; the last one is the one to use if your laptop is 99% of the time connected to power, like mine is), but it seemed to disappear from there with some UEFI update, not sure why? I am quite sure I did limit it there earlier but then couldn't find it anymore after some UEFI update.

Luckily that limit can still be set with the Legion Windows application (also the third-party tool someone made that can be used instead of the official Lenovo app), and apparently it changes something in the BIOS/UEFI level because the limit works also on Linux, or when charging the laptop when it is shut down. Not sure if there is a similar tool also to Linux, kinda shitty one has to boot to Windows to change that setting.


If testing Legion Go without a battery, be sure to test whether its performance will stay the same. My understanding is that some laptops (including Macs) limit the performance of the laptop if they detect battery is removed or not working, like the CPU is forced to run on lower frequency etc. I think the idea is that since it can't get extra power from the battery in case the laptop is using lots of power when CPUs and GPUs run at overdrive, and the power supply can't give enough power momentarily, then bad things happen. With a battery installed, it would normally get that needed extra power from the battery.

So I am wondering if Go has a similar limitation, in case it even works at all without the battery.
avatar
DSHLK: Maybe I'm one of very few, but I am 100% a Steam Deck user for GOG games (I use Heroic Games Launcher, but I do also have Junk Store and the plugin for GOG installed too). I love being able to play my library on the go, and even have achievements working!

So I guess I'm just wondering, how many Steam Deck users are here in the forum?
Oh man, I've just checked and it really seems to have achievements! Does it also calculate your playtime? I like that feature of Galaxy.

I love my SteamDeck (sorry GOG hardcore fans), but when I play GOG games, I usually do it on PC (like 95% of time) as I lunched 2-3 games on deck via Galaxy (yes, on SteamDeck) but performance was a bit worse and things like to crash here and there (or it used as I haven't launched GOG game on SD for months or longer).

---

Thank you DSHLK, you made my day! :)
avatar
sadlyrematch: Y'all, there are more scenarios in life than waiting in a doctor's office lmfaoooo

It's no different than bringing a Nintendo DS in your backpack
That reminded me that I do have a handheld, a Nintendo Switch (and of course an Android phone and a tablet that I guess can play some games too)... I just never got an urge to take it with me in case I want to play (Minecraft or some Zelda game) somewhere else. My laptop is usually enough for that, and allows me to do other stuff too like writing to this forum.
avatar
dtgreene: Those PC handhelds look interesting, but have the drawback that they won't fit in my purse.
avatar
timppu: I'd buy a bigger purse if I were you. Maybe even so big it could fit my laptop in.
Why not going full harcore mode and buy one that fits a desktop and a CRT. Maybe a couple of batteries and a solar panel to help when there's no power :)
avatar
Shmacky-McNuts: If a machine cant turn on, it doesnt matter what the use case and specs are.

If interested the Go has detach able controllers too. But nobody seemms to know if it will run without the battery(AC power only).
I believe this has been discussed a lot in the past, maybe a year or two ago.
I wonder if they run without the RAM plugged in as well, damn greddy hardware manufacturers....
avatar
sadlyrematch: I alternate between my main workstation/gaming PC, my Linux HTPC, and my Steam Deck. I love my Steam Deck! I modified mine to have a purple translucent back. :)
Pretty much this, except I don't love the Deck.
Oh and add a Windows tablet and a Linux Laptop as well.
Post edited January 12, 2025 by Dark_art_
avatar
Shmacky-McNuts: Maintaining a handheld is my largest gripe. Nobody seems to interested in doing things that ensure the long term use of these machines. Like the thread I made about the Legion Go recently. No matter the handheld, from any brand. People who discuss them seem to ignore the key parts that keep them functioning. The AC adapter and the batteries.

If a machine cant turn on, it doesnt matter what the use case and specs are.

If interested the Go has detach able controllers too. But nobody seemms to know if it will run without the battery(AC power only).
avatar
timppu: Was it the thread where someone mentioned they didn't find the charge limit options in BIOS settings but had to use a Windows application to change that (to e.g. limit the charging to 80%)?

I meant to comment there that it seems to be the case with many Lenovo Legion laptops too. I think my Legion laptop used to have the option in the BIOS/UEFI settings to limit the charging by selecting one of three profiles (one charges up to 100%, one to 80%, and one to 60% I think; the last one is the one to use if your laptop is 99% of the time connected to power, like mine is), but it seemed to disappear from there with some UEFI update, not sure why? I am quite sure I did limit it there earlier but then couldn't find it anymore after some UEFI update.

Luckily that limit can still be set with the Legion Windows application (also the third-party tool someone made that can be used instead of the official Lenovo app), and apparently it changes something in the BIOS/UEFI level because the limit works also on Linux, or when charging the laptop when it is shut down. Not sure if there is a similar tool also to Linux, kinda shitty one has to boot to Windows to change that setting.

If testing Legion Go without a battery, be sure to test whether its performance will stay the same. My understanding is that some laptops (including Macs) limit the performance of the laptop if they detect battery is removed or not working, like the CPU is forced to run on lower frequency etc. I think the idea is that since it can't get extra power from the battery in case the laptop is using lots of power when CPUs and GPUs run at overdrive, and the power supply can't give enough power momentarily, then bad things happen. With a battery installed, it would normally get that needed extra power from the battery.

So I am wondering if Go has a similar limitation, in case it even works at all without the battery.
Good to know the laptops may have the power options(depending on model and drivers). MSI laptops seem reliable without batteries, on AC power only too.
https://www.gog.com/forum/general/legion_go_question_for_anyone_that_has_one/


For so odd reason, I see Steamdeck, GPD and most of the others never having a conversation about whether or not these handhelds will run solely on AC power. Its very odd to me. I dig the battery bypass chips though. Some devices have chips for it. Seems as you mention Lenovo laptops may do it with software. Interesting.

Do you happen to have a Legion Go?

Ive been trying to contact customer service at Lenovo. But they dont have any contacts at all unless you buy something lol
24/7 Buying. Have a problem? F**k off! lol
avatar
Shmacky-McNuts: Do you happen to have a Legion Go?
No. Nintendo Switch and some Android phones/tablets are the only "handhelds" I have at this point.

Legion Go seems to have nice specs and now is on sale (599€, normally 795.95€ here) but still I consider the price so high that I can't escape thinking "I could get some ASUS TUF or even ROG laptop for that price...".

If I at some point get several thousand euros of excess money, I might buy one just out of curiosity. Or even a Steam Deck.

https://www.gigantti.fi/product/gaming/pelitietokoneet/kannettava-pelilaite/lenovo-legion-go-kannettava-pelilaite/653040
Post edited January 12, 2025 by timppu
avatar
timppu: I'd buy a bigger purse if I were you. Maybe even so big it could fit my laptop in.
avatar
Dark_art_: Why not going full harcore mode and buy one that fits a desktop and a CRT. Maybe a couple of batteries and a solar panel to help when there's no power :)
avatar
Shmacky-McNuts: If a machine cant turn on, it doesnt matter what the use case and specs are.

If interested the Go has detach able controllers too. But nobody seemms to know if it will run without the battery(AC power only).
avatar
Dark_art_: I believe this has been discussed a lot in the past, maybe a year or two ago.
I wonder if they run without the RAM plugged in as well, damn greddy hardware manufacturers....
avatar
sadlyrematch: I alternate between my main workstation/gaming PC, my Linux HTPC, and my Steam Deck. I love my Steam Deck! I modified mine to have a purple translucent back. :)
avatar
Dark_art_: Pretty much this, except I don't love the Deck.
Oh and add a Windows tablet and a Linux Laptop as well.
Well, supposedly Lenovo would supply a uefi option to change battery max charge. and switch over to AC power. However, this does not cover the future of the device. When any battery dies, this creates ewaste when a owner disposes the device. Im curious about any handheld, when the battery is unplugged; what happens when using AC power?

Legion Go happens to be of interest lately, because it may actually be functional without a battery. But nobody who owns one has tested this. But Tim, mentions some Lenovo laptops may do this....maybe.

edit: oops, wrote Tin by accident....changed to Tim
Post edited January 12, 2025 by Shmacky-McNuts
avatar
Shmacky-McNuts: Legion Go happens to be of interest lately, because it may actually be functional without a battery. But nobody who owns one has tested this. But Tim, mentions some Lenovo laptops may do this....maybe.
I meant it (my Legion laptop) has an option to limit to which level you charge your battery, but you need to use a Windows application for that even though it apparently changes some BIOS/UEFI ACPI setting or something (because the limit works also on Linux and when the machine is shut down). Not sure if there was an option in UEFI to disable the battery; it may be there was, with a note that it is meant for maintenance purposes. in order to make the system totally powerless when maintaining it, changing parts etc... or something like that.

I haven't tested whether the laptop works without a battery, but I presume it does. However, I have reason some (many) laptops and Macs limit the performance of the device if you remove or bypass the battery, and I wondered whether Legion Go has a similar limitation (in case it works at all without a battery).
Post edited January 12, 2025 by timppu
avatar
Shmacky-McNuts: Do you happen to have a Legion Go?
avatar
timppu: No. Nintendo Switch and some Android phones/tablets are the only "handhelds" I have at this point.

Legion Go seems to have nice specs and now is on sale (599€, normally 795.95€ here) but still I consider the price so high that I can't escape thinking "I could get some ASUS TUF or even ROG laptop for that price...".

If I at some point get several thousand euros of excess money, I might buy one just out of curiosity. Or even a Steam Deck.

https://www.gigantti.fi/product/gaming/pelitietokoneet/kannettava-pelilaite/lenovo-legion-go-kannettava-pelilaite/653040
Oh well, worth asking. Heya....you mentioned Minecraft for switch I think. A guy on youtube Modern Vintage Gamer, made a video showing a Switch running Minecraft running better somehow. Dunno if that may be of any interest to you.

Ill try and find the info if that is of use.
avatar
Shmacky-McNuts: Legion Go happens to be of interest lately, because it may actually be functional without a battery. But nobody who owns one has tested this. But Tim, mentions some Lenovo laptops may do this....maybe.
avatar
timppu: I meant it (my Legion laptop) has an option to limit to which level you charge your battery, but you need to use a Windows application for that even though it apparently changes some BIOS/UEFI ACPI setting or something (because the limit works also on Linux and when the machine is shut down). Not sure if there was an option in UEFI to disable the battery; it may be there was, with a note that it is meant for maintenance purposes. in order to make the system totally powerless when maintaining it, changing parts etc... or something like that.

I haven't tested whether the laptop works without a battery, but I presume it does. However, I have reason some (many) laptops and Macs limit the performance of the device if you remove or bypass the battery, and I wondered whether Legion Go has a similar limitation (in case it works at all without a battery).
I will consider their laptops then. Good to know it has power options :)
Post edited January 12, 2025 by Shmacky-McNuts
avatar
pawel-t: Oh man, I've just checked and it really seems to have achievements! Does it also calculate your playtime? I like that feature of Galaxy.
Heroic syncs playtime (with the option to disable it in settings), has achievements, has cloud sync (for games that support it, and it also seems to be Windows-games-only? works fine with Wine/Proton), and has multiplayer support for some games that "require" Galaxy for multiplayer.

It's how my profile is populated with stats.
Post edited January 12, 2025 by sadlyrematch
avatar
dtgreene: Those PC handhelds look interesting, but have the drawback that they won't fit in my purse.
avatar
timppu: I'd buy a bigger purse if I were you. Maybe even so big it could fit my laptop in.
Drawbacks of doing so:
* A bigger purse is more bulky, which is a pain if you're carrying it around everywhere. (Reminder: Women's clothing, for whatever reason, doesn't usually have pockets.)
* Some events do not allow backs (which includes purses) bigger than a certain size.

For situations where I need to carry my laptop, I have a backpack with a laptop pocket that I can use. (I am, however, looking for a new lightweight laptop to fill that pocket.)
avatar
timppu: I'd buy a bigger purse if I were you. Maybe even so big it could fit my laptop in.
avatar
Dark_art_: Why not going full harcore mode and buy one that fits a desktop and a CRT. Maybe a couple of batteries and a solar panel to help when there's no power :)
Actually, a mini pc that fits in a backpack can be useful if, say, you need to bring the computer to a convention to show off a game you're making.

Of course, there's the issue with the monitor, and unless you can find one that folds somehow, fitting it in a backpack could be a problem, and carrying it separately, of course, is annoying. (I've done that in the past, but they were to smaller events where I could park close by.)

avatar
pawel-t: Oh man, I've just checked and it really seems to have achievements! Does it also calculate your playtime? I like that feature of Galaxy.
I don't know if I'm in the minority, but I'd actually prefer my playtime to *not* be tracked, not by the game, and not by the launcher. It's one of the complaints I have about lutris, for example, that it tracts time with no option (that I could find) to disable it.
Post edited January 12, 2025 by dtgreene
avatar
pawel-t: Oh man, I've just checked and it really seems to have achievements! Does it also calculate your playtime? I like that feature of Galaxy.
avatar
sadlyrematch: Heroic syncs playtime (with the option to disable it in settings), has achievements, has cloud sync (for games that support it, and it also seems to be Windows-games-only? works fine with Wine/Proton), and has multiplayer support for some games that "require" Galaxy for multiplayer.

It's how my profile is populated with stats.
Nice! Thank you for the answer. Then I can finally play my GOG games on SD without hacky way or push it to PC only.

Damn, that's a great news :D
avatar
pawel-t: (....)
More like this, please : ) SDxc are great all-rounders. Testing for a year and work everywhere! ^
I don't have one but i have a Linux Mint laptop for traveling, and when i'm at home i use my Windows desktop.

For games that fits better on PC than a console like simulation and strategy games, a laptop is better than a handheld.