CharlesGrey: I had the old Xbox 360 version of AitD. ( Due to the low review ratings I was actually able to pick up the collector's edition really cheap, with a bunch of extra goodies. ) Aside from being a little rough around the edges, I don't remember any major problems, but I don't know how bad the PC port turned out.
Yeah, the PC controls in general were pretty bad, but it sounds like you got lucky, I've seen a lot of people having issues with the 360 version, though I don't know if it was just as buggy or if that was just because more people had it.
As for FEAR, I only played a few hours of the first one but wasn't really impressed. I should add that I have about zero interest in generic military Shooters, and for the most that's what FEAR felt like during those first few hours. You just shoot at human opponents in SWAT gear, and every now and then there's some random scripted shock effect or vision and most of those were rather boring. I do remember a handful of more creative and creepy effects later on, so maybe the game gets better after the first few chapters/missions?
Yeah, the first FEAR is largely shooting soldier guys, most of the supernatural stuff you had to run away from or was pretty non-threatening. It does get more horrific as you go on. Like I said, I think Perseus Mandate and 2 were heavier on the horror, and there's more variety of enemies, though still a lot of military guys.
Condemned is pretty good, it's by the same guys. As was said, PC only got the first one, so I've never played the second, which is a shame because I hear the second has some fantastic sequences and gets completely nuts at the end.
Edit: To address Ricky_Bobby, I believe, and the PCGamigWiki seems to back me up, that it only had a disc check. Hard copies of FEAR as well.