First let me just say I'm against censorship in any way.
The games that get compared the most as I read feedback are:
Grand Theft Auto
Manhunt
Hotline Miami
Postal (The first one)
Grand Theft Auto allows you to slaughter innocents, and in some pretty horrific ways, this is undeniable. However, it is NOT part of the main game. It is NOT required to progress the story. It is PLAYER CHOICE.
So instantly, I rule GTA out. GTA is about playing as criminals, but they have their own greedy and selfish goals that usually involve money and power. Innocents simply get in the way.
Next, you have Manhunt, which is a very dark and gruesome game. But this one also gets crossed out, because, while you may play as a criminal, a death row inmate even, implying he did something very awful indeed, the game doesn't have you killing any innocent people whatsoever. Your enemies are criminals, white supremacists, mercenaries, the mentally disturbed, and cops. Some of those are grey areas, sure, but they are all trying to kill and stop you, the player, from progressing. In other words they are a threat. You the player have to form a sort of unholy alliance to lead the main character to safety. I consider Manhunt a well made piece of dark art in the way it handles that.
Next, you have Hotline Miami, which honestly baffles me. Hotline Miami is about mind control and killing criminals related to the Russians and... its really wacky and out of this world. Just because its top down and violent doesn't mean shit.
Finally, the most accurate of them all, Postal. The first game has you playing a cryptic, delusional, mentally broken man who is convinced something is in the water and the world wants him dead. So he grabs his weapons and goes on a rampage.
However, there is an important thing you must understand about Postal and Hatred. Even in Postal, slaughtering innocents is PLAYER CHOICE. You only have to kill the cops to proceed.
And that's kind of my problem from what I see of Hatred. You see the player dash out, and just start spraying away at innocents, as he does his best edgy voice about being mad and "boo hoo time to kill a bunch of people i want to die violently so brutal".
Look, I hope this game has something to say. I hope it has a purpose. I want to learn about this character. What made him this way? Will he have a moral dilemma? What were the events that lead up to his mass killings? Am I only killing unarmed innocents? If so, that sounds very boring. Am I forced to kill innocents to proceed? Why? What happens to this character at the end? Does he just shoot himself? Congrats you beat the game? Does he go to prison perhaps? Will we see the consequences of his actions? Will he learn anything? Perhaps there will be a twist?
I hope there is more substance to this. I hope it's not Edgy: The Game. I'm sorry, I'm not 14 anymore.
This is the type of game that, when done wrong, can very well damage the art form we all love and enjoy. Video games. I can only hope the developer knows what they're doing...