I'm kind of in a pirate mood recently, I'm playing Sid Meier's Pirates right now and played Seadogs a few days ago. What other pirate games are there on GOG? I've seen videos and pictures of Cutththroat and that games look fantastic, a shame GOG didn't get it yet. Uncharted Waters New Horizons is another classic I played a long time ago, though I heard the MS-DOS version is inferior to the SNES version, and well, I doubt GOG is going to get any KOEI games here anytime soon.

Btw, bear in mind that my PC is crap and anything newer than 2005 probably won't run on it.

The Monkey Island series of course!

I'd say LEGO Pirates but that's more likely to be not what you're looking for.

We've just had Port Royale sale.
In a way its gameplay is similar with Uncharted Waters New Horizons from Koei.

There isn’t much.
Blood and gold Caribbean - a mount and blade mod.
Sea dogs.
Monkey island games.

The best pirate ever as far as I can tell (and that’s even with the ubisoft collectibles everywhere) is assassins creed black sail (and rogue for an add on). There isn’t anything which comes close to that.

Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire has a fair amount of pirate content.

There are not too many pirate games on GOG, especially considering the fact that you already mentioned Sid Meier's game and the Sea Dogs series.

I could suggest "Blood & Gold: Caribbean!", which is now on sale at a good discount, but since it's an unoptimized mess, I doubt that it will work well on potato PC. The same doubts about Risen 2.

You can also try the Port Royal series or its successor / spin-off called "Tortuga: Pirates of the New World", which, unfortunately, is only available on GamersGate.

If you're looking for Pirate-Themed games (aside from those other posters have already suggested) you take a look at these. They are of several kinds but maybe you can find something that interests you:

https://www.gog.com/game/tropico_reloaded

https://www.gog.com/game/the_elder_scrolls_adventures_redguard

https://www.gog.com/game/nightmares_from_the_deep_the_cursed_heart

https://www.gog.com/game/pixel_piracy

https://www.gog.com/game/tempest

https://www.gog.com/game/corsairs_gold

I figured there wouldn't be many pirate-themed games on GOG.

Monkey Island is very good, I have it on my wishlist, but I'm noy exactly a great fan of point and click adventure games, still going to get it eventually.

I don't mind LEGO games, though I just checked its system requeriments and I very much doubt it would run on my PC.

Port Royale seems ok, even wishlisted it, but I must confess, it indeed looks like a facebook game and some reviews aren't really praising it. And I can't see how its gameplay is similar to New Horizons, even by a bit. It's probably going to be on a very low priority for my purchases.

I have played Mount and Blade Warband, albeit on the lowest graphic settings possible, but still liked it a lot, but mods conversions don't tend to run any better than vanilla Warband, stuff like With Fire and Sword, just sheer unplayable on my PC. But I've wishlisted it, maybe someday when I get rid of this old junk and grab a decent computer, I'll play it.

And yeah, Black Flag is completely off-limits to me, AAA games are like alien concept to me.

It indeed looks like there aren't many good pirate games on GOG, I really wish they rereleased some of the classics, as I said before, Cuththroats looks fantastic from what I've seen, but there really isn't a legal way to get it nowadays. (And I've grown out of my young real life pirating days.)

Anyway guys, thanks for all the replies, it seems I'll have to be content with what I got for now, specially Seadogs, I'll probably have to replay it, kinda got bummed out of that game because I couldn't advance anymore in the plot even reading walkthroughs because some event wasn't triggering or something,

Independence War 2

Risen 2's great pirate vibe and dialog is the main reason to play it.

The Risen games are fantasy pirate themed RPGs (at least games 2 and 3 in the series).

Tempest is another fantasy pirate themed mainly nautical action game with some RPG elements.

Man O' War Corsair: Warhammer Naval Battles.

And then there's Corsairs.

If you're looking for a "straight" pirate experience -- and since you own the Sea Dogs games -- I'd suggest looking into the brilliant and extensive modding community for those games.

It's not on GOG but look into Akella's Pirates of the Caribbean 2003 game ("acquire it" as need be, it's not sold on any digital distributor) and maybe look into the "New Horizons" mod for it. It was originally going to be Sea Dogs 2 I believe.

Feral blue is going to sell on gog.com