Posted July 11, 2018
Bookwyrm627: [...] the initial interest in Flub's avatar (was she trying to lynch or out a PR on D1?) [...] I didn't like the PR hunt aspect, [...]
cristigale's claim/argument since the beginning has been that she thinks flubbucket's current avatar (and previous ones, as per post #206) were AI. You felt/thought that she was PR hunting. Do you think she's lying about her motive of looking into the flubbucket avatar business? How certain are you that you're not projecting your own take on the matter? If you think that scum!cristigale is PR hunting here, that would mean that you think flubbucket's town. Would that be because your starting thought is "scum!cristigale is PR hunting", or is there something about his play that supports it? If the latter, could you point out what it is you see as such? This very post suggests that you don't, so that brings me back to why you're so convinced that she's PR hunting.
SirPrimalform: 1 and 2 are both reasonable things to assume but assuming too much is generally a bad thing in a closed set up.
3 is unlikely but not unreasonable. [...]
You're not actually answering his questions #2 and #3. 3 is unlikely but not unreasonable. [...]
elebutterfly: [...] To answer the original, for what it's worth: I read sharing reads on everyone freely, à la Joe, as town because it leaves a clear paper trail of suspicion pattern and indicates independent thought is going on about every player, rather than sliding along with whatever wagon is moving. [...]
*reads elebutterfly's reply, checks back the original comment & question; reads bler144's comment on the patented bler144-dodge; rereads elebutterfly's reply* I think we can agree that you did pull a bler144-dodge here after all.
Could you go back to my post #347 and reread the relevant part, then give answering another try?
adaliabooks isn't playing.
bler144: [...] He has greater attention to detail than the average bear, so he will invariably ask you about some minor detail you barely remember from 18 days earlier that you said off the cuff and barely remember even saying and he will demand you explain every facet of what you were thinking. [...]
Sounds like a PITA to play with; will avoid at all cost. bler144: [...] 1. Yeah, I wasn't particularly worried about that early in D1 though. For one, in these games I end up being wrong even when I think I have a heavily researched, thoroughly considered argument. For two, if I can't clear/defend myself as town based on that out of the gate D1 and most of the day still to play, I probably deserve to get lynched, and at least I feel confident I'd leave a good wagon behind. [...]
Except that I'm not limiting it to D1, or give D1 things a pass. bler144: [...] she didn't hound the person who said they thought they knew what the claim was for details, [...]
Is this something you'd expect scum!cristigale to do assuming she was PR hunting? I wouldn't. bler144: Please, the patented bler144-dodge is to address the question with an answer that is true yet completely dissatisfying to the asker. The bler144-answer contains 8 pages of details and detritus you would rather not have bothered with.
Based on your embedded quotes, she just didn't answer. [...]
Well, judging by the answer she gave in post #374, it looks like the way your patented dodge works wasn't lost on her. Based on your embedded quotes, she just didn't answer. [...]
[emphasis added ]
Excuse me, sir, I believe I never spoke of rear ends, misspelled or otherwise.