He's probably using the scumtell pooka mentioned above, where lift being vigilant early is scummy. I Think someone mentioned it last game at some point.

is this right, fish?

Only go for lynching the lurkers if you have actually put in the work scumhunting and found nothing conclusive about any of the active participants. I'd rather have a lynch of someone who yields more information than someone who barely shows up giving us just about nothing to work with.

So far nothing is popping up at me, save DrKoba's posts being a mixed bag of "probably newbie, probably scum, probably overwhelmed." I don't think catventurer is scummy even with his self-vote. Lift exists. Micro hasn't voted everyone in one single post.

Still nothing to warrant a vote.

im more experienced at mafia than you think. I pr hunt as town and more.
As for hero shot, im commonly a target of ego players thinking they're about to carry.

i have arrived on the thread, hello everyone old and new B)

Well, I'd still like to know who's the wallpost guy. I don't really like you calling yourself an experienced player yet not answering a question that I bet I'm not the only one asking.

you'll find playing with me frustrating then becauae i tend to avoid answering questions i deem unnecessary to answer

Im currently sandbagging to disallow people from playing around me and shall "wake up" when i feel ive found a confident scumread

Also.if im being honest i think i mixed your posts with supplement and just binned it as town lmao

Update - Still not entirely here. I've mostly recovered from the seizure images. It's only 12:30pm, should be 100% in another hour or two... getting lots of cat cuddles and love sponging. <3

I disagree in our current circumstances. I had only a minor issue with the catman but this is something I've revised with his later posts. As their is no scum scent anywhere else this leads me to fully focus on people who are adding nothing to the game. Regardless of role they are not helping the town cause and should not be rewarded for this. They could be scum hiding in plain sight or merely town players who will not help the cause. Either way they should be punished. And I hold this tactical opinion in a varitey of social deduction games.

If the lurkers join the game and help to solve I will obviously look to revise my position if they seem genuine.

You actually admit you don't have any scum reads yourself. So what do we do in the case? Lynch those in hiding IMHO. Otherwise what do you suggest?

Ofcourse if some Mafia type slips and shows a tell we obviously re-evaluate but at the moment we're at very low info levels.

If anyone thinks I'm wrong with my game analysis I welcome to being advised as I've not being at all successful in this game with either role. But I am trying to improve how I analyse the game

Assuming RVS stands for random voting I have no issue if you have any reasonable analysis of the current state of the game beyond it being random. While I've poked a few people I don't think anything is too obvious with anyone yet. If you perceive something suspect that I've missed please feel free to bring it to our attention

Just saw someone call me."probably newbie" which is funny considering im playing my champs semifinals game next month after being advanced via first place votes xD

Anyways i am busier than I thought i would be rn outside of this game so I'm likely going to be not so active day 1, but me being inactive still ends up being top posting in most communities so we good.

Atp my 2 strongest reads are to never kill the 2 people i mentioned in my last post.

I Don't like this. I Don't like this at all.

Unvote Catv

Vote DkKoba1

This post is marked as edit.

So is this one.

If you haven't read the rules, please do. The forum software here has a quirk that everyone needs to account for to make sure this doesn't happen.

Since you're new and likely not used to it I'm letting you off with a warning. If it happens again there will be a punishment.

Okay, we'll go with that for now.

Unvote DkKoba1

Vote razza

lol my posting style is inherently rapid fire so very cool. being limited to 1 post per 10 minutes when people arent being active is :/