It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussion[Forum Game] GOG Mafia game #77: Masters of the Universe Edition(765 posts)(765 posts)
(765 posts)
Pages:
1
10
20
21
22
23
24
30
40
51
This is my favourite topic
Posted August 01, 2022
Also, enjoy your monday morning, everyone.
Posted August 01, 2022
avatar
supplementscene: So you're claiming it was a reaction test, okay. Assuming you are Town, what info do you think you garnered from your reaction test? What are your take aways here?

Did Razza's reaction seem Liberal to you or no indication of alignment?

What did you think of the wagon building on Razza? Town players looking to rightly lynch someone invesitgated as Mafia? Or opportunistic Scum looking to lynch a town player based on what you say was a joke.

What do you think of the voters for the wagon building on yourself now, which makes you the current leader. I can certainly understand Razza being upset with you if he is Town

I'm holding off on voting for you just yet as I didn't actually realise it was a investigation claim until Joe highlighted the matter.
How do you feel about the fact you never got anwer to this post?
Posted August 01, 2022
avatar
supplementscene: So you're claiming it was a reaction test, okay. Assuming you are Town, what info do you think you garnered from your reaction test? What are your take aways here?

Did Razza's reaction seem Liberal to you or no indication of alignment?

What did you think of the wagon building on Razza? Town players looking to rightly lynch someone invesitgated as Mafia? Or opportunistic Scum looking to lynch a town player based on what you say was a joke.

What do you think of the voters for the wagon building on yourself now, which makes you the current leader. I can certainly understand Razza being upset with you if he is Town

I'm holding off on voting for you just yet as I didn't actually realise it was a investigation claim until Joe highlighted the matter.
avatar
Vitek: How do you feel about the fact you never got anwer to this post?
Good call, I completely forgot about it but it does seem remiss or suspect on DkKoba1 part for sure. While he did clarify it wasn't a legit claim, this is suspect
Posted August 01, 2022
So we're in our final day and we don't have any sizable wagons. Can I suggest we all make a list of prefered lynches so we can avoid not lynching today
Posted August 01, 2022
ugh i’m gonna have to post this in two parts, it’s not long, gog just won’t let me send it all for some reason.

avatar
supplementscene: Wait I did get off this wagon as soon as I realised both were likely Town. I only got on it because my experience was of both being none town so I thought they were both none town. I haven't played a game were lovers were town at all
oh! my apologies, i must’ve missed that. i’m not someone who would continue my vote on you if that’s the case so
unvote scene
i’ve still got my eye on you though… xD

vote Frost
^^ for the reasons stated in my listing.
Posted August 01, 2022
9 hours 10 minutes left, so hurry
Posted August 01, 2022
avatar
Ambiti0nZ: Hello, beautiful goglodytes. I am back to catching up. I gotta say, things look to be getting interesting from where I left off. Will continue with this process and hopefully I will be done in a few hours.
I'll fucking mod-murder you, do you get that?!?!

avatar
Ambiti0nZ: One of my favorite songs is The Last Stand by Koda
That's better. Don't test me, bitch.

avatar
Ambiti0nZ: I have a question. In the spirit of being better safe than sorry I cited a song and the artist above, but the bolded part requires some clarification. The way I read this, and this entirely deals with semantics, is that I am required to post as such following both your public announcement and the end of D2, not through. Now, I believe you meant the latter, but since I would like to receive official mod clarification for this despite my own fault in not checking ahead the official announcement, I think it is fair to begin my sentence with this post.
You stop posting songs (and I'm using the term "song" for the lack of a better one - it doesn't necessarily have to feature spoken word, it can be a classical music piece for example) when you wake up on D3, assuming you do. Your last song will be in your last post of D2.



VOTE COUNT (up to #321)

supplementscene 3 - PookaMustard (#251), Catventurer (#294), Ambiti0nZ (#315)
Lifthrasil 2 - DkKoba1 (#211), FrostburnPhoenix (#292)
DkKoba 1 - Lifthrasil (#230)
Vitek 1 - JoeSapphire (#299)
JoeSapphire 1 - Catte (#33)
detective_razza 1 - Vitek (#41)
FrostburnPhoenix 2 - supplementscene (#269), detective_razza (#320)
Ambiti0nZ (MARKED BY YOG) - has to list favorite song + its performer in each post until the end of D2 (assuming survival till then) or get devoured (mod-killed).

Closest to lynch - supplementscene at L-4. It takes 7 to lynch.

Not voting - Microfish_1

Day 1 will end in approximately 9 hours.
Posted August 01, 2022
avatar
Vitek: How come you are calling me out for inactivity but the whole game you ahve not made single mention of Micro?
i could also have called out catte for inactivity, i’m sorry, please don’t take it too personally.

—

i also agree with scene, we should start looking at potential lunches for D1- we don’t have many reliable wagons to go off.
if i had to say, i’d say i’d start to look at koba and frost- though if anyone has any other leads or players they want to look into, please share.

i’ll list my reads on people to start and hopefully get other people’s opinions too:

lift: town. i think they’ve made a good few points, though maybe some people think otherwise?? please elaborate on that if you do, i’d like to understand.
catv: town lover?
pooka: town. i don’t have any reason to believe otherwise at the moment.
catte: unsure/ town. inactive though from last game and last games meta i believe it’s not out of the ordinary for town catte to be inactive, because they’re so used to be mafia xD though, i could be wrong. for now i don’t see any reason to punch them for inactivity.
joe: unsure lover? i honestly have a scummy read on joe, he’s up to something, but with the lover reveal i don’t want to risk anything if he did turn out to be town, then we lose two town…
micro: unsure. a little inactive, i don’t have much of a read.
vitek: unsure. a little inactive, i don’t have much of a read.
ambition: a little inactive, though they have their reasons and i want to be understanding of that.
scene: unsure. i just don’t know. i did have a slight scum read but now i’m just not sure.
frost: unsure/ scum. for the reasons listed above, you acting a lil crazy frost- major sus. it could, like koba, be their okay style but i don’t know…
koba: unsure/ scum. again for the way they reacted to everyone else after their beginning of D1 play, it could just be the way they are- they’ve stated they’re a ‘manipulative player’, but i don’t know… none of it sits right with me.

hopefully that’s everyone xD i usually miss someone by accident,,
Posted August 01, 2022
To give some reads of mine, I am most leaning scum on Lift. The way he got stuck up on the policy lynch reminds me of this argument I saw him do when he was mafia with me in one of my latest games. It spiraled into bigger argument, where Lift just wasn't able to back down from his mechanics based argument and it was hard to not bus him as fellow scum. As dedo said there:
"You feel like scum!Lift to me who is trying to make something stick."
And it was correct observation.

I did not like Phoenix as well. As I said in the past, they seem very opportunistic and just want to see someone lynched. Then, AmbitionZ said they were like that in they town play as well and the way they handled the lovers claim make sense as well if you consider how Frost understood the rule, so I am not sure there. I guess I wouldn't mind see them lynched, but I am much more reluctant than I was before today.

Another one is scene. I find his unhealthy fixation on CatV alarming. It's like he is looking for any reason to jump back on those lovers. Compared to that and the way he seems to hound people for answers, I consider the post I quoted earlier interesting. He put many questions there but was never bothered there were no answers. I wonder if it was just for show.

I wouldn't mind razza or Micro either. I meantioned earlier how razza is calling out people for inactivity but he hasn't mentioned Micro at all while Micro is probably the least active player of all. Could be buddies and razza is avoiding mentioning Micro. Then razza's reaction to DK was quite towny and that's fair amount of points for them, so if I were to lynch one, it would be Micro.

I think I wouldn't mind Pooka either. I have no reads on him and this is one way to get them. :-)

I am not up for lynches of Joe, CatV, AmbitionZ, I think Dk either. I find the fake claim thing NAI, but other than that I don't have much reason to place them either way.

I am missing one person... yeah catte. I think it is usual catte, not too engaged but as mafie he is more eager to jump at stuff, so more on town side I would say.

If I were to put it on list of willingness to lynch, I would say
Lift
Scene
Micro
Frostburn
Pooka
razza
Dk
Ambition
Catte
CatV
...
...
...
...
...
...
Joe (it's just impossible for me to harm Joe)
Posted August 01, 2022
avatar
Vitek: To give some reads of mine, I am most leaning scum on Lift. The way he got stuck up on the policy lynch reminds me of this argument I saw him do when he was mafia with me in one of my latest games. It spiraled into bigger argument, where Lift just wasn't able to back down from his mechanics based argument and it was hard to not bus him as fellow scum. As dedo said there:
"You feel like scum!Lift to me who is trying to make something stick."
And it was correct observation.
oh that’s interesting! i don’t have any meta with lift whatsoever, they were mod for my first and last game, so that’s really interesting-

thank you for your observations!^
Posted August 01, 2022
Sigh, it seems I'm most likely getting lynched today as my wagon is the longest and I seem to be on most other peoples scum lists. I did my best people but it seems I'm very bad at this game

I will ask you hold off on hammer until the last couple of hours of the day for any final discussion.

avatar
Vitek: To give some reads of mine, I am most leaning scum on Lift. The way he got stuck up on the policy lynch reminds me of this argument I saw him do when he was mafia with me in one of my latest games. It spiraled into bigger argument, where Lift just wasn't able to back down from his mechanics based argument and it was hard to not bus him as fellow scum. As dedo said there:
"You feel like scum!Lift to me who is trying to make something stick."
And it was correct observation.

I did not like Phoenix as well. As I said in the past, they seem very opportunistic and just want to see someone lynched. Then, AmbitionZ said they were like that in they town play as well and the way they handled the lovers claim make sense as well if you consider how Frost understood the rule, so I am not sure there. I guess I wouldn't mind see them lynched, but I am much more reluctant than I was before today.

Another one is scene. I find his unhealthy fixation on CatV alarming. It's like he is looking for any reason to jump back on those lovers. Compared to that and the way he seems to hound people for answers, I consider the post I quoted earlier interesting. He put many questions there but was never bothered there were no answers. I wonder if it was just for show.
Interesting take on Lift. I did town read him throughout but unless someone moves to Peonix's wagon in the next few hours I'll have to move to him as he's realistically the only other viable wagon that isn't yours truly.
Posted August 01, 2022
avatar
supplementscene: I will ask you hold off on hammer until the last couple of hours of the day for any final discussion.
Why? So we can have another Chinese fire drill situation, end the day with a no-lynch and escape the lynch?

Like I keep saying time and again, the final 24 hours of D1 should be for securing a lynch. If you need to discuss more, where were you in the previous 6 days? :)
Posted August 01, 2022
Something about the way Lift switched focus from DK to me made me think this is not scum lift.

I'm more convinced scene is town than I am lift is, but I've been wrong before.
Posted August 01, 2022
avatar
JoeSapphire: Something about the way Lift switched focus from DK to me made me think this is not scum lift.

I'm more convinced scene is town than I am lift is, but I've been wrong before.
You had Lift in your mafia pool 10 hours ago.
Besides him there was me, for the usual, he is not suspecting me, he must be scum, that feels like we re doing over and over for decade and that's because we do. Then there are mostly lurkers, Micro and catte and then there is Ambition, who you say you can very much believe to be scum. On what basis do you believe it?
Posted August 01, 2022
avatar
JoeSapphire: Something about the way Lift switched focus from DK to me made me think this is not scum lift.

I'm more convinced scene is town than I am lift is, but I've been wrong before.
avatar
Vitek: You had Lift in your mafia pool 10 hours ago.
yeah but the guy's in hospital...

avatar
Vitek: Besides him there was me, for the usual, he is not suspecting me, he must be scum, that feels like we re doing over and over for decade and that's because we do. Then there are mostly lurkers, Micro and catte and then there is Ambition, who you say you can very much believe to be scum. On what basis do you believe it?
hm. It feels more nuanced than 'doesn't sus me' this time but I guess you're right.

Partly because AZ hasn't done anything to make me think isn't mafia (except for an all-caps town-claim p302 which I do find pretty compelling...)
but also I know it's kinda cheaty logic but the way dedo's handling the punishment made me think dedo didn't want to damage the mafia team, so went "alright - if you suffer because of this it's your own dang fault"
But I shouldn't try to guess what the mod is thinking.


I looked at that scum pool and thought no we can't have three scums here. Someone has snuck into my poe.

It could be pook. Could be scene. Could be frostb.

mm... Pooka Frostburn mafia team...

I'm just making stuff up now. idk.

unvote vitek

myeh. voting scene feels wrong. voting lift feels wrong. I'm sad now
Pages:
1
10
20
21
22
23
24
30
40
51
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussion[Forum Game] GOG Mafia game #77: Masters of the Universe Edition(765 posts)(765 posts)
(765 posts)