supplementscene: I can't see a counter claim, because you've looked the most likely Neutral player.
Technically GR could counterclaim -- that would explain his vote-hopping. He does not care which way the wind blows.
---
supplementscene: If they all vote for me again Town have lost but even if that doesn't happen, figuring out the remainding Town player from the 3 of them also isn't a given.
I won't vote against you. You can't be mafia.
If you were - we would have to ask ourselves - what is your scumbuddy doing?!
Let's look at the vote progression at twilight
if you were mafia:
It can't be joppo because you both were at each others throat the entire day.
It can't be GR because at 1-1-1 vote there would be no reason for him to cast a vote on his scummbuddy.
It can't be me because at 2-1-1 I would not put my scummbuddy at L-1.
It could be Lift though, seeing how he did post 1 comment of your suspect behaviour, but has otherwise not engaged too much against you.
AND He is the one who, despite recently calling out that yes, scene is indeed scummy, came out with the -
actually... we shouldn't vote today... a NL is town-beneficial. Oh, right... Lift is now confirmed Townie. It could be microfish - microfish, also called you scummy, but has not otherwise engaged against you. Much less cast a vote.
Oh, right... Microfish has now come out as Neutral. ---
supplementscene: Atlo said I'd played well if Town or Mafia and then voted for me
I'm glad that I retracted my vote then!
You have to understand it from my point-of-view: Time is running short. We
need a lynch. We are currently at 1-1-1. If I put a vote on GR we are at 1-1-1-1. Scene's last post is calling out
new scummy things made by you. Screw it... there's only so much time I can sacrifice. You are our 1 best shot.
Had Lift not realised an NL is actually town beneficial I would not have retracted my vote.
Had Lift been right about micro being scum - the game could've ended right there and then.
Had you been right about micro being TN
(Heh, you actually were! :D) who sides with scum - the game could've ended right there and then.
---
This all leaves us at:
GR & joppo are both scum.
The only question is - whom do we vote for first?
---
One last thing...
It was mafia who stated this, but I have to agree with them...
supplementscene: CatV, who's confirmed Town, decided to message Scene because she found him the most Town player in the game.
Just because a confirmed townie messaged you - that does not make you a certified townie.
Atlo: CatVenturer [...]
in the very first game we played together I was
convinced she must be Town.
Had I been FN in that game - I would have messaged scum!catV.