supplementscene: I'd also ask the question 'why hasn't Yogs wagon grown quicker and why are there only 2 votes'. Maybe 1 town player knows Yogs is Town because he is the Friendly Neighbour. I think I might have seen someone hint at that through a subliminal message. But I could be reading too much into that
The problem with this is that, if Yog is the Friendly neighbor (FN) then whoever he communicated with should have come forward and vouched for him. Such claim simply wouldn't be counterclaimed; no mafioso would be stupid enough to reveal themselves that way. Thus the FN is pretty much the same as an IC.
OR the FN might have chosen a scum player. Well, the scum could lie and say they got no such message but it's a very stupid way to get themselves in a 1vs1 conflict that will certainly get them lynched sooner or later. So they would tell the truth and the FN gets trusted like an IC either way.
OR the FN chose Trent. In that case, tough luck.
So, assuming Yog is the FN and he did not choose Trent, why isn't anyone coming forward to vouch for him? They know Yog is a townie, why would they let us waste valuable time suspecting him? Thus the only possibilities are that Yog is not the FN or he is but the target of Yog's message didn't survive the Night.
Catventurer: If someone makes a role claim and won't state what their role is, we shouldn't be assigning a role to them. It's going only to create problems if the person who actually has the role tries to make a claim on it. What's going to happen if the actual Friendly Neighbor comes forward to claim their actual role and that person isn't Yog when you've already decided in your mind that Yog is the Friendly Neighbor?
This is the only role where that is not a concern. A scum lying about being the FN won't have someone coming forward to vouch for them. They will be so easy to identify they might as well come forward carrying a "I'm scum" placard.
Atlo: Screw it, doesn't really matter if it's a make-believe vote, that I'll eventually turn real anyway, or real from the beginning. Yogsloth may still comment. Someone else has to do the hammer.
BAD move. We had games in the past where scum took advantage of a player being in L-1 and hammered.
We have time to talk. Let's not waste it. The more the scum talks the greater the chance they will let something slip.
You get scum points in my view for appearing in a rush to get a lynch, even if it's of someone we all suspect. On the other hand MrKrabsWallet get townie points for the opposite reason.
yogsloth: if I ever do criticize the modding, I will do so directly and by throwing things
also FYI I'm frigging dying sick so I'm doing my best right now just to sit in a chair
I... have to admit in my experience that statement above is true. Yog didn't spare the mod's feelings in a game he felt was stacked against us (the scumteam)
And I'm sorry you're sick and I appreciate you making the effort to play despite the bad moment you're in.
joppo: Okay I'll bite. Who would you have aimed at, and why? Assuming scum!Yog would have no idea who the only remaining Town PR is.
yogsloth: TRENT!!!! bwah ha ha. He just assumes I'm mafia 98.46% of the time. And if he's Town, he's usually right.
LOL at this! I was expecting any answer but not this one.
Still... I don't know what to make of it. I feel tempted to say that "scum would never say something so daring", but this is Yogsloth I'm talking about. Scum!Yog would do it without missing a beat.
yogsloth: Side note as I'm writing this up while still scrolling, do you guys notice how everybody is talking about me and my "what does my thing do?" post, and it's making people take stands and interact and place votes? WEIRD HOW THAT WORKS OUT
Maybe but we have a very limited number of mislynches we can afford. With the jailkeeper gone there's no way to avoid NKs. 3 mislynches means game over and we already had one.
Catventurer: I can and will confirm that joppo first PMed me on December 5th in relation to a kitten that was refusing to drink water and has been asking for my advise.
You need to learn to assert with the kitten that you're in charge...
Thank you. I will keep that in mind.
@pooka: Exactly like Catv said, there wasn't even the slightest mention of anything related to Mafia in our PMs.
@everyone: don't worry I won't turn this game into a "cat advice" thread. I will keep that subject for our PMs.
All caught up now. I will think more of questions that still need asking, hopefully before I hit the hay.
joppo: Sorry for appearing AFK all day. The truth is I have been reading but we have a small kitty at home for a few weeks now (Catventurer may confirm; I've been asking her advice). When my wife is away, the kitty stays around me, walking in the keyboard, lieing in the mousepad and attacking the mouse's cord whenever I attempt to use the computer. She makes it impossible to post anything. And when my wife comes home I have a break from the kitty but then I have to help her with household chores. Thus here I am after both went to sleep. You need to learn to assert with the kitten that you're in charge, otherwise you never will be. The cat brain is 90% structurally similar to the human brain. Right now she's a baby cat. Eventually she'll turn into a cat teenager and will start testing her boundaries even more so in terms of what she can and cannot get away with. 
