It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Great job everyone! Great yeet and play.

I really can't stand the "I'm lazy and ineffective when I'm Town" meta because it's such a copout when one rolls mafia and then just has to ignore the game to win, but such is life. Lookin' at you, catte.

Not one person looked at the painting hanging on my guy's wall
<--------------
avatar
Atlo: First question: Are my results even reliable? What happens when a godfather is lynched? Do mafia retain their roles or do they get ''promoted/upgraded'' ?
I can pretty much guarantee any cop results in this game will now be totally reliable.

Because:

a) We don't do stupid bastard shit around these parts, unless it's specifically:
b) a "Godfather" role, which am now deadski.

You can probably just drop your results now, unless you've got a red (mafia) check, in which case maybe you hope that person starts talking to incriminate his remaining buddy somehow.
avatar
Atlo: You mean investigation report?

Oh regarding that I will ask about advice regarding game mechanics and what to do.
avatar
Lifthrasil: What to do is easy: you are basically confirmed Town, with buck being proven Scum. We need all the information we can get, you don't have any reason to keep anything secret. So it is best for Town if you share all the information you have, including whom you targeted and what result you got.
The reason I though withholding information could be useful is ''let mafia dig their own grave''. If I out one as mafia then their interactions ''I don't think X is mafia'' matches ''I cannot imagine Y to be mafia'' would solve finding the last(?(hopefully)) member easier. Maybe a too simple approach, but I think I have proven to have a simple mindset.
In the interests of fairness I will still wait for others to voice their opinions.

avatar
Telika: I *think* cop+bodyguard may be a tad OP for town, balance-wise (to the point where I suspected, this night, Scene to lie about his role because of that).
???
Did you type that up before the day had started?! Scene is now confirmed Bodyguard.
The moment I started shouting at the top of my lungs: ''I AM TOWN COP!!!! I INVESTIGATED CATT, hence the ''I have reason to believe Catt is innocent!!!'' was... because I am townee with different role but had the Catt excuse just so?! That I am mafia and still with dedo and joe removing their votes and hence dispersing Bucktooths wagon, still throw bucktooth under the bus?!

What possible paranoid thought could you even have to think I am not Town Cop!?

avatar
Telika: As a representative of the oppressed french-speaking minority of Switzerland let me squeak a formal protest at that.

#notallswiss
merde! merde! merde!
I had actually considered that, but thought ''what are the chances?''. =P

avatar
yogsloth: Not one person looked at the painting hanging on my guy's wall
<--------------
It's too small! I can't see it!

---
*Investigation reveal in ~17 hours*
avatar
Telika: I *think* the Buck's cop claim was not really planned with his team (unless they really tried to sacrifice him in order to identify a real cop), because being a Godfather, he knew that there would be a real cop in the game.
I doubt that was intentional. The Godfather's ability is that he shows up as town-aligned if investigated. While it tells the entire mafia team that there's a cop on the town-side, they really don't want to be sacrificing the Godfather - especially when they know there is a cop in the game that is still out there. I think that it is more likely that mafia team wasn't prepared to have the Godfather lynched on Day 2, otherwise there would not have been an attempt to role claim cop.

If you're going to falsify a role claim, don't pick something that you know is in the game.
I think it is likely that mafia was completely unprepared for Buck needing to fake a role claim.


avatar
Atlo: For CatVenturer; said Giant cat: *attachments*
Maomolin is about the only good thing about Ranma 1/2. Sorry. T_T
Unfortunately, I associate that anime with someone who was fidelity challenged.
I guess you need adalia's GOG extension that allows you to enlarge avatars

My joke just goes *poofle* in a cloud of tiny pixels
avatar
Atlo: *Investigation reveal in ~17 hours*
Why not just reveal now or do you need some clarification from Pooka first?
avatar
Atlo: For CatVenturer; said Giant cat: *attachments*
avatar
Catventurer: Maomolin is about the only good thing about Ranma 1/2. Sorry. T_T
Unfortunately, I associate that anime with someone who was fidelity challenged.
It's ok. =)
I'm not an avid anime watcher. Do you have any idea how long it took to even come up with ''favorite anime'' much less justify it?
I remember there being not many frames per picture in some episodes, but when I researched the show and rewatched some older episode I was actually surprised that the movement was not that bad. So I disagree on the fidelity challenged part. A matter of taste.
I don't watch anime.

If you showed anime in a movie theater, then crazy-glued my nuts to a cannonball and fired it into the theater, I still wouldn't watch anime.

If you filled that theater with beer, and strippers were drowning in it, and only I could save them, I still wouldn't watch anime.
avatar
yogsloth: Not one person looked at the painting hanging on my guy's wall
<--------------
Oooh I hadn't. Don't know since when it was there.

But I had already decided that Csanj was the mason. By elimination (hecking the posts of other candidates, spotting what they wouldn't have typed as masons), and also with Ambz's weird "chaos and mayhem" answer to Csan. That's why you're not among my suspects.

avatar
Telika: I *think* cop+bodyguard may be a tad OP for town, balance-wise (to the point where I suspected, this night, Scene to lie about his role because of that).
avatar
Atlo: ???
Did you type that up before the day had started?! Scene is now confirmed Bodyguard.
The moment I started shouting at the top of my lungs: ''I AM TOWN COP!!!! I INVESTIGATED CATT, hence the ''I have reason to believe Catt is innocent!!!'' was... because I am townee with different role but had the Catt excuse just so?! That I am mafia and still with dedo and joe removing their votes and hence dispersing Bucktooths wagon, still throw bucktooth under the bus?!

What possible paranoid thought could you even have to think I am not Town Cop!?
Not sure if I/you understand what you/I meant. But during the night, as I was thinking of these roles and Scene was "alive", I mused that he could still have lied about being a bodyguard. The rest is just an opinon on the setting. I think that a cop+bodyguard may be a tad strong as a combo. And so, if there hadn't been a Godfather to confirm to the mafia that there is a cop, I think that false claiming cop would have been a good strategy for Buck (it would have been rational of them to imagine being the only one claiming the role, by assuming that there would be no real cop in addition to a bodyguard). The fact they knew they had a Godfather makes their claim baffling.

Anyway, these are now speculations (and opinions) unrelated to the current investigation.
avatar
Catventurer: I associate that anime with someone who was fidelity challenged.
avatar
Atlo: the movement was not that bad. So I disagree on the fidelity challenged part. A matter of taste.
Uh, I did interpret it as this show having been liked (or watched, co-watched, talked about) by an acquaintance of Catv who didn't exactly keep faithfulness at the deepest of their core values.
avatar
Telika: Okay, people.
Have you ever watched Columbo? You're the other guy.


avatar
supplementscene: Goodbye cruel world.
Well done!


avatar
PookaMustard: "Who's Ranma?" Kitami went.
Fake news, I've seen a few Ranma's back in the day.


avatar
yogsloth: Not one person looked at the painting hanging on my guy's wall
Fake news. I even hinted about it to Telika but he ain't Columbo so I'm not holding it against him.


@Atlo, as others have pointed out there is no reason to not share whatever your result is (even if it's just to clear a Townie) Today. Scene gave you one free shot after you came out but you're likely going down Tonight and you don't want to carry your findings with you.


My money is on Lift by the way but I'd love a Joe incrimination or a dedo Town confirmation so I can tell Telika the rest of the joke.
FYI I finally had a limited chance to talk to Ambition near the end of Day 2, despite him being deadski, and his scumspect list was Buck, catventurer, and dedo.

Then Buck got violated by a tentacle monster, which is what I assume happens to all anime characters regardless of time, space, or plot, and the window to talk to Ambition closed.

So now I'm just plain-jane vanilla Town.

But, yeah, Cop + Bodyguard is OP for a small-ish mafia game. Even with a Godfather.
avatar
yogsloth: But, yeah, Cop + Bodyguard is OP for a small-ish mafia game. Even with a Godfather.
We also have a claimed Tracker.
avatar
yogsloth: But, yeah, Cop + Bodyguard is OP for a small-ish mafia game. Even with a Godfather.
avatar
dedoporno: We also have a claimed Tracker.
Whaaat? There's no f'n way

Cop, Bodyguard, two masons AND a tracker?

avatar
JoeSapphire: aw ded op

My role is tracker, i observed telika night 1, i don't think telika is scum.

Bucktooth's vote looks super scummy. Atlo's teasing is lol
Ummmmmmmm

...


and here comes the point, where as good lil townies, we must decide between "mass role claim to break the game" or "let's not because we don't want to piss off trent"
avatar
Telika: Okay, people.
avatar
dedoporno: Have you ever watched Columbo? You're the other guy.
If our game was Columbo, you're saying that Telika is the guest star right?