Posted November 05, 2022
Catventurer: I said that if I had to pick between Lift and yourself on Day 1 that I was more confident about Lift being Town at that time than yourself.
Okay, yeah. I had misread it as you assuming that we were of different affiliations, but it was just a hypothetical premise. Too bad, i was hoping that you had found some sort of clue on that. Catventurer: With newbie help posts specifically, I treat them as separate entities from the game itself. A new player asking questions needs to be able to trust whatever answer they get and for that reason, we should be given honest answers only.
I don't treat anything separately. But to clarify once again : I wasn't suspecting Lifth to deliberately, coonsciously try to mislead people with a help post. I suspected an unconscious bias of his - knowing that Csanj was town and therefore forgetting to give mafia gameplay info. No machiavellian intent of his, but some sort of freudian slip by omission. To push the blaspheme further with an extreme example : It's like, players will not try to mislead us with fake real life info (that would be cheating), but could theoretically still make accidental slips when giving real life info ("I have my mum's funeral, so I might not be here for the nightkill" "for the what!?" "oops"). Fair or unfair, other players would notice.
Catventurer: I do apologize for the delay and making you wait. As we get to know each other more, you're going to find with me that it's not unusual for me to give the appearance of ignoring something then replying to it later.
Yeah, but when we don't react chronologically, it gives the impression of "skipping" a question. Which can actually be the case, accidentally or not. I won't play the cat card. Let's just say I'm jaded, and I'll develop post-game.