JoeSapphire: they just don't claim to have done a power on someone they didn't do a power on. that way whatever the roleblocker did it can't be contradicted. If you hadn't thought of doing that yet mafia then there you are, you're welcome. [...]
Hey JoeSapphire, thanks for the lesson! My point was that if they know exactly what the Rolestopper did, they might claim to have done a power on someone they didn't because they know that said PR can't contradict them, which in turn muddles the waters and could even lead to incriminating a townie for the mislynch
JoeSapphire: [...] pretty sure the story we were told is that babark got told his action Night 1 was successful, and yet frostburn is dead. So not phishing, just working with the info we have. [...]
I was referring to what Lifthrasil told babark last Night, not what babark told us yesterDay.
JoeSapphire: [...] And don't call me Keane. [...]
What about Jack, can I call you Jack?
JoeSapphire: [...] I'll understand better when babark tells me why was he asking.
Is it babark that's just gone away for three days? bah.
They just don't look to me like the questions of "I should have saved that guy why is he dead?" it looks more like questioning why the mafia chose to target frostburn. [...]
That's fair, and yes, it's babark who won't be back until Sunday evening.
As for the last part - I have thoughts, but I'll wait for babark to reply first.
JoeSapphire: [...] Because he town read me when it would have been easy for him not to, and because when he turned up at the end of day to vote bucktooth
he didn't seem interested in trying to have any control of the situation.[...]
[emphasis added]
Could you point to where this town-read took place? Also go into what you mean with the part I highlighted?
JoeSapphire: [...] We've worked together for a year. I can't confirm whether she's faking naivety or not because I don't know if she's mafia or not. [...]
We seem to have a misunderstanding here, and it's on me. Let me try this again:
-- What I meant in my post #765 about her naivete is that it strikes me as a characteristic of her as a person in RL that leaks into her game, and read your comment in post #777 as you saying "yeah, I think it is... actually, I'm not sure".
-- I read her comment in post #779 as her confirming my assessment - correct me if I read this incorrectly,
@detective_razza.
-- This made me go back to your comment, and ask you to clarify if I read her comment and yours correctly, but your reply here tells me that I misunderstood you, and that we weren't talking about the same thing.
So, now that I've hopefully explained myself better, would you say that, based on your experience with her through work, the characterisation she gave herself as a person is fair?
Note: if the answer is yes, whether she's using that as mafia isn't part of the question.
JoeSapphire: [...] why does it matter how serious I'm being? I'm wading through this list of your questions and you can't give me three names? [...]
I can, just wanted to know what went through your head when you made the post; thanks for indulging me.
1. dedoporno
2. babark
2. RWarehall
JoeSapphire: [...] Another challenge: Who will to speak passionately in defense of zfr? [...]
Funny, just today I was thinking how ZFR has slid into the background after being in the centre of D1; no more inquiries, more reactionary interactions and fewer in number, as we all seem to have left him alone to happily sit on the town-read he got D1. ZFR's not for toDay, but I've made a note to look into him. Same for Ambiti0nZ.
JoeSapphire: [...] IF BABARK's telling the truth we don't want him to act toNight, because
he can't prevent the kill and there's a greater risk he'll interfere with town's abilities. [...]
[emphasis added]
We don't know that for certain, do we? There's always the case the mafia have a Strongman.
JoeSapphire: [...] - any thoughts on how we should play this?
I just thought we could try co-ordinating RW and Babark, to see if RWarehall gets blocked, but I think that's just a recipe for a dead RWarehall.[...]
I'm against telling PRs what to do, because that's giving mafia a blueprint to refine their own actions.
JoeSapphire: [...] Me and dedo were once a scumteam together that got brutally slaughtered by town no matter HOW many memes I offered to spare his life.
I'll let dedo finish this story and explain why it's relevant - @dedo?
Colour me intrigued. Which game was that?