FrostburnPhoenix: So, vote buck even if i'm 85% sure he's town to prevent NL is good?
That has always been the $1,000,000 question. I've resisted voting a player that I was thoroughly convinced was Town in the past, not often on a Day 1 but I may have then too. It all depends how sure you think you are. At the very least, you can state your opinions as to why/why not, with or without a vote.
There is decent value in getting a lynch to have something to analyze except the same stale arguments from Day 1 and read into the night kill. Often following a no-lynch, Day 2 becomes just a rehashing of Day 1 arguments.
In a perfect world, we find a way to hold off on the clinching vote so Bucktoothgamer gets a response. The question is how much time can we give.