I agree with others that this in particular shouldn't be seen as damning on its own as both keeping it a secret and sharing it have their pros and cons.


Doesn't feel like it. I'd say that if one of them is scum it's more likely it's Cadaver. Sure, he's making a very good effort but he is pretty much required to because of the legacy he got from Mango. Leoric has had "good" aura from the start (although it's starting to wear off and it would be nice if he shifts to a higher gear) and if that's been fabricated - well done!


While I was doing some skimming on the last couple of pages I saw this again and wondered about something:

The way this sentence is phrased suggests that Joe just now realizes he probably wasn't a good pick for the kill. Which would suggest earlier he thought he was a legit target. Why not use the ability in that case? On the other hand, if he knew it wasn't worth it to waste the power why agree with Bookwyrm in this way instead of just saying "I knew I didn't look terribly Townie so I sat on the ability"?

ISN'T a good pick for the kill.

In the upcoming nights.

As in trying to get the mafia to think my shots are spent so they'll waste time trying to kill me isn't likely to be effective.

Ah, OK, that makes more sense. Thanks.

That is absolutely unpossible and I'm am never never wrong.

I thought no one was going to do it so I haven't prepared anything.

I'm just gonna go back-to-basics style.

You've earned yourself a coffee spew there pardner. Thank you.

Are YOU scum?

NEWBIE CARD!

AbsoLUTEly not with a long list a superlatives, untralatives, and megaultratives.


Short answer, No.






Long answer.

I feel a bit overwhelmed by so many posts too, and my English, it can be weird, but my Italian is as well. Not being able to edit all my frequent mistakes is painful.
Real life news: I'll spend the next days helping a friend in a place without internet - no wi-fi, no network. My avaibility will be limited - so don't panic if I don't answer PMs at 3 AM this time XD

I'm learning about roles and trying to make sense of the game. I feel powerless and not smart enough. This game is more frustrating than I expected!
Quoting like Cadaver, mentioning the posts by number, looks like a great quality of life emprovement.

542 JoeSapphire:
"mangdaver - mango wrote very little, cadaver's written a lot. sus?"
I don't think so, because they are 2 different people. Mango wasn't maybe interested in playing or had some IRL problem.

545 Cadaver:
"It was discussed how NL is not helping Town, some players might disagree of course, yet I agree that NL is not helping much. So I think that Mafia hides among those who have not hammered poor GH. "
This is scummy. Precisely because it was said that NL is not helping town, I voted for the one who started it - Joe. Could have it been a provocation? Also Mango didn't even vote, contributing to the NL. And that would be you. So, nice try, but...

So Mango and I are different people, but Mango didn't vote GH meaning? Care to elaborate?

I believe she means your slot rather than you personally. You're unfortunately carrying inherited responsibility for Mango's actions (or inactions in this case) after you took his seat.

You are different people so it does not prove nothing that you acted differently. But you have Mango's role. Simple.

Thank you, I would rather Dogmaus explain to me why it's scummy to think that NL is not good. Example of Mango not voting and contributing to NL is peculiar because she noted that we are 2 different people. So I can act like myself (a different person) at the same time I'm somewhat *guilty* of not voting on D1 even thought it was Mango?
She mentioned *a provocation*, I find the reaction interesting.