Wyrm was the Doctor?? Ermm...


If there are in fact 3 scum we might have to.


That's fine. I can also go first.


If it's 3 the only 2 remnants of my original list are Catte and Flub. The other one has to be Cadaver.

Actually, if we're doing this I'd prefer Flub to go first over Catte considering he kept away from Lift's wagon which wasn't a bad wagon.

Stupid game, I specifically checked just Countdown from OP a few hours ago, it was clearly stated 1 more day left. How come?

Lift's death clearly shows that Pooka's list is the same yet different. I still don't get the goal of including a Neutral in game, especially Bulletproof. Was it it counter Mafia or Town, does it mean that there are 3 Mafia still?

Anyway, it's safe to assume the worst, there are 8 players remaining:

1. ZFR - the chances his is Mafia is minimal

2. Joe - same as above

3. Dedo - my most Town read player so far who placed me into Mafia list, hmm. That last hammer I didn't like.

4. Leoric - New Player, lurker

5. Dogmaus - New Player, were more active last Day. Technically it wasn't a hammer, but it was done within a few minutes range, I don't like it as well.

6. Catte - experienced player, yet I was not impressed

7. Flub - I have no idea

8. Cadaver - I'm ready to claim. I get it that ZFR insist on Catte, Dedo go first and I don't care anyway. Would be a miracle to win this game unless we have sleeping agents.

The question which bugs me is why Mafia targeted Book?

I'm going to be quite busy the next few days sorry.

Just imagine that I'm saying idiotic stuff and being wrong abour everything, cheers.

It's just PoE. I really don't have a lot else going against you, just how things look in case we have 3 scum. If for some reason it's just 2 then it's more likely it's Catte and Flub than you.


What's not to like about it?

We had about 3 days left. Lift was not Mafia, and who wants the easy lynches the most? But it seems I understand this game differently.

@Joe
Check the countdown, it's only 20 hours left (I guess it was the same 1 day counter I've seen before but without next Day announcement at the time)

Nope.

I got some intel this Night that tells me flub is very likely Town.

That leaves you and catte as the more likely and Leoric, Cadaver, dogmaus as the less likely. Joe is very unlikely, and he's claimed already.

Actually I don't mind what order the lot of you go, though I'm very happy to leave flub for last. dogmaus already claimed Vanilla.

First of all, I don't know if Lift isn't mafia. Secondly, I didn't believe his claim and did think there was a good chance he was scum. Thirdly, I did make the point of going Wyrm first and then Lift exactly because of the claim but people were already set on Lift so there was no point in arguing against it (also, what if Lift was in fact scum and that was turned against me later on).

In hindsight going the other way might have been even worse although we would have likely ended up in the exact same situation - Wyrm claims, we lynch Lift and Wyrm gets NKed.

Last but not least pretty much everyone (but you, I suppose) was ready for this to be finished so I stand my ground on the wagon not being a bad one and the hammer not being a bad one either.

ZFR, what have you done for FFs!

There was a very good chance based on the info we have Lift was Mafia. Lynch was good.


Exactly. Agreed on Lift wagon.

Sure, you can all claim in any order. I just won't insist on flub going first or going at all (unless there is a major change and someone has a smoking gun against him), but if he wants he can of course claim too.

Wait! I just realized this makes no sense to me. I want you to claim first or at least tell what do you know about Flub or better yet how and I'll go right behind you. And I'm looking for a very specific type of answer.

Nope. I'm PR and that's all I'm saying.

If anyone thinks I'm lying, that means I'm Godfather, which means Pooka added a second Mafioso, a godfather, a neutral and reduced Townies by 1. Now, everyone is free to think what they want, but no way in heck that's balanced. The only way I can see Godfather is balanced is if he changed Goon to Godfather, and added the Neutral, leaving the Mafiosos at 2. But if that's the case, we're not MYLO and there would be no reason for godfather!me to go 1-for-1 with a Townie, because after you see that I was lying about my Intel, Town would go for me tomorrow.

Feel free to do your own research.

PS: the fact that I did get a PR that wasn't in Pooka's original setup makes me think we have 3 Mafiosos and he added my PR to compensate. And if it turns out to be my crazy theory trio of dogmaus, Leoric and Mangadaver I'll by the lottery ticket factory.

Forget what I said. I don't want you to go before me.

bump if still needed.