It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #71(838 posts)(838 posts)
(838 posts)
Pages:
1
10
20
30
39
40
41
42
43
50
56
This is my favourite topic
Posted December 15, 2020
avatar
joppo: Huh. I guess that is that.

Goodbye peeps, I will enjoy the observer thread now. Stay tuned for the reveal.
Thanks.

I guess if you were Town, you'd have posted more thoughts?

And if you're scum, this is your third scum game, out of 4 total?
Posted December 15, 2020
avatar
Lifthrasil: How about you? What is your read on Joppo?
I'm not 100% convinced, but the way he brought yesterday to a premature close does raise significant suspicions.

avatar
GymHenson: Better yet, why isn't NMillar casting the hammer vote? o.0
Because there are still 2 IRL days left until the deadline, and aren't we waiting for to Joe to have the opportunity to contribute further?
Posted December 15, 2020
avatar
nmillar: Because there are still 2 IRL days left until the deadline, and aren't we waiting for to Joe to have the opportunity to contribute further?
avatar
nmillar: aren't we waiting for to Joe to have the opportunity to contribute further?
avatar
nmillar: Joe to have the opportunity to contribute
avatar
nmillar: Joe... contribute
...

Hahahahaha. Good joke.
Posted December 15, 2020
(@OP: No votes in this post)
++++

avatar
ZFR: I guess if you were Town, you'd have posted more thoughts?
I have a feeling that's why Joppo didn't post any suspects/suspicions.
(which afaik he technically could do as it's not EOD yet)

++++

@Nmillar: No need, as ZFR already hammered.

As for Joe weighing in: iirc he weighed in a bit on d2(would need to check to verify, though...memory is a bit spotty).

That aside, and fwiw, I never got that.....why there is a seeming general feeling that each "day" seemingly "must" run until time runs out.
(Yes, waiting for everyone to weigh in is often a good thing.....but on "days" like this when a course has more or less been decided it gets a bit boring waiting for the time to run out, and I sometimes wish we could/would move along and not wait until the last minute)
Posted December 15, 2020
avatar
GymHenson: That aside, and fwiw, I never got that.....why there is a seeming general feeling that each "day" seemingly "must" run until time runs out.
(Yes, waiting for everyone to weigh in is often a good thing.....but on "days" like this when a course has more or less been decided it gets a bit boring waiting for the time to run out, and I sometimes wish we could/would move along and not wait until the last minute)
But, isn't the last minute panic about actually having to come to a decision half the fun?
Posted December 15, 2020
avatar
nmillar: But, isn't the last minute panic about actually having to come to a decision half the fun?
Depends on each player's(in this case my own) mood at the time, and other factors as well. Sometimes it's fun and/or advantageous to draw the game out on each "day", whereas in other instances it's(imo) better to get a move on.
Posted December 15, 2020
avatar
nmillar: I'm not 100% convinced, but the way he brought yesterday to a premature close does raise significant suspicions.
Was there anyone else you would have preferred to vote for? If yes, who and why?

avatar
nmillar: Because there are still 2 IRL days left until the deadline, and aren't we waiting for to Joe to have the opportunity to contribute further?
What else do you think Joe would have contributed than he already did if we had waited for 2 more days?
Posted December 15, 2020
avatar
dedoporno: What else do you think Joe would have contributed than he already did if we had waited for 2 more days?
Lots....i'm thinking like 2 or 3 whole memes at the very least. ;)
Posted December 15, 2020
You're sure you've got it right this time.

Once again you concentrate and eject what you think to be the source of the unpleasant smell.

The smell subsides a little.

joppo was the horrible banan (mafia)!

It is now night, please stop posting.

Night will be around 48 hours.
Post edited December 15, 2020 by my name is sadde catte
Posted December 16, 2020
Oh boobs on a fish.

Stay tuna'd for the reveal.
I can't believe I messed up the chance to make this pun.

avatar
ZFR: And if you're scum, this is your third scum game, out of 4 total?
Actually if I haven't lost count this is my third game, all scum. For some reason Random.org loves putting me in the evil side.

avatar
my name is sadde catte: Once again you concentrate and eject what you think to be the source of the unpleasant smell.
The smell subsides a little.
joppo was the horrible banan (mafia)!
Oh come on, no need for insults!
Posted December 17, 2020
Although the smell improved somewhat with the removal of the banan, you find it is suddenly slightly worse.

JoeSapphire is dead, JoeSapphire was an delicious tunabeef (town).

It is now D4, you may begin posting.

I'm thinking about 19:00 UTC on Monday the 21st of December for the deadline.

With 6 players, 4 votes are required for lunch.
Posted December 17, 2020
So I guess all the people on my second list are gone, lol. Though I guess Joe was the safest choice for our lone wolf, right? If what I'm reading from the posts above is right, he didn't even appear on D3.

We're six people now, one mafiosi among us (yes, this was intended). Each day-night cycle takes two lives. Let me math it up...

Next Day would be 4 people, if we no-lynch then we'd have 3 people; not enough for a mafia win. Alternatively if we no-lynch today, we go to the next day with 5 people, and one less suspect, but would end back up at 3 people anyway. My strongest read remains Lift, but I'm not going to vote him yet. I'd rather we see everyone's takes for today, before I could decide if it's Lift, or someone else.

Maybe a good way to figure out who is Joppo's scumbuddy is to follow his interactions after being called out on his thing with trent fooling him. I reckon someone was going like "why are you even doing this man, get your act together pls" among the others who held him by the collar.
Posted December 17, 2020
So, who do we have left? The random characters make the OP too confusing:

nmillar
Pookina
GymHenson
Lift
ZFR
Dedoporno

Okay, maybe not so confusing after all!

Going to have a look through voting patterns tomorrow, and see if that leads to any theories.
Posted December 17, 2020
Gah, I wanted to say that finally joppo's pelt belongs unequivocally to me, but looking at it, dedo actually made the first reference to it in #301.

Enjoy the pelt, dedo. This way at least I'm more sure of your Townieness.

Joe, your hypothesis was wrong. Mine was right. Why didn't you ever post a bragging rights? You suck.

I'm fairly sure now Lift is the second scum. Mostly by elimination, but everything fits: his quick jump on Micro's wagon as soon as an opportunity presented itself, and his immediate vote on D3 on joppo once he knew he was a lost cause.

There is a small chance nmillar is the one, and a tiny-teeny chance of it being Pooka or GH.

Don't think I'll bother with NL at this stage: it's not like the NK is going to be any of the above if we do it. The scum will go for me or dedo, so the pool won't really get smaller.

Vote Lift
Posted December 17, 2020
Damn. My theory was Joe, after the way he derailed the Joppo wagon for Micro. But now we know he wasn't. Who then? I know several have me as top suspect now. That's a false suspicion, but of course I would say that as scum too and I can't prove it. And I will be very busy with moving to Heidelberg the next few days. So I'll be rarely present here.
The consolation is that we can afford a mislynch now. So do what you must.
Pages:
1
10
20
30
39
40
41
42
43
50
56
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #71(838 posts)(838 posts)
(838 posts)