(Nothing in this post is a vote) (Also to everyone: I got a slight injury on a finger or two, and while I won't need treatment I won't be able to reply as fast as I normally do...just letting y;all know)
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
dedoporno: Most everything you said till this line was in tune with my own view on things. I was almost starting to worry what happened to GH I know. I'm glad he's fine :)
I just had a weird whacky idea: what if that quoted bit of buck's post is them admitting sneakily to being scum to point at later.
Yeah, it's an "out there" idea, which is why I am mainly silly-ily musing on it atm.
(i.e. Buck possibly being the killer, that is.....I still think Buck might be a scum, albeit not necessarily the killer scum)
dedoporno: But a serious one did come through and it was sensitive Town information that reached scum eyes.
I don't know the recipients til I pick someone and it gets sent, and even if I knew who the recipients were ahead of time it wouldn't have helped much in early game when there wasn't much to lean people on.
Anyways, thanks in part to me we have axed one scum....hopefully we can get another "tonight"(n3).
(As long as I don't mess up like with my blotunga read....I was set on lynching them on D2 before I changed course)
dedoporno: People don't trust newbies to be more Town than others. Newbies tend to get more leeway when they do something that can be an honest mistake of a Townie who doesn't know better or [calculated] foul scum play.
This is in part what I was trying to say, in essence...thanks for wording it in the proper way.
dedoporno: I agree with this as it doesn't make sense to me that scum!Catte would risk getting exposed like that for a mere investigation (obviously he won't protect a non-buddy) when they are already down one member.
This
---
ZFR: Today I investigated Joe on the off chance he's a third party killer. He isn't. Joe is neither a killer third party nor a target. Meaning he's Mafia or Town.
dedoporno: You got healed and was allowed to investigate in the same night?
This is a good question.
What say you, ZFR, re the above? ---
dedoporno: If you are what you say you are your role in itself keeps working as intended. Whether or not others would fall for it is a very different topic. It's weird how you don't seem to understand why scum likely wouldn't touch you with a ten foot pole while there is a chance for their kill to backfire.
Tbh I think he is saying such things because he's possibly a newbie scum pretending to be a confused newbie town.
dedoporno: @GH, bucktooth does look like a "safe" policy lynch but I'm also interested in who the other scum is (I believe it's pretty safe to assume that it's unlikely there were more than 3 of them at the start). Also, what if bucktooth is what he claims?
If he's town coward then all we lose is his vote, as if he's town his role would've become nerfed the moment he claimed it.
Also with Catte and ZFR, they can be of help to us more than a town coward can(re their claimed roles), so it's more worthwhile to test Buck's claim with such a lynch than ZFR or Catte.
As for the other scum(....I am confident now we will find them over time...also the likely very high town numbers will hopefully give us an edge, especially if Buck flips scum.
dedoporno: Although, as soon as I wrote this I remembered that we have the numbers in our favor and barring some crazy stuff we can afford to mislynch Today and Tomorrow before we get to MYLO.
Weird, I thought just this when I wrote the bit above, before I read this bit.