It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
If I get Night Killed, I think it will be because I'm onto the scumteam. I'm picking 2 of ZFR, Laser97, Liftrasil and Microfish.

Most likely scumteam is ZFR and Microfish

avatar
ZFR: thanks for the bump.

avatar
supplementscene: The only team that benefits from the day ending prematurely is Mafia. Not Town. So why do you want the day to end early?
avatar
ZFR: Seriously??? We're 1 day before deadline and you're calling this ending it prematurely? What's not an early end then? 10-20 mins before deadline when everyone is doing a Chinese Fire Drill?

Yup, we've got one scum.
Very serious. Ending a day prematurely only helps Mafia

This post pretty much confirms to me you're are Scum

Unvote Laser97 VoteZFR

I think Microfish is probably your teammate.
avatar
ZFR: Seriously??? We're 1 day before deadline and you're calling this ending it prematurely? What's not an early end then? 10-20 mins before deadline when everyone is doing a Chinese Fire Drill?

Yup, we've got one scum.
avatar
supplementscene: Very serious. Ending a day prematurely only helps Mafia
My question wasn't whether ending prematurely helps Mafia, but whether ending it 1 day before deadline is "premature".

So answer my question, please: how late does a Day have to end for it not to be premature? 10-20 mins before deadline?
avatar
ZFR: How on earth would those statistics matter to his current alignment?
Technically it doesn't matter, yet like I said I see a difference between a bluff and bluff backed up with history/statistics, I even provided an example from Court system where a lawyer could forge evidence using something real and mixing it with something fake. In case of Micro the lie, if it's a lie, will be revealed one way or another and never again he could say anything to his defense. All his claims would be read as scum tells, and if he lied without backing up his words with statistics that would be a small lie, the difference is in consequences. That's how it matter.

And in case you will not stop this wagon and he'll flip Mafia, I'll be the next one (I should be I presume). Take this into consideration how ever you want.
No one wants to analyze on Day 1 I recon, it's a shame...
Also: this is LAMIST:

avatar
supplementscene: If I get Night Killed...
Seriously, "LAMIST" was meant to refer to people who indirectly hint at themselves being Town. Like "If I get NKed..." or "Oh no! They got our Cop. We'll avenge him!" or "What does QT mean?".
Kill SupplementScene
avatar
Cadaver747: And I don't want to place my vote on Micro: it's the laziest vote ever with zero to none analyzing. He claimed to be Town, he even provided statistics (7 games in a row, yet there was 1 flaw with Sultan game).
The statistics are completely meaningless. The dice rolls for previous games have no bearing on the dice rolls for this game. Never being mafia before neither makes him more or less likely to be mafia now.

avatar
Cadaver747: I don't believe Mafia would ever dare to be so blunt. And let's imagine that he is indeed a Mafia and he is planning to trick us, would anyone of us think of him like of a good person afterwards?
What? Of course we wouldn't think less of him. If he is mafia then we'd expect him to lie, it's how you play as mafia.

avatar
Cadaver747: I know GOG Mafia is a game of lying and bluff, but never again anyone would take Micro's word seriously and he could never ever say in some GOG Mafia Game #99 something like: "Hey, I was Mafia once in that GOG Mafia Game #94, but it's my 5th time I'm Town so your vote would be a waste", he would be instantly lynched.
It would be as pointless then as it was in this game:
- Previous statistics have no bearing on Micro's current chance of being mafia.
- People playing mafia are always going to lie and claim to be town.

I really don't understand your logic.
avatar
LASER97: Kill SupplementScene
Is that a vig shot?
Holy shit, I guess LASER wasn't kidding?

avatar
Cadaver747: Technically it doesn't matter, yet like I said I see a difference between a bluff and bluff backed up with history/statistics, I even provided an example from Court system where a lawyer could forge evidence using something real and mixing it with something fake. In case of Micro the lie, if it's a lie, will be revealed one way or another and never again he could say anything to his defense. All his claims would be read as scum tells, and if he lied without backing up his words with statistics that would be a small lie, the difference is in consequences. That's how it matter.

And in case you will not stop this wagon and he'll flip Mafia, I'll be the next one (I should be I presume). Take this into consideration how ever you want.
No one wants to analyze on Day 1 I recon, it's a shame...
The history and statistics are completely irrelevant, so you're drawing a distinction between a bluff backed up with nothing and a bluff backed up with nothing. You seem to think Micro should be concerned about tarnishing his reputation, but a mafia player is expected to lie. If he's found to be a liar here it won't tarnish his credibility in future because lying is expected from mafia.
avatar
SirPrimalform: The statistics are completely meaningless. The dice rolls for previous games have no bearing on the dice rolls for this game. Never being mafia before neither makes him more or less likely to be mafia now.
I was talking about history cases of his being Town as his merits (and boredom) of being a Town, not the dice rolls chance on itself. I understand that dice could roll anything. But in case of Micro it was more like "look at that, it rolled Town again, what are the odds". Indeed.

avatar
SirPrimalform: What? Of course we wouldn't think less of him. If he is mafia then we'd expect him to lie, it's how you play as mafia.
Yeah sure, look at Pooka. If this is the case (Mafia lying about being Town) than Micro would envy him and most likely get a lynch 3 or 5 times an row (a slight exaggeration, however it could be even worse). If he just joked about "I'm Mafia, hah-hah-hah" that would be a completely different story, maybe just a few *revenge* RVS votes on Day 1.

avatar
SirPrimalform: It would be as pointless then as it was in this game:
- Previous statistics have no bearing on Micro's current chance of being mafia.
- People playing mafia are always going to lie and claim to be town.
Can't say anything against it. But it would be pointless because no one would ever believe in this trick again. If Micro haven't done Town claims before then I'm screwed and my logic is *bursting at the seams*. For some reason I though Micro claimed Town before but not at such extreme level of boldness.

avatar
SirPrimalform: I really don't understand your logic.
I fully understand your concern. But I can't put it better that I already did (maybe I could but I'm not sure and this is not a problem me having different native language). But I just can't comprehend why on earth he would do such a stupid claim when he could just act like a normal Town player.
avatar
SirPrimalform: The history and statistics are completely irrelevant, so you're drawing a distinction between a bluff backed up with nothing and a bluff backed up with nothing.
Thanks, I was going to reply but this sums up nicely what I had in mind.

As SPF said, the lawyer comparison doesn't apply. No one will go "Oh my God! He lied while being Mafia last time! I'll never believe a word he says again." You are expected too forge the evidence... er lie in Mafia. It's part of the game.
avatar
SirPrimalform: The history and statistics are completely irrelevant, so you're drawing a distinction between a bluff backed up with nothing and a bluff backed up with nothing. You seem to think Micro should be concerned about tarnishing his reputation, but a mafia player is expected to lie. If he's found to be a liar here it won't tarnish his credibility in future because lying is expected from mafia.
In case I screwed myself. I sincerely thought that it would *definitely* tarnish his reputation even if Mafia games mostly based on lies and bluffing. I inadvertently made his wagon more attractive and chained myself to it. Well, I should pay the price for my naivety.

@All
I have no idea what is going on between Laser and Scene, but whatever wagon you choose please stop at L-2 before I provide my analysis. I made a promise and I want to fulfill my obligations.
avatar
ZFR: Also: this is LAMIST:

avatar
supplementscene: If I get Night Killed...
avatar
ZFR: Seriously, "LAMIST" was meant to refer to people who indirectly hint at themselves being Town. Like "If I get NKed..." or "Oh no! They got our Cop. We'll avenge him!" or "What does QT mean?".
Yes but it's also breadcrumbing, the game is nearly solved. Town must ask why night kills happen.

avatar
LASER97: Kill SupplementScene
So I was right? It's you and ZFR.

avatar
supplementscene: Very serious. Ending a day prematurely only helps Mafia
avatar
ZFR: My question wasn't whether ending prematurely helps Mafia, but whether ending it 1 day before deadline is "premature".

So answer my question, please: how late does a Day have to end for it not to be premature? 10-20 mins before deadline?
If most people can be online in the final day, yes extra info is found out. It's perhaps worth taking it to N2 12 hours before to allow claiming and reaction to the claim
avatar
Cadaver747: In case I screwed myself. I sincerely thought that it would *definitely* tarnish his reputation even if Mafia games mostly based on lies and bluffing. I inadvertently made his wagon more attractive and chained myself to it. Well, I should pay the price for my naivety.

@All
I have no idea what is going on between Laser and Scene, but whatever wagon you choose please stop at L-2 before I provide my analysis. I made a promise and I want to fulfill my obligations.
Well it's only your second actual mafia game, you're still learning. Doesn't look like we're going to get our questions about Micro answered today anyway because it looks like LASER just used his vig shot, which will end the day according to the PM in the OP (it's as if he forced a lynch essentially).
avatar
supplementscene: So I was right? It's you and ZFR.
Did you even read the OP?
avatar
LASER97: Kill SupplementScene
avatar
supplementscene: So I was right? It's you and ZFR.
How could you possibly draw that conclusion? Do you think the mafia can day-kill?