supplementscene: I appreciate this analytical effort and because of it
I won't be voting for yourself today Thank you, there wasn't anything analytical about it, I just placed posts with votes and first entries. I don't think I can appreciate your gesture though: sounds like you're making me a favor or a threat even.
Joe's voting results were worth noting how exactly? (have you avoided that question?)
Only 2 players (Laser & Lonzi) out of 6 in your list (or Joe's voting results from Post#49 if you prefer) haven't voted by the time of your post, all past votes (Laser's included) were cast on the 1st day and you said:
supplementscene: You expect me to update my list of players
who haven't voted 3 days on when everyone has voted?
I mean I got votes on myself for far less (games #65-66), I don't get how some players "liked" your posts.
I can't exclude me being paranoid for no reason of course.
supplementscene: I tend to think lurky silence should be punished regardless of role. As it makes it too easy for Mafia to hide in the shadows and if these players are town they don't help town solve the game.
Another threat from one of your previous posts. The lurkiest ones were Carradice, you, Laser and Lonzi. The only player who haven't voted "3 days on when everyone has voted" (your own words) is Lonzi
And yet you're willing to vote Lith (because he was the 3rd voter on Pooka), Micro (the LAMIST) and ZFR (because he sees nearly all others as Town but not SPF - which can't be true - however, I must admit, that part about "buddying the townees, picking an unpopular wagon and not scum hunting" is interesting to think about).
I don't think you're scum but I don't understand your logic at times. If it's because of IRL and you just can't physically read and remember all the things happened, then I guess it's just my paranoia (that would explain your mistakes and some other oddities). If not, then you're a strange man:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JqyMPETa588 supplementscene: I don't know if I've played with you before, so I'm curious how many mafia games you've played
You don't? We've played together in Court of the Sultan game hosted by Zazak (now Laser).
Either you don't have much time to read all the posts or it's something else, like I said...
Cadaver747: ...it's my third game.
1. The Shining GOG Mafia #65 (Town, Self-Watcher)
https://www.gog.com/forum/general/the_shining_gog_mafia_65_return_to_the_stanley_hotel/page1 2. Court of the Sultan #1 - Janissary Revolt (Protester, Rebel)
https://www.gog.com/forum/general/court_of_the_sultan_1_janissary_revolt/page1 3. Current game so far (Cadaver Slim at your service).