While it would personally feel great to be believed and to lynch Joppo, I agree that the odds are better in lynching one of GR or Carradice. The possibility that you're scum is somewhat slim, but since it exists I still think we should be careful choosing between Carradice and GR. I lean towards Carradice for his overreaction to me calling him scum (before Cristi even gave her results).

It's nearly 9pm now, I'm going offline for now but I will check back in before bed.

Hang on, let me use my revolver on myself.

puts gun on head and pulls the trigger - nothing happens

oh, I was one-shot too.

...the amount of not reading the OP in this game is hilarious.

OK, Scenario 1 is impossible.

I am confident enough that my N1 was not re-directed, that you, Pooka and I are conftrmed (you mostly confirmed) town.

We need to all vote together.

It's not about necessarily voting for the one person who looks the scummiest, although that could be the case.

There are three scum, we have to hit one. Who makes the most sense as a team? Who makes no sense as team? There's a lot to consider here besides who we vote today.

Because paranoia is a real thing.

Unless we get lucky and hit the bulletproof, I am dead tonight. Tomorrow, you need to work with scene and pooka to determine the next target.

My initial reaction after Joppo claimed was that he was legit. But SPF feels better overall today. There are some parts I have barely skimmed and need to reread.

Y'all could lynch me if you want.....or don't....at this point if I don't get lynched(it being after D2 and all) i'll likely die of boredom waiting for something to happen.

EBWOP

Unless we get lucky and hit the strongman, I am dead tonight.

> waiting for something to happen
Joppo and SPF: Are we jokes to you?

----
GR's playstyle makes him not that easily readable as scum, or as Town, but he would fit in the scumparty. If we combine this with cristi's reveal that Laser is probably Town, that makes his "oh the deadline was too close, sorry I'm gonna unvote" vote a lot more fishy. So I suggest starting with him. What do you think, @Cristi?

I meant with your own "grandstanding" the one day, and then cristi holding her reads today(barring the irl stuff she had to do, of course)**.....I felt at times like that meme of the man turning into a skeleton waiting for x or y thing to happen. ;)

(**=Not that they weren't fun to read at times, of course)

@Cristi

Scum needs a mislynch today. They have nowhere to hide tomorrow otherwise.

Well as for Carradice, as much as I feel his Town self from that HP game is there, well by process of elimination, he is more likely to be scum than usual. In the previous Mafia game he was much more obvious as a jester. If he is scum now, things have changed and he can't just jester his way out, he has to survive for his team. Probably it's a lot easier for him to pretend he was Carradice from that HP game rather than a Townie, if you get what I mean.

But seriously, if he turns out to be scum, I'll be singing praise for him all day. Yes, for fooling us all.

Gotta say I have a feeling GR is "bored" and "waiting for something to happen." Maybe he is waiting for end-game. He doesn't necessarily need to be Town to give up, in other words.

He mostly just fooled you. Carradice never moved from being my #2 scum read.

Scene, we know that there is one town and one scum between Joppo and SPF.

What do you think about choosing between Carradaice and GameRager? There must be scum between these two. Best case is both are scum, worst case is 50/50.


@Pooka - I don't think giving up is necessarily town, GR should care if he is town

I agree with this, most importantly we need to avoid scum

I think we either have a situation where Laser and Rager are Scum or Carradice and Rager are scum. So we only lose if Laser is bluffing us over Rager not being scum. Otherwise Rager is certainly scum

In these games, town or no, I often play to have fun...and sometimes I either get burnt out for some reason or (more so in this case) I have IRL to deal with which saps some of my enthusiasm.

(Note: Not posting my IRL to ate.....if you want to suspect or vote me go right ahead)