I was being funny ... or so I thought!

I suspected as much. ;P

I think these are RFG's breadcrumbs SPF was talking about

And what do you make of RFG specifically namedropping you? I've got my own thoughts but I'd like to know what you think before I share them. I don't want to influence you.

And now we are likely be both gone very soon, as I looked ahead and saw you were lynched......hopefully I will survive and any investigator will be checking out one of the remaining players.
=====================================
Note to all: I would ask next time if we have ample time till deadline and a wagon forms in the future that others kindly wait(if possible) until I get online so I can weigh in. Thanks in advance.
=====================================

1st bit: If there is why didn't they verify our claims yet or look into us(even when we weren't claiming mason we were both very visible in posting)? If they haven't yet I think they should either look into one of the lurkers(more likely than SPF) or SPF.

2nd bit: If we have an investigator role(as I think we did with one comment by one user here recently...not naming them to avoid them being outed of course, but look back the last few pages to posts by the lurkers for more on that) they would be dropping breadcrumbs by now, wouldn't they? Or pushing the lynch away from those confirmed as town?
==============================

Nice sized post.....will unpack each bit in turn:

1. I do that by default(talk that way) when I know myself to be town or others to also be town....force of habit....I know I am not above suspicion.

2. It might until said roles have to claim for some reason, and it removes the small but still there chance for a mason town team(now gone of course) to stick around until the last "day" and lynch the final scum.

3. Do you mean/meant more PRs besides us masons or what? Do you really believe our side is loaded with PRs? Also with me and blotunga more or less confirmed, we(before his lynch) had a 1/4 chance of hitting scum(or is it 1/5) if we had gone that route.

4. We had more than enough time to risk a lynch of one other player....it would've given any investigator time to confirm our masons claim without a lynch being needed and also would've given us a small but noticeable chance to hit the last scum.


I wonder if an investigator used the nolynch "day" to check into one of us, and if so why they haven't said so yet.

(Well a post or two could be them doing so, but I don't know and don't want to point them out.....check back to the lurkers the last few irl days iirc, that is all I will say)

Unless scum goes after the other players instead to try and hit any such PRs, or the PRs(if any) have to claim for some reason.


Was this a misread or intentionally not seeing he meant us as town and not a third party?
====================================

That is assuming we have PRs, and I myself care very much....but I did not see the value in one of us being lynched as I saw going after a nonconfirmed(to us masons) player while waiting for any possible town cop/etc to check into us to be more viable.

Also I might also want to survive until game end for a change a small bit...that much is true....and I want town to win but I care more about having fun than winning at all costs/etc. That's just how I play.
==============================

I was willing to lynch you to try to hit scum, and then another the next day if need be...etc. If red had voted earlier that "day" it would've happened.

(Which is odd, how he posted 12+ minutes AFTER the "day" ended.....as if he wanted to appear on the wagon but not lynch you for some reason.)

Now this last 'day' the wagon formed on others so no chance to lynch someone I wanted to, or convince others to do so(they rushed the lynch of blotunga before I could reply and try to stop it), and I wasn't about to self lynch or lynch blotunga.
=================================

Nonsense? Dohoho......
------------------------

If he were cop he likely would have looked into us on the nolynch "day/night".
=================================

I am guessing it's most likely one of the ones on your wagon(lurker or SPF), and that's who I hope any PR looked into overnight.

Also to blotunga: Was fun playing with you, even if we didn't converse much even in game. Have a good one and here's hoping we win the game. :)
=================================================

Dammit. I was guessing either RedFire or LolChan was a cop/etc and now we have lost our tracker....GL guys/gals.
================================================

Btw to all: Only caught up to post 696....need bump to post more in a bit most likely....thanks in advance

Nvm on the bump....all done and caught up
=================================

Check Post 700......it shows one I picked up on and you somehow seem to have missed.

Yes, it is ever so helpful we lost a town PR....weren't you worried about losing town PRs before? This sounds like you saying "RFG was a PR? Eh, no biggie that we lost him".
===================================

See ya next time, gog mafia cowboy.
===================================

I think I know why he dropped LolChan's name....but I also am waiting to see LolChan's take on it first.

Okay, I finally get online!

No. That's not why I didn't give my name, and the reason I gave for that reluctance was legit (and I was more than happy to oblige when you told me I misremembered). Besides, I couldn't come up with such a name as "Dieuli Redoo" if given an eternity before the Day was over. I'm bad at names.

Now that we're thinking about it, the wording sounds odd. Besides, what the heck's up with dropping LOLChan's name all of a sudden? Is that an implication that he may be more than he appears to be?

Let's see, the current state of affairs...
- SirPrimalform
- Pooka
- GameRager
- nmillar
- LOLChan

Can't believe it's Day 4 after several games that only ended on Day 3. At least from my angle, I can see that the scum has to be one of SirPrimalform, nmillar or LOLChan. After blotunga's flip, I am not worried about there being two scum like I used to when he was alive. I'm concerned that the scum have left SPF alive, considering he's extremely engaged this game compared to other games; then again, one can argue that he's been left alive precisely because he was distracted by the Mason Team and wasn't going after the real scum. I'm still having a hard time reading nmillar and LOLchan.

Also, all things considered, two of five have claimed. Given RFG the Tracker was killed while only leaving behind breadcrumbs, I think it's fair to massclaim right now, what's with three nights of results. Not to mention that tomorrow is LyLo. And yes, I want everyone to claim now rather than tomorrow; as all it would take for the last scum to prevail is to spin a lie and have everyone believe it on the last day. That's what HSL did in Captain Sapphire, and it's fair to say that we're dealing with a skilled lone mafioso.

Do you have any reads on other players? You seem to be posting as little as possible to get by without offering any opinions.

That's what I think too, and if that's the case then I interpret the post to mean you visited pooka that night.

In which case, you're pretty much outed as some kind of PR now. Do you have any info that could help us crack the game?

So here's the thing. Do we know for sure which night RFG tracked LOLchan? As long as it was N2 or later, then LOLchan couldn't be mafia because they would have to be the one killing. If LOLchan visited pooka then LOLchan couldn't have been out killing.

Which narrows the pool considerably...


1. You mean the one we've been discussing for most of the current page? Yeah, I don't think I've seen it yet. :P

2. What I said was that we might either lose you or a PR but we couldn't lose both. In losing RFG we've kept you, which is useful now that you're confirmed. It's not good that we lost RFG, but it narrows my suspect pool.

1. It's ok, information since that post makes me think you likely cleared anyway.

2. Yes, I think we might be able to crack the game here and now with a massclaim actually. The question is which order to do it in...

Doesn't matter the order, what matters is we start it now and no later.

If you want an order, you begin followed by LOLChan and finally nmillar.

Wrong. The order can be of great significance. The later the scum claims, the more info they have to work with in coming up with a falseclaim.

Why on earth would you place nmillar last? From my perspective he is almost certainly the last scum. It won't be as clear to you as both me and nmillar are possible suspects, but do you really suspect LOLchan more than nmillar?

Whoa! I thought we were friends?

Actually, I agree that the order is very significant, and Pooka's disregard for this is odd ... will have to re-analyse RFG's posts prior to the one we already discussed to establish if he was actually clearing Pooka, or drawing LOLChan's attention to him.

Up to this point, it was a simple decision between SPF and LOLChan for me, but now I'm starting to doubt myself. There goes my ultimate fantasy of un-masking SPF in a dramatic final day showdown!