Yes, it is. It would have to be a non-killing faction. Which means they could be a neutral faction. But a second scum team is unlikely.

For now I'll keep operating on the assumption that we have only one scum left. We should first wait for GR's confirmation and then move on to try to find the remaining scum.

Dammi....I mean Yayyyyyyy! *waves arms like Kermit*
===========================

Dammit, why'd you have to basically put targets on both our backs? :\

Oh well, it's out now at any rate....best make the best of it.
===========================

See reply to blotunga above this bit.....you guys/gals basically put us right in the crosshairs, y'all know that right? o.0
===========================

------------------------------------
Stop fishing for info, pal-i-o. If blotunga wants to give it out and feels it pertinent he(or I I guess) will give it out when need be.
=============================

Tbh I didn't know masons were a PR or that they COULD chat to one another. My bad for not looking into it, but at the time I was having IRL issues that distracted me a bit coupled with the fact I am a bit lazy with such(which you should be able to confirm via my participation last game).
=================================

Confirmed......now let's find that other scum.

Frankly, anyone confirmed town already has a target on their back, so you're not really in any more danger than before.

The PR though and it's ability gave us an advantage(even if I didn't know about it until today irl), though.....one which is now somewhat gone now that everyone knows it.

(Thanks everyone...:p)

Also it is likely scum will try taking one of us out now that they know about it.

Yes, but I was hoping I would be the main target as to draw a possible block from a doctor if we have one.

I was wondering earlier about you saying this, but post 437 clears that up for me, since you said you didn't know masons were a PR.

I'm reexamining my earlier guess that scum wouldn't have bussed Trent so soon after ZFR said they both might be scum. I still feel that Lift and SPF are town, but I need to look back at NMillar's posts, since they were last to join in on ZFR's theory.

Again, that is not what fishing means. Interrogating someone who has voluntarily claimed in order to try and verify their claim is not role fishing (or indeed any kind of fishing). There were numerous things about blotunga's claim that I found suspect, questioning for detail is how you catch scum who are falseclaiming.

To me it technically still is a sort of fishing, and one town should try to do carefully so as not to force PRs to give up info that could help scum somehow.

Well then town players need to look for subtle hints(by blotunga and by me once I got that I was a PR as well) to not delve further or press town for further info that might also make other town become targets. ;)

100% town by PR
Blotunga
GameRager

so scum has to be one of these

likely town
SirPrimalform
Lifthrasil

somewhat town
PookaMustard
RedFireGaming
NMillar
LOLchan

allow me to clear my name.

Why would I help facilitate in the of lynching trent. As a new player even if I was coached in PM I would stand little chance of surviving. If I was scum I would probably soft out myself to protect trent.
My “lurking” is from my inability to know what I say in most situations that hasn’t been said. (as saying something prior stated would appear scummy) I don’t yet know who is the third scum but for now I will look at the trent train to see if I can find some leads.

I like how you put yourself as somewhat town......seems funny in a way.

Also why would you(if scum) out yourself to protect trent? If you got lynched then eyes would have gone back to trent, most likely, losing scum the game.

I agree we need to check into the trent train, however, as well as those who didn't vote and what they did leading up that lynch.

I'm leaning slightly towards nmillar being scum. Something about the way he joined the wagons.

With agentcarr there's a feeling of "My buddies are bussing each other. Whoops, better pick a side quickly!

With Trent's wagon, nmillar was theoretically in favour of lynching Trent earlier on but seemed to spend a long time stalling before eventually hammering. Once the lynch seems inevitable you've got to make sure you're on the wagon!

It's not much, but it feels like something. Anyone got any thoughts on my thoughts?

You might have a point there, or you might not....I will do a bit of re-reading perhaps tomorrow(irl) when I get back online in 17 or so hours.
================================================================
*BTW Happy Columbus Day/Indigenous People's Day(whichever you fancy) to my fellow Americans*
================================================================

Nmillar wanted to slow down the vote.(that's for certain) But it also seems that nmillar was on with trents lynch. Not sure if that’s just a tactic not to appear suspicious. He was however very early in defending gamerager.(post 379)
Make of this as you will.