It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
It would be more beneficial if I wouldn't reveal myself completely. I'd rather wait the next day (or NK) to make the full reveal. I'm a bit unsure about some things (not related to GameRager's alignment) so bare with me.
Do you expect to survive the Night with your soft-claim, blotunga? Unless you're confident someone will save you, I wouldn't count on surviving the Night at all...

Do you have any other information to share?
avatar
PookaMustard: Do you expect to survive the Night with your soft-claim, blotunga? Unless you're confident someone will save you, I wouldn't count on surviving the Night at all...

Do you have any other information to share?
I hope I might be save-able. Also a bit of logic, there are 7 town and 1 scum. It would make no sense to make such a gambit. A scum would've laid back and waited until town lynched GR. He was the most likely candidate since yesterday anyway.
avatar
nmillar: Okay, we're going to need a proper claim, as at the moment there are two possible scenarios.

1) blotunga is telling the truth, which means GameRager and Blotunga re both town.

2) this is a very brave scum move, and blotunga is soft claiming, as he knows we will not sacrifice a town PR. He's using this to keep everyone's favourite suspect alive to give him a better chance of making it to end game. He knows if we do lynch GameRager, that he will flip town and "verify" him as town PR at the same time.

Either way, GameRager is definitely town.
True.

And I agree that we need a full claim from blotunga now. The damage to his position is already done and if he is Town, he most likely won't survive the Night. @blotunga: so we need all the information you have Today!

unvote GameRager
avatar
nmillar: Okay, we're going to need a proper claim, as at the moment there are two possible scenarios.

1) blotunga is telling the truth, which means GameRager and Blotunga re both town.

2) this is a very brave scum move, and blotunga is soft claiming, as he knows we will not sacrifice a town PR. He's using this to keep everyone's favourite suspect alive to give him a better chance of making it to end game. He knows if we do lynch GameRager, that he will flip town and "verify" him as town PR at the same time.

Either way, GameRager is definitely town.
avatar
Lifthrasil: True.

And I agree that we need a full claim from blotunga now. The damage to his position is already done and if he is Town, he most likely won't survive the Night. @blotunga: so we need all the information you have Today!

unvote GameRager
I was hoping that at least some people would understand that it's not always beneficial to full claim. GameRager's wagon wouldn't have given us much information so likely it's not a huge blunder coming out. Anyway if the majority will want a full claim, I will make one tomorrow.
Let's do it everyone.

vote fullclaim for blotunga
avatar
PookaMustard: Vote GameRager

I don't think there's any plausible reason why gogtrial disappeared...unless...he was the one actively going after the scum.
Again, why(if I were scum) would I NK the person who was most/most recently vocal about me possibly being scum? It'd make no sense.

=================================
avatar
Lifthrasil: So GR's conviction didn't come from any any invesitgation and his reference to the Cop wasn't breadcrumbing his results. Which makes that question more role-fishy and GR's defense of trent more fishy in general.

I can very well see GR panicking after agent revealed the whole initial scum-team and trent failed to pick up on that. So he probably defended trent because he didn't want to be the only scum left on D3 (after just having been re-rolled as scum)

In other words: vote GameRager
On the role-fishing: I also said in those posts that if we had such a role they should drop the info without exposing themselves/role claiming.

Also you guys are making another mistake(as with many past games where I was also town)....but feel free to fall for the scum's ploy to set me up as an easy mislynch, it happens to me regardless in many games(quick lynch or NK).
===============================

avatar
PookaMustard: You're, one hundred percent sure, that GameRager is not scum. This post alone implies you did something at night through which you figured out that GameRager is not the guy we're looking for. Given that we only need to lynch one guy, would you kindly reveal what you've got in your mind? Any decent scum will pick up on this post as "blotunga has a power role" and will nightkill you accordingly. Basically what I'm saying is you're already beyond the point of no return, so it's best to get the show started.
----------------------------------------
avatar
PookaMustard: The first line in my last post: GameRager is NOT scum. The "not" was missing.

avatar
blotunga: I don't want to completely waste today's lynch so that's why I interjected so soon. But I do want to let scum keep guessing a bit. I will reveal the details later as soon I'm starting a trip and I won't be online for a while. But as said, please focus on someone else than GameRager and me until then. It's wasted effort.
avatar
PookaMustard: The scum has already gotten a piece of the puzzle that says enough about you; you're a power role. That's more than they have on the rest of us. Claim who you are and give us a good reason not to waste effort on GameRager.
Why do these two posts seem like role fishing to me? It would normally be a bit of a scum tell, but seeing as you are right and blotunga basically has outed themselves I am leaning more on you being town.

I still don't think blotunga should tell us too much, though, in case his likely PR has a modifier/etc that he wants to keep close to his chest for some reason/until the right moment.
=============================

avatar
SirPrimalform: Absolutely, if GameRager was scum then Blotunga would have to be town and lying for some reason, which obviously isn't the case.

Definitely need a full-claim from Blotunga now, I can't see a town advantage to keeping things mysterious. If he's telling the truth then he's already a target. Claiming isn't going to make him more of a target.
As I just told Pooka i'd rather blotunga keep any modifiers/extra info about his likely PR to himself until it is advantageous to do so(or before the next "night" when he might likely be targeted).
============================

avatar
RedFireGaming: Sorry GR, I guess it really was your playstyle. It's going to be interesting to see Blotunga's big reveal, but I'm traveling for the next 5 hours, so I'll probably just catch the results. So with GameRager effectively confirmed town, and GOGTrial NK'd, is the 3rd scum Pooka, LOLChan, or maybe Nmillar? I'll have to read through posts again.

And I'm finally going to be back at my desktop.
Either blotunga is scum and is claiming a PR to clear me and clear himself in the process, or it's someone else entirely.

And yeah, it's my playstyle for every game.....I mainly read quickly/don't keep lists of what people said/etc, and mainly play to have fun & converse with people. :)

(And also sometimes roleplay, if I know the topic that needs to be roleplayed, that is)
================================
avatar
PookaMustard: Do you expect to survive the Night with your soft-claim, blotunga? Unless you're confident someone will save you, I wouldn't count on surviving the Night at all...

Do you have any other information to share?
Do you believe his claim? If you do then who is your next likely suspect, if I may ask?
-----------------------------------------
avatar
PookaMustard: Let's do it everyone.

vote fullclaim for blotunga
I think he should only give up the info we need atm, and not full claim until right before the end of the current "day", personally.

==============================
==============================
*End of replies.....Some were made before I saw more recent ones so read my replies accordingly*
==============================
avatar
blotunga: Anyway if the majority will want a full claim, I will make one tomorrow.
You've already had four requests for a full claim, so I guess you're only waiting for one more. I find your reluctance kind of strange, so vote blotunga while we wait.
avatar
blotunga: Anyway if the majority will want a full claim, I will make one tomorrow.
avatar
SirPrimalform: You've already had four requests for a full claim, so I guess you're only waiting for one more. I find your reluctance kind of strange, so vote blotunga while we wait.
Maybe he has some PR modifier that he doesn't want to reveal or other such info he is holding as long as he can so scum don't know it as well? That could be it.
I did some reading on the wiki, and it gave some good suggestions. 1st, softclaiming as scum is unlikely. 2nd, we should let the softclaim stand until at least the end of D3.

That said, Blotunga should seriously consider the benefits of fullclaiming. After which, my vote is let Blotunga decide for himself.
avatar
RedFireGaming: I did some reading on the wiki, and it gave some good suggestions. 1st, softclaiming as scum is unlikely. 2nd, we should let the softclaim stand until at least the end of D3.

That said, Blotunga should seriously consider the benefits of fullclaiming. After which, my vote is let Blotunga decide for himself.
All I know is that this is gonna likely seriously put a damper on my whole "dies before day 3 every time" streak. o.0

Of course I am totally ok with that. :)
avatar
blotunga: It would be more beneficial if I wouldn't reveal myself completely. I'd rather wait the next day (or NK) to make the full reveal. I'm a bit unsure about some things (not related to GameRager's alignment) so bare with me.
waiting might not be the best option as if you aren't scum you will probably die from your soft claim PR tonight. Then again if you have a plan that will help town in D4 then I'm willing to wait for blotungas full explanation.

If I may so bold. What exactly are you “unsure” about blotunga? Please do tell. (if that’s not a compromise to your plan)
I still think that it would benefit town more if I didn't full claim. Alas to stop the needless fishing (which I was hoping to extract some info about scum actually), I promise I will full claim before the end of the day. Now can we please move on and try to figure out who trent and carr's scumbuddy was? I have no other relevant info to share about that.
avatar
RedFireGaming: I did some reading on the wiki, and it gave some good suggestions. 1st, softclaiming as scum is unlikely. 2nd, we should let the softclaim stand until at least the end of D3.
The second makes some sense and I could get on board with that, but the first doesn't make much sense to me.

Scum like to keep things vague. The more specific they have to be, the more likely they are to be caught in a lie. This is why I find blotunga's reluctance a bit suspicious.
avatar
GameRager: All I know is that this is gonna likely seriously put a damper on my whole "dies before day 3 every time" streak. o.0
It's already Day 3 and you're not dead!

avatar
blotunga: I still think that it would benefit town more if I didn't full claim. Alas to stop the needless fishing (which I was hoping to extract some info about scum actually), I promise I will full claim before the end of the day. Now can we please move on and try to figure out who trent and carr's scumbuddy was? I have no other relevant info to share about that.
You managed to clear GR on N1 but you have no relevant info from N2? Ok.
avatar
blotunga: I still think that it would benefit town more if I didn't full claim. Alas to stop the needless fishing (which I was hoping to extract some info about scum actually), I promise I will full claim before the end of the day. Now can we please move on and try to figure out who trent and carr's scumbuddy was? I have no other relevant info to share about that.
This is starting to look more and more scummy to me. What difference does it make if you claim now, or claim before the end of the day? What exactly are you hoping to achieve? A mis-lynch of GameRager, which subsequently "verifies" your claim?

With two scum eliminated in the first two days, it makes sense that the remaining scum could take some risks, and this is starting to look like exactly that.