I've tried to catch up as much as I can, and I see not much has really changed. A lot has been said and the game has moved nowhere. I'm with bookwyrm, we need to vote so we can see where everyone's thoughts are at. Since my vote is missing I will stay with who I think is most likely scum.

Vote flubbucket

Joe's reasoning on flub's listing goes like this:

But his reasoning on me goes like this:

So I was wondering how flub is higher in towniness than me, considering he has something on flub but nearly nothing on me at the time (as in literally nothing being used against me). So more or less it's "how is literally nothing worse something potentially questionable?"

----

By the way dedo, I see you think I could be possible scum along with Joe and Micro. But is there anything to support me being not possible scum along these two? Like, I'd love a list on what of my play is town and what of my play is scummy. The main reason why I wasn't on blotunga's wagon is that I believed scene to be the scummiest and at the same time I thought blotunga's play looked more town-like than scummy (at least in the context of how blotunga usually plays). I stuck with GameRager because his play felt like scum playing the safest role on the table, one that is shared among town and scum, but he didn't play it well enough to prevent a mislynch.

Right now, I'm still torn between voting for scene or Micro. Scene still has his strange as heck play, while Micro still worries me. Not sure what to think of Joe, I still find his ordering of players a bit weird to be honest.

Why is Flub your most likely Scum? What differences do you note in his Scum and Town games?

bump?

bump...?

Scene - ^^^ answer Bookwyrm's question ^^^


yeah sorry it wasn't supposed to make sense. There's no reason why I should trust your bookwyrm read, and yet I find that I do. Leap of faith?


Yes, but I learned my lesson about expecting-the-things-flub-says-to-mean-something last game.

...

Hm. I've just thought it through a bit more it doesn't make sense. I thought flub might have got to 'one-shot' by using what he knows about the setup combined with the public knowledge (we have either T, TTT, or TTTTT; B; and at least another either R or D because of the failed kill last night - assuming mafia didn't decide not to kill, which is a fairly safe assumption.) Anyway I can't see a role that flub could have that would leave only one letter available for a one-shot whatever so BLAHBRAIN.

(So thinking about it, I guess if you have a power role and you didn't prevent the kill last night you should be hunting for two mafias and not a lone godfather) RXX means we can't have TTTTT.


I would support these wagons:
Trent
Flub
Microfish

I will not join these wagons:
Gogtrial
Pooka
Supplementscene
Joe

Come on let's goooooooooo!!!!

My stance from here is still what I believe. Nothing has changed my view on them.

Where is bookwyrm and dedoporno? And why would you join the Joe wagon?

Bump requested and approved.

*Why would you NOT, Joe?

You can ISO me simply enough.

Focusing on a few posts should clarify my alignment. For example...

They are UNDEFINED

I would join Joe wagon because I can picture him going "I'm not going to vote for supplementscene and gogtrial because I don't see them as scummy" and his teammates going "Trentonlf! We have a town to destroy here!"

It just occurred to me if he and supplementscene were a team, his Day One stance on Supplementscene could be a straight-up bussing attempt and his subsequent Day Two turnaround is him realising that with SirP gone supplementscene's his only remaining ally...

hm.

it's a nice narrative that I just invented. not sure I buy into it that much.

(shall we refer to Joe as Trentonlf and Joe as JoeSapphire for the time being? to avoid confujion...)


Oh. Well I'd rather lunch possible mafia.

I agree with that, and Pooka's my third in that category of "People that aren't feeling like town". Scene is in a special category of suspicion.

I can't shake the feeling that one of the 'old-guard' (survivors consist of Flub, Dedo, and Trent) are on the scum team. Joe might fall in that category, too, so one of the "less newbies", I guess. Problem is, I suspect that feeling mostly comes from the N1 kill; that kill doesn't feel like a newbie-team choice, but SPF has been around the block several times and could have been the driving force behind selecting Agent (and I'd bet it was a cross kill, where they literally killed each other). I don't know; something about SPF pushing for Agent to die doesn't feel right.

Let's walk through a scenario together, now that a/the Town RB is dead.

Pretend that we hadn't lynched GR D2, so we still don't know his alignment. He says he's going to block Scene (claimed vanilla). No kill occurs during the Night. What do you do? What do you think happened?

Hm.

My memory says it wasn't a strict cross post (like how I ninja'd ZFR on something, with both our posts saying "Posted Now"), but the time gap WAS short.

If you are doing absolutely nothing memorable, then you aren't trying to solve the game. Townies should be trying to solve the game, so not-solving is a mark of scum.

I agree somewhat.

However I'm curious how you "know" which one to Vote.