SirPrimalform: Hmmmm. This is all in character for Scene, but I'm not seeing a huge amount that looks AI to me. He tends to ask odd questions that are answered in the OP in pretty much every game.
What I saw in my skim of games #54-57 is that he
made (bad) assumptions as both town and mafia, but actually only
asked (odd) questions when town. If you have the time to look for yourself, please do so; I'd be genuinely interested to see if you come to the same conclusion, or if I'm suffering from some kind of confirmation bias after realizing Bookwyrm might be on to something.
supplementscene: So the observation I held back in Post 34 was that Trent voted for the Mod. I thought this was perhaps a way of being agreeable and non confrontational. It wasn't particularly significant and I wanted to see how his game developed
I find it interesting that after a single further post by him (#84), you now consider his game to have developed enough to share this observation.
What did you think about Microfish's mod vote in
#89?
supplementscene: Gogtrial - Now this is somewhat significant, a third vote on Day 2. Gogtrial states he knows it's a third vote.
Just so there's a record of the timeline: when I wrote my post, only Bookwyrm had voted you. I reloaded the game thread before posting, saw agentcarr's post (at 2 minutes old), pondered if that was going to affect my vote, decided not, added my final question, and posted my vote about 5 minutes after agentcarr.
supplementscene: Gogtrial doesn't vote for me after our initial interraction only after the votes move to 2. Why didn't he vote for me initially if he thought it seemed suspect?
Because my read of you based purely on our interaction was a slight town lean, mostly due to the way you structured your suspicion of me (see
#64 for me alluding to that). Bookwyrm however pointed out your attitude toward the setup, which was a perspective I hadn't considered at all (being too focused on myself, and not having had to examine your behaviour in game #55 too closely, as I already knew you were mafia). So I went to skim the first couple of pages of games
#54,
#55,
#56 and
#57, and observed different behaviour between town-you and mafia-you with regards to setup, with your current behaviour more closely matching mafia-you.
supplementscene: Trent's claiming
I'm arguing about the set up. I'm not I'm highlighting Gogtrial potentially coaching mafia players.
Trent wrote:
trentonlf: The OP clearly states the setup and how everything was determined, yet Scene is trying to put doubt out there about the setup Which I'm reading as alluding to:
supplementscene: If there's only 1 death, that likely means the serial killer either doesn't exist or has 1 night bulletrproof.
I kind of bet we have an SK though. ZFR put another faction in his last game and I bet he's done it again here. supplementscene: Which could be a mistake on my part but let's be accurate about what's being discussed.
More than one thing can be discussed. You:
- accused me of potential coaching (which trent didn't comment upon)
- seem uninterested in setup details / question mod information about the setup (which was the first of the two reasons given by trent for voting you)
- questioned why I asked Bookwyrm for his reasoning behind the vote, which trent read as "trying to accuse me" (and was the second of the two reasons given by trent for voting you).
Side question here: Was your questioning of my motivation in
#63 intended as the "accusation" that trent reads it as?
supplementscene: I'm asking why Gogtrial needs to ask other players opinions about my posts rather than forming his own.
For the record: Did my answer to that question in
#65 make sense to you? Any thoughts about it?
supplementscene: Agent looks less suspect as he only took the vote to 2. So if I get lynched on Day 1 - please look at Gogtrial, Trent, Blotunga throughout this game
You don't find agent suspicious for putting an RVS vote on you when there's already a serious vote on you?
supplementscene: the reasoning from Agent, Gogtrial, Trent, Blotunga was all sloppy and lazy.
Interesting contrast.
supplementscene: Gogtrial even said I appeared to play similarly to my Liberal game
No, I said it is dissimilar to the start of your play the last time you were mafia.
supplementscene: 2. I've made more analysis
You keep using that word...
Not cool, man. Not cool at all.
bump please?
