Well, uhh, I'm not honestly sure how to answer that. I'm smart enough to have several As and at least one A+ in every college semester, studied to the point that I felt studying more was the most pointless thing ever and yet...I find the "other kids didn't ace it!" line to ring true sometimes?

Erm, look. I'd like you to look over my interactions with bookwyrm and see if I am indeed scummy as hell or an inexperienced player as gogtrial says, since you agreed with bookwyrm about how you read me. You're saying you would have me as the second lynch if flub doesn't go through. My question is, how much is my position in your possible scumteam based on YOUR own reads and not Wyrm's? If you saw the interactions I mentioned, does it change how you see me there?

This is important in helping me take a stance on the second mafioso.

No.

Well, I've been distracted with bookwyrm in-game (and I do want to address one of dedo's posts but I am tired and almost sleepy now.

flub is certain for me. Hard to read. First votes bookwyrm and then insists to keep his vote on him for a reason before suddenly changing his tunes to agreeing with wyrm about me being scum, unvoting him.

The other is a tie between dedo and bookwyrm. dedo's leaning to lynch me as the alternate choice instead of the main, but, from at this point in time, I'm not seeing any hints that he formed an opinion from my interactions with bookwyrm. bookwyrm on the other hand is focusing his lasers on me and has me as top suspect.

I'd say for now, my most likely scumteam is flub and Bookwyrm. Dedo's response to my above question could change things, but from where I'm seeing it now, this is the most likely lineup. Willing to lynch flub more than bookwyrm though.
---

Also, I'll steal a page from Bookwyrm's.........book, and I'll say that the time for actions is upon us. 25 hours before the day closes. Time to settle on a consensus. I've already reached mine, and I'll stand by it.

VOTE FLUBBUCKET

(Also @Bookwyrm, I'll respond to your post tomorrow when I am less tired).

Okay, yeah, I'm starting to see the Pooka thing now.

Also, no reads lists from Pooka on D3. Last time was the #595 I mentioned before.

No. Previous game I played was Mafia #55 - Trouble at Arstotzkan Boot Camp, which also had ZFR as mod (the C9++ with a twist game). Back then I was tragic lovers with Joe, with our own win condition. We successfully fooled town into believing us Town Siblings, so the "big bro" thing is carried over flavour from that.

Sorry for making it all even more confusing for you.
After Bookwyrm made his post, there were three people up for lynching Pooka: Bookwyrm, flub and dedo. If Pooka is town, and I'm mafia, I could've easily gone along with Bookwyrm's reasoning, for an easy win.
So, you only have to worry about the scenario where both me and Pooka are mafia. Neither Bookwyrm nor dedo is seeing that, which should tell you a lot. Also Pooka's examination of the interaction between me and scene (which I was townreading him so hard on) doesn't make sense if he knows that I'm his mafia buddy but has never played with me. So I'm not on a team with Pooka, so I'm not mafia.

Don't townread anyone because of that. (I know Bookwyrm also got me, but it was mostly dedo not buying my theory which allowed me to be swayed.)

"him" book, or "him" pooka?

Q. "him" book, or "him" pooka?
A. Him=flub it was in the untitled flub paragraph

@micro: I'm realizing you would not necessarily be the target tonight. If you're judged to be more easily swayed into voting town than someone else, then that someone else would make more sense as the night kill.
So, in case that's me, and assuming there is a tomorrow, my current percentages are:
flub + pooka: 50% (yes, I went from 3% to 50% based on a single thing. yes, I suck at this game)
bookwyrm + flub: 35%
bookwyrm + dedo: 10%
flub + dedo: 5%
but my thoughts are still bouncing around like crazy, so, erm, make up your own mind.

Vote Count

flub 2 - Micro, Pooka

6 players, takes 4 to lynch.

I'm still up for some reason, but...why the massive jump now? Because of what you quoted saying that I didn't find flub to be a noteworthy lynch? Well, that was back in D2, and what have we got there?

- blotunga was lynched instead of the more questionable scene
- GameRager claimed roleblocker and appeared to not offer much in the way of proving he's tow + his vote on Joe.

By then, I thought of the Joe and flub wagons as less concerning than flub is on Day 4. I admit that I was tunnelling on GameRager and scene, but when I gave flub the time of day with a proper ISO, I could see why he received that heat earlier. I just can't see how I went from 3% to 50% for that.

I also wonder somewhat, but I think part of it, Pooka, is due to Book's very incriminating read on you, and when gogtrial read it from that perspective, he saw you (from t!Book's perspective) as scum. I don't totally see it myself, but the only one I trust is myself, and to a lesser extent one of Book & Gogtrial.

There's 6 of us, and 2 are bad boys. I think I can safely clear the mod & backup mod at this point.

@ZFR question for post-game--are team rosters also compiled via random.org, or handpicked for your enjoyment? Please don't answer now.

LOL, I suspect I might, and--if you are town--apologize in advance.

PLEASE give your list as of this moment for "most to least scummiest"

No need for apologies ever. It's just a game and I don't get too caught up in win/lose.

Regarding most to least:

I said something about something here.

And I find you and I least scummy.

The other two are in the middle.

Last thing before I'm off to work......who will get the label of "crucial contribution" on my wagon??

I appreciate that. :D

Ok, thank you. I wasn't sure if anything had changed in the last few hours.

Not I, I'm already there...but maybe you can be the judge?

HAPPY 4TH OF JULY, EVERYONE!
(of course, you probably don't care if you aren't american, but have a good day anyway. :D )

a messed-up flag attempt was here

MURICAN BUMP

Fixed now, I hope. Thanks, Pooka!

it wasn't, thus was deleted with ZFR permission.