FIRST

I was right all along.....and then changed my late pick to Muddysneakers after he said he knew Cristi was Town and was 50-50 on the other 2 players. @Muddy it sounded a little scummy and everyone was saying Bler would not have pulled off this audacious move off pretending to want to sub out.

I'm still surprised no one asked questions about Bler earlier. The statement that Lift asked if Bler would stay in the game if I was night killed didn't seem like something Lift would do imo. There looked to be buddying going on with Cristi. Bler left my wagon way too soon if he really thought I was scum. Bler didn't want to be investigated alongside me despite him thinking I was Scum. Bler wasn't on either Scum Wagon either.

Well played Flub, I noted all of the above, I noted that Agent suggested double lynching Muddy and Ixam and I still saw Muddy as the final Scum member. The statement by Agent made it very unlikely Muddy was scum.

@Bler well played, I assumed the subyou defined the narrative throughout and managed to get almost confirmed town off our early encounter. You bussed Agent in a way starting the narrative of his wolfyness. Do you regret not being on your buddies wagon?

@Ixam I actually bought your claim over P1NA

@Agent, can you reveal why you self hammered?

I really don't think parity cop helped much in a 3 faction game

Maybe majority, but with no double lynch. In case of a 2-way tie you could:
_Decide randomly.
_Make a random rock-papers-scissors diagram of all players that is known pre-game. (like http://www.umop.com/rps.htm). So in case of a 2-way tie it is known in advance who gets picked.

Also, thanks for hosting, Lift. Good game, everyone.

EDIT 2: Very nice game, muddy.

Thank you so much for hosting. I had fun.

I think I like the "Phase 2" thingy. It could possibly be tweaked or used as is depending on the game.

Well done town, nice to have you join the winner. :D

Well played flub, I've been suspecting you of being the bentau for the last couple of Days. I'm not in the slightest bit surprised bler was scum, there was something off about how readily he accepted Ixam's claim.
Ahem...








Thanks for the good game!

Just been reading the scumchat and had a good laugh when I saw Bler pondering whether to NK me on D3 after I'd left the game.

Have I missed something here? In what sense did the mafia need neutrals alive to win?

Yes thank you Lift for organising and administrating the game. I do think the balance was actually weighted to Mafia with their only been 7 Town players and only 2 roles, 1 of them being parity cop not that useful in this set up. It seemed to undergun Town as a team imo. If the Neutral Lyncher targeted Town it definitely would of been unbalanced

The turning point of the game seemed to be Ixam's claim. I must have been the only person who bought it.

I suppose Neutrals are going to be less aggressive at Scum Hunting. That's all I can think of.

When I wasn't looking for angles to get Ixam lynched, I was scum hunting at my usual town level (which isn't great). But yeah, I guess that can't be assumed. Still, that's not exactly a "need" for mafia.

Huh we won despite me. I guess I'm pretty surprised agent followed bler so closely so often. Made me think they couldn't both be scum.

Don't sell yourself short, you guessed Flub was bentau and in voting for him allowed him to self hammer!

bler, reading over the scum chat I guess I don't understand why cristi last night? I was quite inclined to believe you over cristi and it sounded like she was too.

flubb, at what point did you stop suspecting me?

No Town player can ever 'know' who Scum is. I also felt it unlikely initially that they would follow each others wagons initially. They had both been on the most town wagons though. And as someone who's played a Scum role I know the temptation to get on and start misslynch wagons and then happily jump off them mid day to another misslynch wagon.

Also SPF and myself got P1nas last night read, that Flub was 'same' and also town, so we knew it wasn't Flub and he's the hardest player to read for me.

You did well drilling down on Agent

You also did well in the debate with Ixam by stating you weren't neutral and seemingly very town. Although because P1na was inconsistent I bought Ixam's claim. The rest of the team didn't because you played it well.

Bler did well reading Flubb as vengeful neutral so I'm also surprised he didn't take him out to increase his win likelyhood.

I don't think he did read him as that because there wasn't one in this game and the OP made that pretty clear. :P

Yeah, I knew he read him as bentau, I was just correcting the neutral bit.

Paranoid vengeful survivor would be a fun role, a little chance to take revenge for having your wincon blown up. :P

thank you, thank you.



Ohbuggerit. I forgot you don't quote your own posts in the same way. I just deleted most of post 104.