It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #56 - The Witches of Salem(770 posts)(770 posts)
(770 posts)
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
41
42
43
44
45
52
This is my favourite topic
Posted November 24, 2018
Lifthrasil, can we have another vote count please?

avatar
Ixamyakxim: Lucky guess? Why leave out that he's scumbuddies with Muddy and copped you? He already mentioned that he "parity copped" you - maybe he just tacked on the parity. I still find that it makes ZERO sense that he supposedly had a "different" read on you Yesterday, and yet didn't vote to lynch you. He made up a reason to vote HSL.

I don't get why people don't see that as something a real town parity cop would never do.
Uhhh, looking at the PMs in the first post, the scum have a Vanilla Cop. From the description it sounds like they get one result for vanilla town and the other for anything else. So your theory is that I was vanilla copped by the scum and based on the "interesting" result they decided they were certain enough I was neutral and not a town power to risk a fake CC? Think how easily that could have blown up in their faces.

And I'm not sure what the motivation would have been. To save muddy? Better to lose one member of the scum team and bus them than to live and expose yourselves. If we lynched you and you flipped parity cop then we'd know both of them were lying.
To get you killed? Makes more sense to NK than to push for your lynch with lying.

Sorry, I don't believe you. I had reservations about your claim already, P1na's is (to me) pretty rock solid.
Posted November 24, 2018
avatar
SirPrimalform: Hmm, I thought there'd be more activity by now. Oh well, suits me as I overslept.

avatar
flubbucket: What about working toward a three-way-lynch and let ZFR's RNG make the choice?? .............just sayin'
avatar
SirPrimalform: That's a horrible idea. 3 way random chance strikes me as worse than making an educated guess. At least with a double lynch you know what you're getting. As far as I'm concerned there's no need for a double lynch now, P1na's claim is pretty much verified (to me) by his knowledge about me.
Yes. That would be bad. And as we discuss it more I think we're coming to the conclusion that double lynch would never work for town.
Posted November 24, 2018
@ SPF, who do you like tomorrow?

@ cristi, what do you think about agent as lyncher? with flubb or maybe Ixam as possible target? voting Ixam and leaving before the counter claim is a little suspicious to me.
Posted November 24, 2018
avatar
muddysneakers: @ SPF, who do you like tomorrow?
My prediction is if we lynch Ixam he'll flip scum. I would then look at the reactions to Ixam's claim, particularly those who accepted it without question. Off the top of my head, Bler seemed pretty easily sold on Ixam's claim.
Posted November 24, 2018
Arg, computer froze as I was typing. I got to leave.

I actually want to vote agent, but no time to pursue that.

@muddy - that is possible about agent, but haven't thought about the implications or if it fits

Ixam has denied being neutral so my theory is already full of holes (if Ixam is not lying) .

If SPF saw my question, I don't like that he has not responded. Although, I tend to believe the claim. Unless P1na and he are working together.

We need to clear up who is lying about the PC. That means lynching either P1na or Ixam.

@flubb - nope, not a fan of leaving the lynch to chance

@Ixam - I am sorry if I am wrong about this

Vote Ixam

I will try to check in on phone when I stop for a dog pit stop in a few hours if the day is still going.

Would love to be able to read flub and bler's stance then.
Posted November 24, 2018
avatar
muddysneakers: @ SPF, who do you like tomorrow?
avatar
SirPrimalform: My prediction is if we lynch Ixam he'll flip scum. I would then look at the reactions to Ixam's claim, particularly those who accepted it without question. Off the top of my head, Bler seemed pretty easily sold on Ixam's claim.
Yes I'm thinking that his play was less win game now (if 3 mafia) and more sacrifice myself to draw out the cop and keep my buddy in deep cover. I think bler and flubb are options and you and agent less so now.

@ cristi did you consider that SPF could be neutral and bler scum? Other possibilities SPF neutral bler town, SPF scum and bler town, or SPF scum and bler neutral. You seem pretty sure bler is town here.
Posted November 24, 2018
Well, not much movement indeed. I guess I'll just move my vote as promised and bow out. It's been an honor, people. May you find the evil witches.

unvote SPF

vote ixam
Posted November 24, 2018
avatar
cristigale: If SPF saw my question, I don't like that he has not responded. Although, I tend to believe the claim. Unless P1na and he are working together.
Hmm? I'll have a look for it.

avatar
P1na: Well, not much movement indeed. I guess I'll just move my vote as promised and bow out. It's been an honor, people. May you find the evil witches.

unvote SPF

vote ixam
I think that's hammer?
Posted November 24, 2018
avatar
cristigale: @SPF - are you plain survivor or lyncher/survivor?
The latter.
Posted November 24, 2018
avatar
cristigale: @SPF - are you plain survivor or lyncher/survivor?
avatar
SirPrimalform: The latter.
Is it bad form to keep posting after the hammer but before mod says to stop posting?
Posted November 24, 2018
avatar
muddysneakers: Is it bad form to keep posting after the hammer but before mod says to stop posting?
Not in this community. Certainly it's fine before the hammer is acknowledged and most mods will include a note in the final votecount to the effect of "It is now twilight, you may continue posting until the lynch scene is posted".
Posted November 24, 2018
avatar
cristigale: @SPF - are you plain survivor or lyncher/survivor?
avatar
SirPrimalform: The latter.
Who is/was your target?
Posted November 24, 2018
avatar
SirPrimalform: The latter.
avatar
muddysneakers: Who is/was your target?
It's not really in my interest to claim that. I guess if pressured to then I might, but otherwise I see no reason to tell.
Posted November 24, 2018
avatar
muddysneakers: Who is/was your target?
avatar
SirPrimalform: It's not really in my interest to claim that. I guess if pressured to then I might, but otherwise I see no reason to tell.
Then you'll understand my skepticism of the claim going forward. Especially if you get another 48hrs to prepare an answer.
Posted November 24, 2018
avatar
SirPrimalform: .................
Uhhh, looking at the PMs in the first post, the scum have a Vanilla Cop.

................
This is not a fact, merely a possibility.

No where did the mod confirm all roles listed are in this game.
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
41
42
43
44
45
52
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #56 - The Witches of Salem(770 posts)(770 posts)
(770 posts)