It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #55 - Trouble at Arstotzkan Boot Camp(1211 posts)(1211 posts)
(1211 posts)
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
50
56
57
58
59
60
70
81
This is my favourite topic
Posted October 03, 2018
avatar
Bookwyrm627: The new page bug replaced some variation of " Ixam" with "..."? That would be a new and exciting bug for the gog forums. :P
Someone said it does? :-)

In fact I intended to vote someone else entirely and the forum realised how stupid it is and bleeped my vote out by itself.


No, I just couldn't see that post and subsequent ones and post again for a short while.
Posted October 03, 2018
Joe just asked me to pass on his apologies, he can't get a computer today or tonight (at least one he's allowed to play mafia on).
Posted October 03, 2018
avatar
Vitek: Quick look over Trent's and HSL's posts shows they had decent amount of interactions, mostly initiated by HSL, but barely any confrontation.

HSL interaction were mentioned in the past (him appearing to coach him or giving him outings).
Trent was 3rd vote (2nd serious) on scene D1 for scene voting Poppy just to lynch someone else than him but also then unvoted at the EoD and appeared to not be aware of scene false claiming.
On D2 his interaction with scene look quite standard and not really interesting in any way (maybe with the exception of "I am voting the same way as mchack but mchack is scummy for his reasoning").

So, based on this could these 3 be item? Yeah, but I don't see so much that would make it that more likely than other combination. Maybe.
At the EoD you, me, dedo, Mchack, and HSL all thought scene’s claim could have been legitimate. For me I went back over everything scene had done during Day 1 and came to the conclusion that he must have been lying because I couldn’t see a Townie acting the way he did on Day 1. I based nothing off of PM information, I find that scummy to do. I now see why Mchack went with PM information, but at the time I didn’t know and found his reasoning to be scummy so I voted him.


@sirprimalform, what makes you so sure HSL is scum and not one of me, bookwyrm, Vitek, or gogtrial and Joe?
Posted October 03, 2018
avatar
Bookwyrm627: The new page bug replaced some variation of " Ixam" with "..."? That would be a new and exciting bug for the gog forums. :P
avatar
Vitek: Someone said it does? :-)

In fact I intended to vote someone else entirely and the forum realised how stupid it is and bleeped my vote out by itself.

No, I just couldn't see that post and subsequent ones and post again for a short while.
I'm (mostly) not complaining about you voting for the lynchee after the lynch was achieved. Even if you did do it twice in a row.

I just don't quite understand how you messed up that EOD vote on Ixam. You had to have written the post, including the part of it that says "Vote..." before the new page bug could ever get a shot at it. This means that you messed up the name.

In other news, who did you originally intend to vote in that post?

avatar
trentonlf: @sirprimalform, what makes you so sure HSL is scum and not one of me, bookwyrm, Vitek, or gogtrial and Joe?
That feels like an odd question.
Posted October 03, 2018
avatar
trentonlf: @sirprimalform, what makes you so sure HSL is scum and not one of me, bookwyrm, Vitek, or gogtrial and Joe?
Well I'm fairly certain I laid it out yesterday, but I understand if seeing another post of mine with quotes from HSL made your eyes glaze over.
Well if Joe is scum then so is gogtrial and vice versa. But out of the rest of you, who's to say I don't think any of your are mafia? My near certainty about HSL doesn't mean I'm townreading everyone else.

I agree with bookwyrm, it's a weird question.
Posted October 03, 2018
avatar
Vitek: Someone said it does? :-)

In fact I intended to vote someone else entirely and the forum realised how stupid it is and bleeped my vote out by itself.

No, I just couldn't see that post and subsequent ones and post again for a short while.
avatar
Bookwyrm627: I'm (mostly) not complaining about you voting for the lynchee after the lynch was achieved. Even if you did do it twice in a row.

I just don't quite understand how you messed up that EOD vote on Ixam. You had to have written the post, including the part of it that says "Vote..." before the new page bug could ever get a shot at it. This means that you messed up the name.

In other news, who did you originally intend to vote in that post?

avatar
trentonlf: @sirprimalform, what makes you so sure HSL is scum and not one of me, bookwyrm, Vitek, or gogtrial and Joe?
avatar
Bookwyrm627: That feels like an odd question.
Sontimes a question is more than just a question, I was looking to see how he answered.
Posted October 03, 2018
avatar
Bookwyrm627: I just don't quite understand how you messed up that EOD vote on Ixam. You had to have written the post, including the part of it that says "Vote..." before the new page bug could ever get a shot at it. This means that you messed up the name.

In other news, who did you originally intend to vote in that post?
What?
No.
I was joking.
Of course I intended to vote Number 9 (IX) and not someone else.
I put the "..." there myself to draw that out for fun. I even said it there that I like it tense. ;-)
I intended to vote in the following post and I did, only I was several seconds too late. And that's it. Thrilling story.
Posted October 03, 2018
avatar
trentonlf: Sontimes a question is more than just a question,
It's a cigar?

avatar
trentonlf: I was looking to see how he answered.
Aww.
Posted October 03, 2018
avatar
Vitek: Don't you realise how much effort it takes to not post again?!
Yes.

Can you explain why you've voted after the lynch twice and therefore you've never been on a lynch yet??
Posted October 03, 2018
Vote count:

HSL - 1: SPF

Not voting - 7: Bookwyrm, flub, gogtrial, HSL, Joe, trent, Vitek

8 players. Takes 5 to lynch.
Posted October 03, 2018
avatar
flubbucket: Yes.

Can you explain why you've voted after the lynch twice and therefore you've never been on a lynch yet??
Geez, I don't know if I'll be able to say a single word about it. It's really touchy subject and I am shy to answer.
Or just look at what I replied to BW.

avatar
SirPrimalform: Well if Joe is scum then so is gogtrial and vice versa. But out of the rest of you, who's to say I don't think any of your are mafia? My near certainty about HSL doesn't mean I'm townreading everyone else.
So you now read Joe and trial as more as town if you think HSL is scum?
And do you have an idea for HSL buddy or not? I don't necessary need to know right now, just wonder if you tried to make out the team or not.
Posted October 03, 2018
avatar
Vitek: So you now read Joe and trial as more as town if you think HSL is scum?
And do you have an idea for HSL buddy or not? I don't necessary need to know right now, just wonder if you tried to make out the team or not.
Well the two possibilities are mutually exclusive as far as I can see. The largest number of remaining mafia we can have is 2 as far as I'm aware, so if HSL is mafia then Joegtrial must be town.
Assuming Joegtrial town for a moment, then yes there are some people I feel more likely to be scum but if you don't want to know right now I guess I'll keep it to myself.
On the other hand, if Joegtrial are mafia then I congratulate them on a ballsy play, but if that's the case we may be able to expose them by figuring out the remaining letters when people flip.
Posted October 03, 2018
avatar
Vitek: .........<snip>..........
So... claim perhaps?
Yes.

I'm the Innocent Child. I'm the Serial Killer.
Posted October 03, 2018
avatar
Vitek: .............
So you now read Joe and trial as more as town if you think HSL is scum?
.............
For the record, I'm not buying the lover thing one little bit.

Why would scum kill one when they could have killed two??
Posted October 03, 2018
Here's the Trifecta!

Vote: gogtrial34987
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
50
56
57
58
59
60
70
81
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #55 - Trouble at Arstotzkan Boot Camp(1211 posts)(1211 posts)
(1211 posts)