No, I haven't read most of the last page or so. However, if any role sees a claim that matches their role, a claim that goes on to say "This is my exact pm", I'd expect that claim to maybe, possibly think "huh. No mention of the limitations I've got. Might be a false claim".

I'm not even talking about matching wording and spelling here, I'm talking about simple description of the role's abilities.

yes. or better yet (because money is needed for internet and kids and so on): if you're away at work EoD, don't even try to follow on your phone. you'll only make matters worse. just don't be around EoD when at work.
Which is exactly how I'll handle it in the future. I won't try and skim on a phone while working, I'll just either be there or not be there around Lynchtime.

Today I'm available all day though :D

---

noone said "this is my exact pm", by the time I posted #334 (which was also when I stopped following the thread until I got home long after deadline) and I know that If I had the time to think and look things up, I would've hammered him, but all I saw was, he claimed doctor. It's possible that it's true. I can protect him at night, he's not lost yet. -> posted and resumed my work.

While I believe you were probably mostly skimming, had work, etc (the RL stuff), I still don't believe you about your claim or your reaction to Scene's claim. It just doesn't gel for me.

Time to wait and see where the rest of these folks finally decide to vote. Hopefully they lynch you.

Come on, rest of you guys! Lynch Mchack!
"Sin Bravely!"
"No Fear!
"Just Do It!"

Interesting. While you were all about letting scene self-resolve yesterday and lynch someone else. Now you don't want to risk it? Now you are 100% sure and rallying everyone to mis-lynch the doctor, knowing full well that I'll be nk tonight, because unlike scene I'm not scum false-claiming but a real doctor.

Just so you can use the nk tonight on someone else and not risk having scum lynched today. How can you be so obviously scummy?

Assuming you are Town what reason do you have to lynch me now? if I tell the truth, I'll be dead by tomorrow anyway and scum can't nk anyone else. If they do nk someone else there's the even chance that I'll protect that person. but if I were scum then I'd "self-resolve" anyway tomorrow. Why the change in perspective now?

Seeing as we don’t want a Chinese fire drill it looks like either Mchack or Joe today, what are your thoughts on Joe?

it's 3:3 right now, between me and Joe.
What are your own thoughts on Joe? (now that bookwyrm went hiding after assaulting me and seems not to answer)

oh: Hi flub. What are your thoughts on Joe?

It sounds genuine and him protecting you sounds plausible as he townread you throughout D1.
Then as I said, it would be fairly good fakeclaim, there is what Joe mentioned about him not having trouble with scene's claim and also that I am horrible at judging claims as I showed here as well.

So... not sure, but gut tells my it is real.



Does anyone have bad dreams at night?

When I ISO'd Joe I got a meh reading on him. I have trouble reading him because of all the joking he does. Joking is an easy way for scum to hide, I mean who wants to kill the person that's bringing some laughter and smiles to the game. But from what I remember seeing in the other game he played was he joked a lot in that one too as town.

So if I try to ignore the joking Joe does not have much substance to his play other than his focus on Vitek.


I'm unsure how to take his claim as well, although there's been no counter claim and I would think if there was another doctor still out there they would know if mchack was lying and say something, but there is no guarantee of another doctor. Are you talking bad dreams in game or in real life?

So then are you considering hopping over to his train and maybe have him talk a bit more about himself?
A decision about who to lynch of the two of us has to be made tonight and while I've gone full monty already and have told everything there is to be said about game-me, the same has not been true for Joe at all.
So not a good base to make a judgement call yet (like bookwyrm wants), is it?

--- Time marker for re-reads:
6 hours until deadline.
5 hours after mchack claimed.

both Joe and mchack are currently at L-3

Will we see more interest in Joe for the coming 5 hours or will we see nothing until it's too late and then town just lynches their doctor? Stay tuned to find out.
----

Vote Count

mchack - 3: Ixam, flubbucket, Bookwyrm
JoeSapphire - 3: Vitek, HSL, mchack
HypersomniacLive - 1: SPF
Vitek - 1: Joe

Not voting - 1: gogtrial, trent

10 players. 6 to lynch

So do you believe machack’s claim now, why not before? Who on your wagon do you think is scum and why?


Has your opinion of HSL changed? I’m just wondering why you jumped onto a wagon of someone you had not mentioned before and was being pushed by someone you considered scum. Who on your wagon do you consider scum and why?

Is there someone you'd pick to lynch if mchack was off the table?